Loading...
PZC Packet 0620171 Agenda posted on Friday, June 16, 2017 at the following public places within the Town of Avon: -Avon Municipal Building, Avon Recreation Center, Avon Public Library, Town of Avon Website www.avon.org Please call 970-748-4023 for questions. Planning & Zoning Commission Meeting Agenda Tuesday, June 20, 2017 One Lake Street If you require special accommodation please contact us in advance and we will assist you. You may call David McWilliams at 970-748-4023 or email cmcwilliams@avon.org with any special requests I. Call to Order – 5:00pm II. Roll Call III. Appointment of Chairperson and Vice Chairperson IV. Additions & Amendments to the Agenda V. Conflicts of Interest VI. Consent Agenda VII. Sign Program Amendment – 150 East Beaver Creek Boulevard – CONTINUED FROM JUNE 6, 2017 File: SGN17004 Legal Description: Lot 24, Block 2, Benchmark at Beaver Creek Applicant: Chad Wilkison Summary: Proposal for an updated Sign Program to allow more flexibility in design at the Avon Plaza. VIII. Work Sessions A. Seventen Lofts Summary: Review of updated plans for a new fifteen (15) unit condominium project at 710 Nottingham Road. The project was last reviewed by PZC in July 2015. B. Garage AEC Summary: Cursory review of an Alternative Equivalent Compliance (AEC) application related to a garage addition and relief to Section 7.28.090(i)(2), Single-Family and Duplex Garages, and Section 7.28.090(c)(4)(ii), Roof Overhangs, Avon Development Code. B. Landscaping Code Text Amendment Summary: Staff seeks direction for potential changes to Section 7.28.050, Landscaping, Avon Development. IX. Minor Development Plan – Landscaping Modifications File: MNR17021 Legal Description: Lot 7 Western Sage Subdivision Applicant: Buz Reynolds Summary: Proposal to modify planted tree location, and retaining wall design (as constructed). 2 Agenda posted on Friday, June 16, 2017 at the following public places within the Town of Avon: -Avon Municipal Building, Avon Recreation Center, Avon Public Library, Town of Avon Website www.avon.org Please call 970-748-4023 for questions. X. Approval of Meeting Minutes  June 6, 2017 Meeting Minutes XI. Approval of Record of Decision  MNR17017 – Beaver Creek Blvd Streetscape XII. Staff Approvals  MNR17019 – Minor Development Plan for 10 Stonebridge Drive. Summary: Eaglebend Apartments approval to modify exterior materials/colors to twenty (20) apartment buildings.  MNR17018- Minor Development Plan for 4274 Wildridge Road West. Summary: Deck addition with stairs. XIII. Adjourn June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Avon Plaza, Lot 24 Benchmark at Beaver Creek Subdivision Page | 1 Staff Report – Sign Program Amendment and Minor Development Application Continued from June 6, 2017 Meeting Date: Project Name: June 20, 2017 SGN17004 Zoning: Shopping Center Address: 150 East Beaver Creek Boulevard Location: Prepared By: Lot 24 Block 2 Benchmark at Beaver Creek David McWilliams, Town Planner Staff Report Overview This staff report contains one application for consideration by the PZC:  SGN17004: Sign Program Amendment for Avon Plaza. This application seeks approval for a new Sign Program that allows greater flexibility in color choice, design, and materials. Summary Chad Wilkison (the Applicant) is presenting a Sign Program Amendment proposal for the Avon Plaza that has been updated since the June 6, 2017 PZC meeting. During the last meeting, the PZC expressed interest in a modified application that:  Was more encompassing of the entire site, including the second floor  Had fewer typos  Included provisions for temporary signs  Explored the feasibility of “gooseneck” exterior lighting  Eliminated the addition of a tenant sign for unit B-106A Since that time, the application addressed the first three interests, and did not fundamentally change direction for the last two. For these points, the applicant and HOA representatives presented an email statement (Exhibit D) reaffirming their commitment to interior lit cabinets and the inclusion of a new tenant sign. The new sign application is included as Exhibit A (text) and B (elevation exhibits). The original Sign Program is included as Exhibit C. Amended Sign Program As before, the amended Sign Program generally maintains the same size and location of signs from the original Sign Program. This includes one tenant sign for every location, and larger allotments for spaces with more floor area. The original program required tenants to have green pan channel letters, and sign lettering entirely contained within the designated background area. The new program provides cabinets for tenant signs at the same square footage of the designated background area. It allows more “breaking” of the allotted background, but stipulates that the square footage for each sign will be the same (see Exhibit B, page 9 for an example). Also, the new program allows the fonts and colors to be at the discretion of the tenant, subject to HOA approval. These rules now evenly apply to the first and second floor. The email statement from Chris Neuswanger lists a few reasons for the continued inclusion of the back-lit signs.  Difficulty of snow removal in the winter with the extended lights.  Interest in maintaining reasonable harmony as the new plan signs replace the old plan signs. The continued inclusion of back-lit signs is supported by staff to preserve harmony during the transition. June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Avon Plaza, Lot 24 Benchmark at Beaver Creek Subdivision Page | 2 The new Program continues to propose an additional sign to unit B-106A on the rear of the building, roughly facing City Market, seen in Exhibit B, page 1. The sign is proposed to be a maximum of 25 s.f. Reasons stated for including this addition are:  The walkway connecting ANB Bank with this property already is an attractive pedestrian corridor for many users, and the added sign would enhance this while not overwhelming the Bank with new trespassers. The HOA president has stated that a conversation with an ANB representative did not result in any immediate rejection of the notion.  The tree in front of the unit prohibits adequate visibility of the currently approved sign.  The unit already has window frontage on this side, and a sign would naturally fit. PZC should carefully weigh if this inclusion is merited, given the position on the building with no direct street frontage. If the PZC choses to incorporate a new sign into the sign program, perhaps a sign geared to pedestrians and not automobiles is more appropriate in this location. Review Criteria According to the AMC, the Planning and Zoning Commission shall consider the following items in reviewing proposed designs: a. Sign programs shall be compatible with the site and building, and should provide for a similarity of types, sizes, styles and materials for signs within a project. Several alternatives for signage should be included in the program so as not to be so restrictive as to eliminate individuality. b. Sign programs may be proposed or changed only by the owners of the building or the owners' association. Sign program changes or proposals may not be made by an individual business. c. Proposed signs, not in accordance with an approved sign program, will only be considered by the Planning and Zoning Commission upon receipt of written evidence that the proposed sign is acceptable to the owners of the building or the owners' association. d. All sign programs shall be in written and plan form. Plans shall indicate size, location, type and number of signs for the site and buildings. e. Programs may include limitations on wording, colors, design, lighting, materials and other restrictions, and deemed appropriate by the applicant. Staff Response: The Sign Program is cleaned up, compatible with the site and building, and provides for more alternative design ty pes than the original Program. The Program provides flexibility and harmony between tenants and during implementation. Page 10 of Exhibit B shows a good demonstration of what the two programs might look like during the transition. The written and plan form of the Program meet the Sign Code standards. Recommended Motion: “I move to Approve Case #SGN17004, a Sign Program Amendment application with the findings as recommended by staff.” Finding:  The Application was reviewed in conformance with Section 15.28, Sign Code, and found to be in conformance with the design review criteria outlined in Section 15.28.070, Avon Municipal Code. Exhibits A. Sign Program (Proposed) June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting Avon Plaza, Lot 24 Benchmark at Beaver Creek Subdivision Page | 3 B. Sign Program Exhibits (Proposed) C. Sign Program (Existing) D. Response from Chris Neuswanger 2 COMPREHENSIVE SIGN PROGRAM AVON PLAZA BUILDING EAST BEAVER CREEK BLVD. AVON, COLORADO SEPTEMBER 1996 AMENDMENT 2017 THE AVON PLAZA BUILDING WILL CONSIST OF A BUILDING HAVING A MIXED USE OF RETAIL AND COMMERCIAL TENANTS. THE INTENT IS TO PROVIDE A POSITIVE DEVELOPMENT TO THE COMMERCIAL CORE OF AVON. IN KEEPING WITH THIS GOAL, ALL DESIGNS, MATERIALS, WORKMANSHIP, AND MAINTENANCE WILL BE OF A FIRST CLASS NATURE. IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS INTENT THE COMPREHENSIVE SIGN PROGRAM SHALL: I. IDENTIFY THE DEVELOPMENT FROM ADJACENT STREETS TO VEHICLAR TRAFFIC. 2. IDENTIFY FIRST FLOOR TENANTS AND SERVICES. 3. IDENTIFY MAJOR SECOND FLOOR TENANTS. 4. IDENTIFY TO PEDESTRIANS AND VEHICLUAR TRAFFIC THE BUILDING ENTRANCES AND PARKING LOCATIONS. A. GENERAL REQUIREMENTS: I. ALL TENANTS AND OWNERS WILL SUBMIT TO THE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION DRAWINGS AND SPECIFICATIONS FOR ALL PROPOSED SIGNAGE. WRITTEN APPROVAL IS NEEDED PRIOR TO SUBMISSION TO THE TOWN OF AVON. 2. ALL IMPROVEMENTS WILL BE MAINTAINED BY THE CONDOMINIUM OWNER, AND UPON VACATING BY A TENANT, THE EXISTING SIGNAGE WILL BE REMOVED AND ALL HOLES AND DISCOLORATION WILL BE PROMPTLY AND PROFESSIONALLYREPAIRED, (BY THE CONDOMINIUM OWNER). THE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION WILL HAVE THE RIGHT TO PERFORM SUCH WORK, IF NOT DONE BY THE CONDOMINIUM OWNER IN A TIMELY OR PROFESSIONAL MANNER, AND LIEN THE PROPERTY FOR ALL COSTS INCURRED. B. SIGNAGE SPECIFICATION I. BUILDING IDENTIFCATION THE BUILDING IDENTIFICATION LOCATIONS ARE SIGN LOCATIONS A & B ON THE TWO SIDES OF THE EAST TOWER ON BUILDING A. THESE SIGNS SHALL CONSIST OF INTERNALLY ILLUMINATED REVERSE PAN CHANNEL LETTERS, STUD MOUNTED, AS SHOWN IN EXHIBITS 4 & 5. ALL FACES ARE TO BE TERRA-COATA IN COLOR, SIMILAR TO THE ROOF COLOR, PMS # 167. SIGN SIZE AREAS ARE INDICATED IN EXHIBIT 2. THE BUILDING NAME MAY INCORPORATE THAT OF AN ANCHOR TENANT. 3 2. FIRST FLOOR TENANT SIGNAGE Italic copy = Delete below see amend to: TENANT IDENTIFICATION WILL BE IN THE AREAS INDICATED ON EXHIBITS 4, 5, 6 & 7. THESE SIGNS WILL BE PAN CHANNEL LETTERS, FACES PAINTED GREEN, SIMILAR TO PMS 3435C, TRIM & RETURNS WILL BE PAINTED ANODIZED BRONZE, AND THE SIGNS MAY CONSIST OF TEXT AND LOGOS, WITH THE LOGOS COMPRISING A MAXIMUM OF 35% OF THE ACTUAL SIGNAGE. MAXIMUM OVERALL HEIGHT SHALL BE 26", AND MAXIMUM LENGTH SHALL BE 60% OF THE SPACE FRONTAGE. (SEE EXHIBIT 1). MAXIMUM LETTER HEIGHT FOR A SINGLE LINE OF TYPE SHALL BE 20". A MAXIMUM OF TWO LINES OF COPY SHALL BE ALLOWED, IN WHICH CASE A MINIMUM HEIGHT SHALL BE 8", AND A MAXIMUM SHALL BE 16" PER LINE, NOT TO EXCEED 26" IN TOTAL HEIGHT. THE LOGO HEIGHT MAY BE 26". THE TEXT PORTION MAY CONSIST OF A BUSINESS NAME AND THE NATURE OF THE BUSINESS. THE BUSINESS NAME SHALL BE 50% OF THE SIGN SQUARE FOOTAGE, OR GREATER. THE NATURE OF THE BUSINESS PORTION MAY BE ILLUMINATED, OR NOT, AT THE OPTION OF THE BUSINESS. IF NOT ILLUMINATED, THE TEXT SHALL BE PAINTED METAL LETTERS, WITH GREEN PMS 3435C, 3. AMEND TO Tenant Identification locations will (remain) in areas indicated on exhisting exhibits 4, 5, 6, 7. An additional location for Unit B-106A has been added per NEW exhibit 7B. Not to exceed 25 sq. ft. for Unit 106A.Tenant Sq. Ft. allowance shall be equal to sign having overall height of 26” and length of 60% of the tenant’s linear store front per sign location. Custom shapes and broken borders on sign faces will be allowed and if height of sign increases the length of size should be shortened to keep tenant in allocated sq. ft. allowance. Logo styles, letter heights etc. will be at the tenant’s discretion while staying with-in the maximum square foot allowance. Colors and font choices for sign faces are at the tenant’s discretion but will need approved by the building association. Cabinet box edges or reveals should all be MAP paint color dark bronze for consistency in all sign cabinets. (see materials examples) 4. TENANTS IN UNITS 101 AND 10 7 MAY HA VE TWO SIGNS (ONE IN THE FRONT AND ONE ON THE SIDE ADJACENT TO THEIR SPACE). TENANTS IN SPACE 105 MAY HAVE 45 SQUARE FOOT FRONT SIGN. 5. ALL WORKMANSHIP AND SPECIFICATIONS WILL COMPLY WITH ALL APPLICABLE GOVERNMENT REGULATIONS. 6. THE COST OF OBTAINING PERMITS AND APPROVALS WILL BE THAT OF THE CONDOMINIUM OWNER. TYPESTYLES AND LOGOS SHALL BE UP TO TENANT SELECTION, BUT WRITTEN CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION APPROVAL IS REQUIRED TO INSURE COMPATIBILITY OF SUCH SIGNAGE WITH THE FIRSTCLASS IMAGE THAT THE AVON PLAZA COMPLEX IS MAINTAINING. THE LOGO COLOR, AT THE DESCRETION OF THE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION, MAY DIFFER FROM THE PMS 3435C GREEN. Amendment:= delete above reference in italics on PMS color IF A FIRST FLOOR BUSINESS OCCUPIES MORE THEN ONE SPACE, THAT TENANT CAN USE THE SQUARE FOOTAGE ALLOWANCE FOR THE FIRST SPACE, AND 50% OF THE SQUARE FOOTAGE ALLOWANCE FOR THE SECOND SPACE, FOR A MAXIMUM OF 45 SQUARE FEET PER SIGN. 4 ALL WINDOW SIGNAGE SHALL CONFORM TO THE THEN CURRENT TOWN OF AVON PERMITTED SIGNAGE. COLORS, SIZE AND PLACEMENT SHALL FIRST REQUIRE WRITTEN PERMISSION OF THE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION TO INSURE COMPATIBILITY OF SUCH SIGNAGE WITH THE FIRST CLASS IMAGE THAT THE AVON PLAZA COMPLEX IS MAINTAINING. EACH FIRST FLOOR TENANT MAY HANG A I ' X 4' DOUBLE FACED SIGN IN THE WALKWAY IN FRONT OF THE MAIN STORE ENTRANCE. THE SIGN CAN BE OF COLOR AND STYLE OF THE TENANTS SELECTION (SUCH AS ROUTED, SANDBLASTED, OR SURFACE GRAPHICS). SEE EXHIBIT 10. \ 3. SECOND LEVEL TENANTS TENANTS OF SPACE 207 MAY HA VE AN EXTERIOR SIGN AS SHOWN IN EXHIBIT 7. THIS SIGN MAY NOT EXCEED 30 SQUARE FEET. MATERIAL SHALL CONSIST OF PAN CHANNEL LETTERS (OR \4'' THICK MINIMUM FOR METAL LETTERS). COLOR SHALL BE GREEN, PMS 3435C FOR THE FACE AND, IF PAN CHANNEL, HA VE AN ANODIZED BRONZE COLOR FOR THE TRIM AND RETURN. AMEND TOO MATERIAL SHALL CONFORM TO AND MATCH STANDARDS FOR EXTERIOR SIGNS AS NOTED FOR 1ST FLOOR TENANTS THE ENTRY AREAS TO THE SECOND FLOOR OFFICE BUILDING MAY HA VE A MATCHING QUALITY SIGN OUTSIDE THE ENTRY TO EACH STAIRWAY. THE SIGN SHALL HAVE TEXT SIMILAR TO "OFFICE ENTRANCE", AND LOCATED AS SHOWN IN EXHIBITS 5 & 7. A DIRECTORY OF 24 X 36 INCHES MAY BE PLACED BY THE ENTRY DOOR TO THE UPSTAIRS, AND LIST THE TENANT LOCATED IN THE COMPLEX. AMMENDED ADDITION: SECOND LEVEL TENANTS WILL BE ALLOWED WINDOW SIGNAGE NOT TO EXCEED 25% OF THE GLASS AREAS OF SECOND FLOOR TENANTS WITH A BUILDING RESTRICTION OF NO MORE THAN 25 SQ FT PER BUSINESS IN WINDOW SIGNS FOR ANY 1 GIVEN WINDOW SPACE. 3.) TEMPORARY SIGNAGE Italic copy = Delete below see amend to: AFTER APPROVAL OF A PERMANENT SIGN BY THE TOWN OF AVON, THE TENANT CAN UTILIZE TEMPORARY BANNER. THE COLOR SHALL BE SIMILAR TO PMS 3435 COLOR, AND THE COPY SIZE, LAYOUT AND TYPESTYLE SHALL BE SIMILAR TO THAT APPROVED IN THE PERMANENT SIGNAGE.THE TEMPORARY BANNER MAY BE USED FOR A MAXIMUM OF 60 DAYS DURING THE MANUFACTURING OF THE PERMANENT SIGNAGE. Amend to: AFTER APPROVAL OF A PERMANENT SIGN BY THE TOWN OF AVON, THE TENANT CAN UTILIZE A TEMPORARY BANNER. THE BANNER, COLORS, COPY SIZE, LAYOUT AND TYPESTYLE SHALL BE SIMILAR TO THAT APPROVED IN THE PERMANENT SIGNAGE.THE TEMPORARY BANNER MAY BE USED FOR A MAXIMUM OF 60 DAYS DURING THE MANUFACTURING OF THE PERMANENT SIGNAGE. EXHIBIT #! AVON PLAZA BUILDING TENANT SIGNAGE SQUARE FOOTAGE & SPECIFICATIONS SIGN LINEAR 60% MAX MAX SQ FT SIZE W/ LOC # FRONTAGE WIDTH 26" HIGH COPY UNIT 101 94' 1 SIDE 22.5' 13.5' 30 2 FRONT 28' 16.8' 30 3 UNIT 102A 31' 18.6' 30 4 UNIT 102B 31' 18.6' 30 5 UNIT 103A 22.5' 13.5' 30 6 UNIT 103B 22.5' 13.5' 30 7 UNIT 104 24' 14.4' 30 8 UNIT 105 66' 39.6 45 9 UNIT 106A 22.5 13.5 30 10 UNIT 106B 22.5 13.5 30 UNIT 107 73 11 FRONT 45' 27.0 45 12 SIDE UNIT 207 28' 16.8 30 13 FRONT 31' 18.6 30 ADDITIONAL SIGN SPECIFICATIONS I. ALL PERMITS FOR SIGNS AND THEIR INSTALLATION SHALL BE OBTAINED BY THE TENANT AND COMPLY WITH ALL GOVERNMENTAL ORDINANCES. 2. A LICENSED ELECTRICIAN WILL NEED TO MAKE THE FINAL ELECTRICAL CONNECTION AFTER SIGN INSTALLATION. Delete see amended below 3. ALL PAN CHANNEL LETTERS WILL BE 5" DEEP, FABRICATED FROM PAINTLOK SHEET METAL (24 GAUGE), OR ALUMINUM AND BE MOUNTED DIRECTLY TO THE BUILDING VIA A THIN RACEWAY AS SHOWN IN EXHIBIT 9. THE MINIMUM STROKE SHALL BE I 3/4" TO PERMIT UL APPROVED HOUSINGS FOR ALL PENETRATIONS. ALL ELECTRICAL SHALL BE UL LABELED. TYPESTYLES AT TENANT OPTION. 4. ALL NON-ILLUMINATED COPY AND LOGO WILL BE STUD MOUNTED WITH A 1/2" TO I" REVEAL AND BE FABRICATED FROM CAST OR CUT OUT METAL LETTERS PAINTED, MINIMUM THICKNESS TO BE 1/4". AMEND 3 & 4 ABOVE TO: Tenant signs shall be an illuminated metal cabinet box using interior white LED lighting components. Business name, logo’s and/or lettering should be relief cut (routed) out of a metal or aluminum sign face utilizing routed relief area allowing light through acrylic for logo’s, business name, branding and coloriaztion accents. Lettering or routed areas will have option of translucent flush acrylic or push through dimensional letters which create halo around letters or a combination of the two. (see material examples) 5. ALL SIGNS ARE TO BE CENTERED HORIZONTALLY AND VERTICALLY IN THE TENANT SIGN AREA, EXCEPT AS OTHERWISE APPROVED BY THE CONDOMINIUM ASSOCIATION. 6. (Delete see above) THE COLORS OF THE LETTERS SHALL BE GREEN, SIMILAR TO PMS 3435C FOR THE FACES AND METAL LETTERS, AND ANODIZED BRONZED, SIMILAR TO THE WINDOW AND DOOR FRAMES FOR THE RETURNS. 7. (Delete see above) ALL SIGNS WILL BE ILLUMINATED WITH 60 MA TRANSFORMERS TO PROVIDE EVEN ILLUMINATION IN COLD WEATHER. EXHIBIT 2 BUILDING IDENTIFICATION SIGNAGE SQUARE FOOTAGE & SPECIFICATIONS BUILDING A SIGN FACE A -EAST ELEVATION BUIDING A SIGN FACE B - NORTH ELEVATON SIGN AREA 4' HIGH X 18' WIDE SIGN AREA 4' HIGH X 18' WIDE ABOVE SIGNAGE TO BE REVERSE PAN CHANNEL LETTERS, MOUNTED WITH OR WITHOUT RACEWAY (FABRICATION OPTION). FACE AND RETURN OF LETTERS TO BE TERRA-COATA, SIMILAR TO THE ROOF, PMS 167. ADDITIONAL SIGN SPECIFICATIONS 1. A LICENSED ELECTRICIAN WILL NEED TO MAKE THE FINAL ELECTRICAL CONNECTION AFTER SIGN INSTALLATION. 2. ALL REVERSE PAN CHANNEL LETTERS WILL BE A MINIMUM OF 5" DEEP, FABRICATED FROM PAINTLOCK SHEET METAL (24 GAUGE), OR ALUMINUM. THE MINIMUM STROKE SHALL BE I 3/4" TO PERMIT UL APPROVED HOUSINGS FOR ALL WALL PENETRATIONS. ALL ELECTRICAL SHALL BE UL LABELED. ILLUMINATION WILL COME FROM WHITE 15 MM #6500 NEON. 3. ALL SIGNS ARE TO BE CENTERED HORIZONTALLY AND VERTICALLY IN THE BUILDING IDENTIFICATION SIGN AREA. 4. ALL SIGNS WILL BE ILLUMINATED WITH 60 MA TRANSFORMERS TO PROVIDE EVEN ILLUMINATION IN COLD WEATHER. PARKING SIGNAGE- SEE EXHIBIT XXX. l. P-1 DUMPSTER PARKING (12 X 18) 2. P-2 HANDICAPPED PARKING (4)(12 X 18) 3. P-3 LOADING AREA PARKING LIMITS (12 X 18) 4. P-4 PARKING FOR AVON PLAZA ONLY TO BE PLACED AS APPROPRIATE (18 X 24) pg 1 AMENDED SIGN LOCATION EAST WALL FACING CITY MARKET BLDG B UNIT 106A ALLOWED ADDITIONAL SIGN LOCATION 106A EXHIBIT 7B EXITING PATHWAY EXISTING MSP SIGN LOCATE TREE INTERFERENCE BREEZE WAY SIGN LOCATION SIGN LOCATION pg 2 (2) Example of Routed copy no push thru (1) Example of Push thru Letters (3) Example of Combo Push thru Letters Routed Tag Line Materials Options Exhibit A photo sample pg 3 T he UPS Stor eThe UPS Stor e Materials Options Exhibit A Continued (4) Example Custom Shape Face and Push Thru Letters (5) Example Custom Shape Digitally printed Texture Background Thru Letters, Broken Border Icon (7) Example Cabinet Box Push Thru Letters Broken Border Icon (6) Example of Cabinet Box Routed Face with separate logo Icon pg 4 SAMPLE SIGN DISPLAY pg 5 EXHIBIT 5A SIGN LOCATIONS EXAMPLE SIGN LOCATIONS / AMENDED MATERIALS EXHIBIT 7 pg 6BUILDING B EAST ELEVATION EXHIBIT 4 BUILDING A EAST ELEVATION pg 7 EXHIBIT 5A BUILDING A EAST ELEVATION pg 8 pg 9 EXHIBIT 5B BUILDING A NORTH ELEVATION EXHIBIT 6 pg 10 BUILDING B NORTH ELEVATION Exhibit C From:Chris Neuswanger To:David McWilliams; Matt Pielsticker Cc:info@eaglevalleyaccounting.com; "Barbara McCracken"; "Patty Cuny"; "Pete Brill"; "Art Work"; chad.wilkison@gmail.com; "Doug Jimenez" Subject:Avon Plaza signage plan modification response Date:Thursday, June 08, 2017 4:20:56 PM David & Matt The Avon Plaza Condo Association thanks the staff and the DRB for giving our request due consideration and the option of modifying it to more meet their perception of what appropriate changes would entail. However, after consideration of the DRB suggestions posed, the Association would like to point out our serious concerns in complying with said proposed changes. 1. Putting Gooseneck lighting on the front parapet (the wall where the signs are) would be completely inappropriate for two reasons. First, portions of the building have steep metal roofs that drop snow and ice down and need to be cleaned a couple of times a year for safety reasons (protecting pedestrians and cars in the lot below). Doing so is a major operation costing several thousand dollars involving as many as a dozen men, a front end loader and a dump truck. The most economical way we have found to do it is to avalanche parts of the roof over the overhang (we put plywood up to create a chute) and block off portions of the lot and make a controlled avalanche into the lot. Currently, we can easily clear the existing signs but a goose neck lamp sticking out would be demolished. Occasionally in spite of our extensive snow management efforts a section will rip loose on its own and we have lost 2 car windshields and one car hood over the years. · 2. The 1st stated goal of the sign code is · a) Harmonious with Town scale. Sign location, configuration, design, materials and colors should be harmonious with the existing signs on the structure As all are aware, there are 7 other businesses in Avon Plaza that have the green back lit channel letters. Many of these signs could easily be there for 20-years, and one is only about 18-mo old and cost over $6,000.00 To make any new signs going forward be front lit is going to cause a hodge podge of back lit and front lit signs, which we deem to be anything but harmonious in appearance to our building or the area. While the proposed requirements would differ from the green channel lit at least they would all be back lit and we could (and likely would) ask individual owners incorporate some shade of green accent somewhere in all new ones to give it somewhat of a tied together look. It is my understanding that the DRB wishes to study moving to codify prohibiting back lit signage completely in the future. That is certainly their prerogative to pursue, but I would note that it has not happened yet, and further the DRB apparently was fine in approving extensive backlit signage for ANB Bank and the Medical Center in recent months. In addition, the DRB should carefully consider the implications that the imposition of such a requirement will cause future mix and match disjointed appearances on buildings currently using back lit signs (Chapel Square, West Gate, the SSF Center complex, ANB, City Market, and the Medical Center to name a few) and it is hard to understand how that would be a harmonious change. Also Per our discussions with Sign Design representing our MSP there has been past discussions on the terms , interior-lit box-type plastic, in PZ meetings in past but they always referenced, and discouraged, square box acrylic faced signs like the ones on Mountain Center along Nottingham Rd, (although these were deemed acceptable as they only faced I-70) while the metal routed face application like the example with joe’s liquor Westgate bldg. was deemed “outside” this reference as plastic portion is replaced with metal face. We have allowed and not limited the tenants to custom shapes etc. vs. a continuous box style application. The combination of these two elements we feel takes our proposal out of the term “interior-lit box-type plastic” As to the new sign for B106a, that unit is currently under contract for sale contingent upon getting the additional signage approved. That unit has had numerous lookers over the last several years it has been on the market and in my role as President of the HOA have met with several potential buyers all of whom have noted the limited visibility of the unit as a detriment. The front of the unit is covered by a large crab apple tree, which even if severely pruned would impede visibility form the street of the signage on the front of the unit. As we all know, the TOA does not advocate cutting down trees either (and everyone likes that tree, it’s a beauty). As to concerns about creating additional foot traffic across the ANB lot, isn’t it a stated goal of the Avon Govt. to make Avon more pedestrian friendly? That sidewalk was added because that is where everyone was walking and it was a muddy mess. Pedestrians will go where its easiest. There is a large amount of foot traffic from the Plaza, and the Christy Lodge as a shortcut to the Bank and City Market and Chapel Square. It’s a long established pedestrian path. To pose it would create a parking issue for ANB is at best highly subjective and in our view, unlikely. ANB can certainly post “NO Avon Plaza Parking” or something similar and there are adequate town codes to enforce any issues that may arise. Surely most people coming out of City Market can figure out that is the back of a shopping mall and find their way to the front of the building. Also, a bit of history here: the sidewalk between the Plaza and the ANB lot was built as a joint project by both owners as we felt it would be mutually beneficial to both circulate foot traffic and solve a muddy boot problem for both, and ANB has contributed to the maintenance of the sidewalk. That was about 20-years before Avon decided to become “pedestrian friendly” I spoke with Chris Rowberry, who is the local Bank President, and while he could not speak formally for the ANB Bank, stated he had no personal objection to the placement of a sign there. Lastly, in regards to the concerns of the DRB that the original 1996 signage plan contained in- consistencies and typos, I would remind all that we are not here to do a whole new sign plan which would cost the HOA at a minimum hundreds of dollars, nor should we be expected to. The Town of Avon accepted the plan in 1996; we are simply amending a couple of provisions. The format which we have presented is I believe the appropriate format (i.e. noting that certain sections be deleted and new verbiage substituted. Chad Wilkerson (of Chronic Tacos) and myself will be at the June 20th meeting. We look forward to continuing this conversation with the staff and DRB. Best Chris Neuswanger, President Avon Plaza Condo Association 970-748-0342 June 20, 2017 PZC Work Session Lot 30 Block 1 Benchmark at Beaver Creek PAGE 1 OF 2 To: Planning and Zoning Commission From: David McWilliams, Town Planner Meeting Date: May 16, 2017 Agenda Topic: Work Session – SevenTen Project / 710 Nottingham Road Introduction Representatives from the SevenTen project will be in attendance for a work session concerning the SevenTen apartment project on Lot 30 Block 1, Benchmark at Beaver Creek. This meeting follows an initial work session with PZC that took place in July, 2015. The purpose of Tuesday’s work session is to provide the Planning and Zoning Commission with a presentation on the progression of the project , and elicit feedback about the mitigating potential issues with the project. Design modifications, including the addition of three units for a total of 15 units, have taken place since the initial review by the Planning and Zoning Commission. Staff encourages the PZC to come prepared with questions and comments on the attached development plan drawings. The applicant is seeking direction on the revised plans, as well as providing the Planning and Zoning Commission with the opportunity to review the applications prior to a public hearing. We urge the Planning and Zoning Commission to consider what additional submittal items (if any) would be of assistance to fully review the application at the upcoming hearing. The project timeline, below, would be required to zone and approve the design of the project. Table 7.20-5 is also included for reference to what the typical dimensions found in Residential High Density are. The PUD overlay would then be necessary to achieve overall town land use goals and increase the allowed density from the zoning requirement. Project Timeline Rezoning IC to Res HD Overlay to PUD Development Application Review by PZC June 20, 2017 PZC Work Session Lot 30 Block 1 Benchmark at Beaver Creek PAGE 2 OF 2 Table 7.20-5 Dimensions for the Residential High Density District Dwelling Type Max. Density (units/ acre) Min. Lot Size (acres or sq. ft.) Min. Lot Width (feet) Max. Lot Coverage (%) Min. Landscape Area (%) Min. Front Setback (feet) Min. Side Setback (feet) Min. Rear Setback (feet) Max. Building Height (feet) Max. Units/ Building Townhouse/ multifamily 20 *must meet density and setback requirements n/a 80 20 10 0 10 60 n/a Attachments  Executive Summary of Development Proposal (Note- the proposed project density has changed to 15 units since this summary)  Development Plan Drawings From:Charlie Perkins To:Brian Garner; Matt Pielsticker; John Perkins Subject:Lot 30 Nottingham Road Synopsis Date:Wednesday, July 01, 2015 7:55:21 PM Re: Seventen Lofts Lot 30, Block 1 Benchmark @ Beaver Creek Amendment No. 4 Avon, Colorado Date: July 1, 2015 Development History Lot 30 Lot 30 was first proposed to Town of Avon Community Development staff in late 2001 as a 4,685 sq.ft. commercial carwash with an additional 4 dwelling units of 1,380 sq, ft. each. The project was approved for construction...but property Owner allowed the permit to expire. The permit was re-newed a second time..and again was not executed, resulting in the Town of Avon effectively denying the project as a commercial carwash. In conjunction with this approval...the Town of Avon executed Resolution No. 02-08 approving a temporary easement for Lot 30. This easement area was for the purpose of temporary construction access, slope contouring, and grading and slope maintenance, including grade, fill, drain, pave, build, and construct retaining walls. This resolution was adopted by the Town Council of Avon on February 26, 2002. The site has had no further development exploration or activity until now. Property Description Lot 30 is a 0.5367 acre parcel located @ 0710 Nottingham Road. It is abutted by Lot 31 (Pet Store) to the west and Town of Avon "Tract B" to the north and east. Topography on the site has a vertical fall from north to south of approximately 25 to 30 feet. Vegetation is sparse, with no significant trees or water features. Property Access The proposed development would share the ingress/egress easement currently utilized by Lot 31. Additional and proposed one way vehicular egress would occur @ the southeast corner of the property and discharge onto Nottingham Road. Current Zoning Existing Town of Avon zoning designation is "Light Industrial Commercial (IC)" as described in table 7.20-13 of the town of Avon Development code. Proposed Zoning JMP Architects, Inc. is proposing a rezoning classification of "Residential High Density (RH)" that would replace the current IC zoning. The RH zoning allows for a maximum density of 20 units per acre. JMP Architects is requesting 12 units for the entire property (0.5367 acres) Given the current and trending housing shortage the Town of Avon and valley municipalities are experiencing, plus proximity to pedestrian/bicycle paths, Town of Avon bus routes, and Town core;....JMP Architects, Inc. believes the RH zoning classification has merits of satisfying pressing community needs and goals more favorably than IC zoning. Additional vehicular demand on Nottingham Road would not be compounded due to RH zoning, as compared to IC zoning, and arguably would reduce traffic volume during mid morning to mid afternoon hours. Assuming that peak trips from Lot 30 would be generated from the hours of 7am to 9am......and 4pm to 6pm. Proximity to town pedestrian/bicycle paths would also assist in reducing traffic volumes along Nottingham Road, as compared to IC zoning "destination" arrivals and departures by automobile at all hours of the day. Proposed "Seventen Lofts" Project Description The proposed Seventen lofts would contain a "mix" of (6) 2 BR units @ the mid level of approx. 1,152 square feet and (6) 2 BR units at the upper level of approx. 1,392 square feet. Upper units would have access to privatized roof top decks with commanding views of Beaver Creek and Arrowhead ski areas. All units would have private garages at the lower or street level capable of stacking two vehicles. Access to mid and upper units would be achieved by 3 stair bays. Exit discharge at the rear or north of the project would traverse east and west along a protected and paved route until merging onto the downslope at the east and west end of the property. Seventen lofts also employs solar energy collection at the rooftop through standard photo voltaic panels, and accommodates those with disabilities with a designated ADA compliant unit. The ADA unit occurs at the east end of the project at mid-level and is serviced by a 'limited use limited accessibility" elevator or "LULA" lift. Associated ADA parking is achieved with one space at the east end of surface parking. Facade articulation is achieved through the use of external balconies and varying vertical planes. Grade level garage access is protected by building projections and balconies. JMP Architects is requesting that Town of Avon planning staff consider the use of vibrant colors on the facade in keeping with the spirit of "freeway architecture" and compliment the modern nature of the proposed design. Snow storage/collection areas occur at the east, center, and west ends of the surface parking area along Nottingham Road. A landscape noise buffer and possible berm is proposed for the entire frontage along Nottingham Road. The project will utilize a internal fire sprinkler system and comply with all Town of Avon fire department and International Building Code regulations regarding life safety. Specific Project Data Lot 30 Site area: 0.5367 Acres Maximum Lot Coverage: 80% (RH zoning) Maximum Density: 20 units per acre (RH zoning) Site Square Footage: 23,378.65 Building Footprint: 9,750.00 sq. ft. Impervious Coverage: 7,350.00 sq. ft. Landscape Area: 6,278.00 sq. ft. Minimum Landscape Area 20% (RH zoning) Required Parking: 2 per unit Parking Provided 2 per unit Required Guest Parking: 11- 15 units = 4 spaces Guest Parking Provided: 8 spaces plus 1 ADA compliant space 2 BR Unit Mid-Level sq. ft. 1,152 2 BR Unit Upper-Level sq. ft. 1, 392 Roof top deck sq. ft. 521 Roof top deck storage sq. ft. 77 Stairway sq. ft 425 Total Project Square Footage Lower Level (garages/storage/stairs) 8,187 sq. ft Mid Level ( 2BR units @ 1,152 sq. ft ea.) x 6 6,912 sq. ft Upper Level ( 2BR units @ 1,392 sq. ft ea.) x 6 8,352 sq. ft Grand Total Project Square Footage 23, 451 sq. ft. * * number reflects stair sq footage as being calculated on first floor only....does not include roof top deck sq. ft. John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOCOVER SHEET A0.00 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER COVER SHEET A0.00 SITE PLAN A0.01 WEST PERSPECTIVE A0.02 BASEMENT PLAN A1.00 FIRST FLOOR PLAN A1.01 SECOND FLOOR PLAN A1.02 THIRD FLOOR PLAN A1.03 ROOF DECK PLAN A1.04 ROOF PLAN A1.05 COMPOSITE PLAN A1.06 ELEVATIONS A2.01 ELEVATIONS A2.02 ELEVATION SOUTH W/CARPORT A2.03 BUILDING SECTIONS A3.01 ENLARAGED GARAGE PLAN A4.00 ENLARGED FIRST FLOOR A4.01 ENLARGED SECOND FLOOR A4.02 ENLARGED THIRD FLOOR A4.03 ENLARGED FOURTH FLOOR A4.04 ROOF DECK ENLARGED A4.05 Seventen Lofts ISSUE No. Date Remarks EAST PERSPECTIVE 144' - 0" NOTTINGHAM ROADEXISTING DRIVEWAYRES.UNIT #5GUESTRES.UNIT #4GUESTRES.UNIT #4RES.UNIT #5RES.UNIT #3RES.UNIT #3GUESTRES.UNIT #2RES.UNIT #2GUESTRES.UNIT #116' - 1 5/32"1 2 ' - 0 1 7 /3 2 " John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOSITE PLAN A0.01 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1" = 10'-0"1 SITE PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOWEST PERSPECTIVE A0.02 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status ISSUE No. Date Remarks WEST PERSPECTIVE A2.03 1 W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6 1 2 3 4 5 6 M5 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 26' - 0"9' - 5"26' - 0"9' - 5"52' - 3"9' - 5"26' - 0" 158' - 6"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"6' - 0"48' - 0"62' - 0"unit 6 garage unit 7 garage unit 8 garage unit 9 garage unit 10 garage unit 11 garage unit 12 garage unit 13 garage unit 14 garage unit 15 garage A2.01 2 13' - 0"13' - 0" 158' - 6" 13' - 0"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" A2.02 2 A2.01 1 A2.021 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOBASEMENT PLAN A1.00 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 ENTRY LEVEL north ISSUE No. Date Remarks UP UP UPUP UP UP W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6 1 2 3 4 5 6 M5 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 unit 1 unit 2 unit 3 unit 4 unit 562' - 0"48' - 0"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" 26' - 0"9' - 5"26' - 0"9' - 5"52' - 3"9' - 5"26' - 0" 13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" 158' - 6" A2.01 2 A2.021 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOFIRST FLOOR PLAN A1.01 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 FIRST FLOOR north ISSUE No. Date Remarks UP UP UP UP UP UP W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6 1 2 3 4 5 6 M5 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 unit 6 unit 7 unit 8 unit 9 unit 1062' - 0"48' - 0"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"158' - 6" 26' - 0"9' - 5"26' - 0"9' - 5"52' - 3"9' - 5"26' - 0" 13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" A2.01 2 A2.01 1 A2.02 2 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOSECOND FLOOR PLAN A1.02 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 SECOND FLOOR PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks DN UPUP DN UP DN UP DN UP W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6 1 2 3 4 5 6 M5 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 unit 11 unit 12 unit 13 unit 14 unit 1562' - 0"48' - 0"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"158' - 6" 26' - 0"9' - 5"26' - 0"9' - 5"52' - 3"9' - 5"26' - 0" 13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" A2.01 2 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOTHIRD FLOOR PLAN A1.03 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 THIRD FLOOR PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks DN DN DN DN DN DNDNDNDN DN W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6 1 2 3 4 5 6 M5 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.0162' - 0"48' - 0"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"158' - 6" 26' - 0"9' - 5"26' - 0"9' - 5"52' - 3"9' - 5"26' - 0" 13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" unit 11 deck unit 12 deck unit 13 deck unit 14 deck unit 15 deck A2.01 2 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOROOF DECK PLAN A1.04 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 ROOF DECK PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6 1 2 3 4 5 6 M5 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.0162' - 0"48' - 0"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"158' - 6" 26' - 0"9' - 5"26' - 0"9' - 5"52' - 3"9' - 5"26' - 0" 13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 1 1/2"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" A2.01 2 A2.021 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOROOF PLAN A1.05 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 ROOF PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks UP W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6 1 2 3 4 5 6 M5 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 A2.01 2 A2.02 2 A2.01 1 GARAGE/ENTRY FIRST LEVEL SECOND LEVEL THIRD LEVEL FOURTH LEVEL/DECK John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOCOMPOSITE PLAN A1.06 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 COMPOSITE PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" WM1S1S2S3S4M3M2PM4S5ES6M5 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 00-ENTRY LEVEL 80' - 0" 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6M5 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 FOOTING 76' - 0" John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOELEVATIONS A2.01 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 ELEVATION NORTH ISSUE No. Date Remarks 1/8" = 1'-0"2 ELEVATION SOUTH 00-ENTRY LEVEL 80' - 0" 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" 1 2 3 4 5 6 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 3 A3.01 FOOTING 76' - 0" 00-ENTRY LEVEL 80' - 0" 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" 123456 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 3 A3.01 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOELEVATIONS A2.02 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status ISSUE No. Date Remarks 1/8" = 1'-0"2 ELEVATION WEST 1/8" = 1'-0"1 ELEVATION-EAST 00-ENTRY LEVEL 80' - 0" 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6M5 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 b.o. basement foundation 69' - 0" FOOTING 76' - 0" John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOELEVATION SOUTH W/CARPORT A2.03 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 ELEVATION SOUTH WITH CARPORT ISSUE No. Date Remarks 00-ENTRY LEVEL 80' - 0" 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" 123456 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 3 A3.01 FOOTING 76' - 0" 00-ENTRY LEVEL 80' - 0" 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" 123456 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 3 A3.01 FOOTING 76' - 0" 00-ENTRY LEVEL 80' - 0" 01-FIRST FLOOR 91' - 0" 04-FOURTH FLOOR 124' - 0" 02-SECOND FLOOR 102' - 0" W M1 S1 S2 S3 S4 M3M2 P M4 S5 ES6M5 03-THIRD FLOOR 113' - 0" 05-ROOF PLAN 136' - 6" 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 FOOTING 76' - 0" John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOBUILDING SECTIONS A3.01 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/8" = 1'-0"1 BUILDING SECTION A ISSUE No. Date Remarks 1/8" = 1'-0"2 BUILDING SECTION B 1/8" = 1'-0"3 BUILDING SECTION C UP W M1 S1 S2 S3M2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOENLARAGED GARAGE PLAN A4.00 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status ISSUE No. Date Remarks 1/4" = 1'-0"1 GARAGE ENLARGED PLAN UP UP W M1 S1 S2 S3M2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOENLARGED FIRST FLOOR A4.01 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status north ISSUE No. Date Remarks 1/4" = 1'-0"1 FIRST FLOOR ENLARGED PLAN UP UP W M1 S1 S2 S3M2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 unit 6 unit 762' - 0"48' - 0"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"26' - 0"35' - 5" 13' - 0"13' - 0"9' - 5"13' - 0"13' - 0" A2.02 2 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOENLARGED SECOND FLOOR A4.02 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status north ISSUE No. Date Remarks 1/4" = 1'-0"1 SECOND FLOOR ENLARGED PLAN UP DN UP W M1 S1 S2 S3M2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 unit 11 unit 1262' - 0"48' - 0"23' - 6"14' - 6"10' - 0"26' - 0"9' - 5"26' - 0" 13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0"13' - 0" John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOENLARGED THIRD FLOOR A4.03 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status north ISSUE No. Date Remarks 1/4" = 1'-0"1 THIRD FLOOR ENLARGED PLAN UP UP DN W M1 S1 S2 S3M2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOENLARGED FOURTH FLOOR A4.04 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/4" = 1'-0"1 FOURTH FLOOR ENLARGED PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks DN DN W M1 S1 S2 S3 M2 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 A3.01 2 A3.01 3 A3.01 5' - 0" John M Perkins, AIA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 720.201.9760 perk.jmparchitect@gmail.com Charlie Perkins, PA PO Box 2007 Avon, Colorado 81620 214.862.8942 percharlie@gmail.com SHEET NAME SHEET NUMBER PROJECT NO: PHASE:SEVENTEN LOFTS710 NOTTINGHAM, EAGLE COUNTY, COLORADOROOF DECK ENLARGED A4.05 xx.xxxxx.xx Project Status 1/4" = 1'-0"1 ROOF DECK ENLARGED PLAN north ISSUE No. Date Remarks June 20, 2017 PZC Work Session Lot 39 Block 1 Wildridge PAGE 1 OF 2 To: Planning and Zoning Commission From: David McWilliams, Town Planner Meeting Date: June 20, 2017 Agenda Topic: Work Session – Greer Garage Project AEC Introduction Amy Greer will be in attendance for a work session concerning the Minor Development Plan (MNR) and Alternative Equivalent Compliance (AEC) applications for a garage project on Lot 39 Block 1, Wildridge, 2137 Long Spur. The purpose of Tuesday’s work session is to provide the Planning and Zoning Commission with an overview of the project, and elicit feedback about the AEC criteria of the project. While the garage itself falls under the MNR review process, its location in front of the main house precludes staff approval due to its conflict with the code section below. Section 7.28.090(i)(2) of the Avon Municipal Code (AMC) states: Single-Family and Duplex Residence Garages: (i) Front-loading (street-oriented) garage doors shall either recess behind the front façade of the dwelling portion of the structure or a front porch or recess beneath a second floor bay. (ii) Side-loaded garages shall provide windows or other architectural details that are consistent with or complement the features of the living portion of the dwelling on the side of the garage facing the street. (iii) The use of alley or side-loaded garages or the use of a combination of these garage orientations is required where feasible. Further, the addition is proposed without roof overhangs. The garage abuts the party wall line and it appears an overhang would extend over to the other duplex unit’s property. AMC section 7.28.090(c)(4)(ii), states: (ii) Overhangs are required on pitched roofs and shall extend at least one and one-half (1.5) feet from the point where the wall meets the roof as horizontally measured from the exterior wall of the structure. These conflict triggers the AEC process, whereby the applicant is required to demonstrate consistency with the intent of AMC through her proposed alternative. The criteria for the decision are listed below: (1) The proposed alternative achieves the intent of the subject design or development standard to the same or better degree than the subject standard; (2) The proposed alternative achieves the goals and policies of the Avon Comprehensive Plan to the same or better degree than the subject standard; (3) The proposed alternative results in benefits to the community that are equivalent to or better than compliance with the subject standard; and June 20, 2017 PZC Work Session Lot 39 Block 1 Wildridge PAGE 2 OF 2 (4) The proposed alternative imposes no greater impacts on adjacent properties than would occur through compliance with the specific requirements of this Title. Staff has concerns with various aspects of the project, including:  Car turning movements associated with the proposed addition  Snow storage abutting the southern neighbor’s property, and potentially blocking turning movements  Site drainage  Landscaping replacement to the additional paved area The applicant is soliciting feedback before the July 18 PZC meeting so the hearing is more predictable in a month. Staff encourages the PZC to come prepared with questions and comments on the attached development plan drawings and narrative. Attachments  Project Narrative  June 15 letter addressing specific staff concerns  June 15 letter addressing AEC requirements  Photo of exterior  Site elevation and plan view Amy and Brandon Greer 2137 Long Spur A Avon, CO 81620 June 15, 2017 Planning and Zoning Committee Members, This letter is to directly address the 4 criteria required in the Alternative Equivalent Compliance Process. The 4 criteria are as follows (responses are in bold): (1) The proposed alternative achieves the intent of the subject design or development standard to the same or better degree than the subject standard; The design works within the pre existing constraints of the property line and the design suits the site to a better degree than the development standard. In this circumstance it is not possible due to the layout of the lot to have a side facing, or ally entry garage. (2) The proposed alternative achieves the goals and policies of the Avon Comprehensive Plan to the same or better degree than the subject standard; The proposed design is in compliance with the goals and policies of the Avon Comprehensive Plan. The Wildridge subdivision is identified as a low priority district in the Avon Comprehensive plan. The structure will be harmonious with the existing structure. Any landscaping improvements will be harmonious with the existing trees, shrubs and natural landscape. (3) The proposed alternative results in benefits to the community that are equivalent to or better than compliance with the subject standard; and The proposed alternative design benefits the community in an equivalent manner to compliance. The proposed addition improves the current condition of the property by repairing the driveway and creating a more appealing and up to date looking property. (4) The proposed alternative imposes no greater impacts on adjacent properties than would occur through compliance with the specific requirements of this Title. June 15, 2017 Greer Residence Addition The proposed design does not impose upon adjacent properties any more than a compliant design. In fact, in not building living space above the proposed garage, the design imposes less upon adjacent properties. Sincerely, Amy and Brandon Greer Work Session – Landscape Code June 20, 2017 Planning & Zoning Commission Meeting Summary The Avon Town Council 2017-18 Strategic Plan highlights the Landscape code, chapter 7.28.050 of the AMC, for an update. Specifically, the Strategic Plan, Tier 1 Priority, states:  Amend the Town’s landscape code to more effectively replace vegetation which has been removed  With the expertise of the UERWA, develop outdoor landscape guidelines/regulations to reduce water use and off-site impacts, such as fertilizer run-off, which can affect the Eagle River  Assess the Town's public tree stock in the park and in right-of-ways for timely replacement  Proactively ensure trees on public and private property do not host and spread viruses; remove dead trees with a well-developed landscape program The purpose of this work session is to review the progress that staff has made in achieving these objectives. A strikethrough of chapter 7.28.050 Landscaping Code, chapter 8.36Noxious weed Removal, and supporting documents structured to guide applicants represent the best effort of staff to represent the various issues and talking points brought up during the last PZC meeting. The meeting’s task will be to determine which regulations it recommends to Town Council. Staff has continually received new information, particularly relevant to “fire-wise” landscaping, that is not included in this not included in this work session. Also, water budgeting may be explored, as a next step for staff to implement. Any other pieces that are missing should be brought to staff’s attention to ensure a complete update that represents best practices and adherence to the strategic plan. Attachments A. Strikethrough of chapter 7.28.050 B. Strikethrough of chapter 8.36 C. Tree Removal guidelines D. Suggested List of Plants to form Hydrozones for Landscape Plan E. Example water budget form from Aspen Project type: Code Text Amendment Location: Prepared By: Throughout Town David McWilliams, Town Planner Page 1 7.28.050 - Landscaping. (a) Purpose. The purpose of the landscaping standards is to ensure that landscaping in the Town: (1) Integrates building sites with natural topography and existing vegetation; (2) Minimizes disturbed areas; (3) Conserves Respects the limitedations and best uses of water resources; (4) Reduces the amount of reflected glare and heat absorbed in and around developments; (5) Breaks up large expanses of parking lots; and (6) Preserves residential neighborhoods by lessening the impacts of potentially incompatible uses; and. (7) Reduces water use and off-site impacts, which can affect the Eagle River. (b) Applicability. This landscaping Section shall apply to all new development and redevelopment as provided in Subsection 7.28.010(b), Applicability. Applicability of the provisions of this Section shall be as indicated in Table 7.28-6 below. (x) A Landscape Plan shall be required, the content of which is at the discretion of the Community Development Director, and further outlined in Subsection 7.28.050(XXXXX). (c) Required Landscaped Area. Minimum landscaped area and maximum irrigated area for each zoning district shall be as indicated in Table 7.28-6, below. Note: Specific PUDs may have different regulations. _______________________________________ Table 7.28-6 Minimum Landscaped Area and Maximum Irrigated Area by Zoning District Zoning Districts Minimum Landscaped Area (% of Gross Lot Size) Maximum Irrigated Area (% of Landscaped Area) Maximum Irrigated Area (Total Square Footage) NC, MC, TC, IC 20 20 5,000 RSF, RL, RM, RH 25 20 5,000 P, PF, OLD 0 n/a n/a _______________________________________ (d) Landscape Buffer. The following regulations apply to properties where a nonresidential district or use abuts a residential district or use: (1) A minimum fifteen-foot-wide buffer space shall be provided. Attachment A Page 2 (2) The buffer shall be designed with adequate landscaping or screening to properly separate the differing uses. (3) New trees and shrubs shall be evenly spaced at planting. (4) A solid masonry wall, minimum six (6) feet in height, may be substituted for required shrubs. (5) Where a natural buffer exists, as determined by the Director, it shall remain undisturbed. (6) If used in addition to a landscape screen, fences shall have additional evergreen shrubs planted on the residential side of the fence. (7) Mechanical equipment, permanent detention and temporary erosion and sedimentation control basis are prohibited in the buffer area. (8) Utility easements should avoid being placed in the long dimension of a buffer yard. (9) Wherever practical, pedestrian access shall be placed through the buffer yard. (e) Landscaping Units. Required landscaping is calculated in landscaping units. Landscaping shall be provided at a minimum of one (1) landscape unit per fifty (50) square feet of landscaped area, whether irrigated or not. At least twenty-five percent (25%) of all required landscape units shall be provided as trees. Significant landscaping features (trees, etc.) within utility easements will not earn landscaping units. The following table indicates the landscape units awarded for various preserved or planted landscape materials: Table 7.28-7 Landscape Units Awarded Landscape Material Landscape Units Awarded Newly Installed Existing Retained Evergreen tree, > 10’ ft. high 8 14 Evergreen tree, > 8.01—10’ ft. high 8 11 Evergreen tree, 6—8’ ft. high 6 9 Evergreen tree, <6 ft. high 1 2 Deciduous tree, > 8" caliper n/a 14 Deciduous tree, > 4.01—8" caliper n/aq 11 Deciduous tree, > 2.51—4" caliper 7 9 Deciduous tree, 1.5—2.5" caliper or multi-stem 4 4 Deciduous tree < 1.5” caliper 1 2 Page 3 Shrubs, 5-gallon 1 1.2 Shrubs, 3-gallon 0.8 0.9 Shrubs, 1-gallon 0.5 0.6 Perennials/ground cover 1 per 400 sq. ft. Annual flower bed 1 per 400 sq. ft. Xeriscapeing ground cover 1 per 800 400 sq. ft. Flower basket support 0.2 per basket Earthen berm, minimum 18" high 0.05 per linear foot Hardscape Material Units Awarded Split rail fence 0.20 per linear foot (0 in Wildridge) Screening (opaque) fence 0.40 per linear foot Shredded bark or 3"+ rock mulch such as river rock 1 per 500 sq. ft. Ornamental pavers 1 per 250 sq. ft. Landscape boulders, 3' or greater in height 1 per boulder Seating 0.40 per linear foot Landscape lighting, sculpture, art, water feature and/or sheltering structure/landmark As determined by Director Retained Existing Vegetation Mass Irrigation Bonuses Bonus Landscaping Units Awarded 300 + sq. ft. of native vegetation 10% Page 4 300 + sq. ft. with a minimum of 3 deciduous trees (4" caliper or greater), 3 evergreen trees (minimum 6 feet high) or any combination thereof 15% 500 + sq. ft. with a minimum of 5 deciduous trees (4" caliper or greater), 5 evergreen trees (minimum 6 feet high) or any combination thereof 20% 800 + sq. ft. with a minimum of 8 deciduous trees (4" caliper or greater), 8 evergreen trees (minimum 6 feet high) or any combination thereof 25% 20% or more of total landscaped area on temporary irrigation 10% 50% or more of total landscaped area on temporary irrigation 30% 80% or more of total landscaped area on temporary irrigation 50% (f) Parking Lot Landscaping. The following landscaping requirements shall be met for all off -street surface parking lots, except those in the TC district, as provi ded below. (1) Parking Lot Perimeter Landscaping: (i) Perimeter parking lot landscaping a minimum width of six (6) feet shall be required for all parking lots having more than three ten (103) spaces where the parking lot is adjacent to a public street or a nonretail or industrial use such as a residential area, institutional use (e.g., hospital) or office. (ii) The parking lot perimeter landscaping shall screen 80% of the length of the perimeter bufferachieve a minimum of one and two-tenths (1.2) landscape units per lineal foot. (iii) Where lots are being developed in a mixed -use district, the parking lot perimeter landscaping requirement may be reduced along an interior lot line, at the discretion of the Director, provided that interior parking lot lands caping applies to both parking lots. (2) Internal Landscaping: (i) Landscape strips shall be installed between the parking rows of every other double row of parking when parking rows exceed fifty (50) parking spaces. (ii) Landscape islands shall be installed for every ten (10) parking spaces contained in a parking row, either within the parking row or at the end of the parking row. (3) Curbs. Landscaped areas within parking lots or the along perimeter of the property must be protected from vehicular traffic through the use of continuous concrete curbs. At least one (1) break per thirty (30) lineal feet of curb is required to allow for ru noff inflows into the landscaped areas. (4) Internal Landscaping Island Design. The intent of internal landscape islands are to separate pedestrians from vehicles. Internal landscape islands shall: (i) Be a minimum of six (6) feet in width. (ii) Be at least two hundred (200) square feet. Page 5 (iii) Be sunken below the level of the parking lot surface to allow for runoff capture. (iv) Have a minimum of four (4) five-gallon deciduous shrubs and one (1) deciduous tree a minimum of two and one-half (2.5) inch caliper per two hundred (200) square feet. (v) Incorporate perennials and grasses for seasonal color. (vi) Contain a minimum of fifty percent (50%) living landscaping material, with a maximum of fifty percent (50%) nonliving landscaping material. Approved sid ewalks are not counted toward the nonliving landscape material percentage. (5) Internal Landscaping Strip Design. The intent of internal landscape strips are to separate pedestrians from vehicles. Internal landscape strips shall: (i) Be a minimum of ten (10) feet in width and shall extend the length of the parking row. (ii) Include a four-foot-wide sidewalk and a six-foot-wide planting strip. (iii) Meet planting requirements for interior landscape islands, as outlined above. (6) Parking Lot Landscaping in the TC District. Any boundary of a surface parking lot in the TC district that abuts a public street or alley or lot used for detached residential dwellings shall be landscaped according to this Subsection. (i) For corner-lot buildings with side-yard parking, the boundary between the parking lot and the street-facing side property line shall be landscaped or screened adjacent to the right -of-way according to one (1) of the following options: (A) A minimum four-foot-wide planting strip containing a low, continuous hedge a minimum of thirty (30) inches tall at maturation consisting of a double row of evergreen shrubs planted a minimum of three (3) feet on-center in a triangular pattern; or (B) A minimum two-foot-wide planting strip containing an ornamental metal fence or masonry wall, with a minimum height of three and one-half (3.5) feet and a maximum height of four (4) feet, combined with a single row of shrubs planted a minimum of three (3) feet on -center. (ii) For all other parking lot boundaries, the boundary shall be landscaped or screened according to one (1) of the following options: (A) A minimum two-foot-wide planting strip containing a single row of shrubs planted a minimum of three (3) feet on-center combined with a minimum three-foot-high ornamental metal fence or masonry wall of materials compatible with the primary structure. In the place of shrubs, deciduous shade trees may be planted a minimum of ten (10) feet on -center along the common boundary line; or (B) A minimum four (4) foot wide planting strip containing a low, continuous hedge a minimum of thirty (30) inches tall at installation consisting of a double row of evergreen shrubs planted a minimum of three (3) feet on-center in a triangular pattern. (iii) As applicable, landscaping materials shall be planted on the side of the fence/wall closest to the street, alley or residential property. (iv) The interior landscaping requirements of Subsection 7.28.050(f), Parking Lot Landscaping, shall apply to all parking areas that meet the applicability standards of that Section. (g) Sight Distance Triangle. A sight distance triangle within the off -street parking area must be established at street intersections by maintaining a maximum height for shrubs and ground cover of thirty (30) inches as measured from the driveway surface. No obstructions are permitted in the sight distance triangle, including tree branches that must be trimmed within eight (8) feet of the ground. All applicable sight distance requirements must be met for parking lot internal circulation and access points to the public right-of-way. (h) Landscaping Standards. All landscaping elements, including but not limited to planters, retaining walls and berms, must be specifically approved and shall conform to the following standards: Page 6 (1) Preservation of Existing Vegetation. Landscaping plans should be designed to preserve and protect existing native vegetation and mature trees. Bonus landscape credit shall be awarded for preserved vegetation as indicated in Table 7.28-7, Landscape Units Awarded, above, where the Director accepts the existing vegetation as being in good health and meets the intent of the landscaping requirements of this Chapter. (i) No trees or vegetation shall be removed except as specifica lly allowed in this Section. (ii) On any lot in the RL, RD and RM zoning districts that has an area greater than one -half (½) acre, no trees or vegetation except for noxious, non -native vegetation shall be removed outside the designated site disturbance en velope. (iii) All native landscaping shall be kept in its native state. (iv) Significant trees and vegetation that are removed from a development site shall be replaced as set forth in this Section. (A) Significant Trees. Significant trees, as defined by this Section, shall be preserved to the maximum extent feasible. (1) A significant tree means a tree of at least eighteen (18) inches in diameter for a deciduous tree and twelve (12) inches for evergreen s, measured at a height of fifty-four (54) inches above the ground. (2) When a significant tree is removed from either inside or outside the designated building envelope, the developer property owner shall replace such tree on the lot, either inside or outside the building envelope, with a minimum of two (2) trees a minimum height of eight (8) feet or a minimum caliper of two and one -half (2.5) inches. (3) Replacement trees shall be maintained through an establishment period of at least three (3) years, except that single-family and duplex dwellings shall have an applicable establishment period of one (1) year. The developer shall post a bond guaranteeing the survival and health of all replacement trees during the establishment period. (4) It is the responsibility of the property owner to preserve and maintain any established significant tree. (5) Alternative tree removal guidelines are at the discretion of the PlanningCommunity Development Director. (B) Non-significant Trees. Preservation of non-significant trees of a protected species with dimensions equal to or greater than the minimum dimensions required for new landscaping trees is encouraged. (C) Protective Fencing During Construction. All vegetation, significant trees and trees intended for use as credit towards the landscaping and tree protection standards of this Development Code shall be fenced in accordance with this Subsection before grading or other land-disturbing activity begins. The Director shall consider existing site conditions in determining the exact location of any tree protection fencing. (1) Type of Fencing. The developer shall erect a plastic mesh fence, straw bale or equivalent method of fencing at the perimeter of the designated building envelope and a minimum of four (4) feet in height at the drip line around each tree or group of trees within the building envelope to prevent the placement of debris or fill on vegetation to be preserved or within the drip line of any tree. (2) Inspection. All tree and vegetation protection measures shall be inspected and approved by the Director prior to start of any land disturbing activities. Failure to have protection measures inspected prior to the commencement of construction is a violation of this Development Code. Page 7 (2) Allowed Plant Materials. Proposed materials must be specified on development plans. A list of permissible plant species that are compatible with various climate zones found in the Town and that promote water conservation shall be adopted by the Planning and Zoning Commission and may be amended from time to time. Materials not on the list may be approved if the Director determines that they are equally or more suitable for local soil conditions, climate and water conservation goals and would provide the same or bett er level of visual benefits and have desire growth habits. No noxious weeds, as defined by Chapter 8.36, are permitted for use in the Town. (3) Noxious Vegetation and diseased trees. The identification and removal of noxious, non -native, or diseased vegetation is required and shall be in compliance with Chapter 8.36. (4) Irrigation and Landscape Plan Required and Watering Requirements: (i) All required landscaping shall be irrigated pursuant to Table 7.28 -6, Minimum Landscaped Area and Maximum Irrigated Area by Zoning District. The landscaping irrigation site plan must identify the area of approximate installation of an automatic irrigation system, its maintenance and intended uses. All landscape planting plans must note and delineate all irrigated planting and sod areas. Irrigation system requirements shall include the following items: (a) Backflow prevention devices to protect the potable water supply from contamination by the irrigation system and comply with local plumbing codes; (b) Manual shut-off valves (such as a gate valve, ball valve, or butterfly valve), as close as possible to the point of connection of the water supply and to isolate sections of mainline on larger systems, to minimize water loss in case of an emergency (such as a main line break) or routine repair; (c) Master shut-off valves integrated with the automatic irrigation controller on all projects with a point of connection flow rate exceeding _XX_ gpm except irrigation systems that make use of technologies that allow for the control of sprinklers that are individually pressurized; (d) Dedicated landscape water meters, defined as either a dedicated water service meter or private sub meter, for all non-residential irrigated landscapes of sq. ft. and residential irrigated landscapes of 4,000 sq. ft. or greater. A landscape water meter may be either: (1) a customer service meter dedicated to landscape use provided by the local water provider; (2) a privately owned meter or sub meter to measure irrigation water usage; (e) Flow meters that detect and report high flow conditions created by s ystem damage or malfunction for non-residential development; (f) Smart irrigation controllers labeled by U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's WaterSense Program or with published reports posted on the Smart Water Application Technologies website. Suggestions? Suggestions? Page 8 If a flow meter is used, then the controller shall be able to use inputs from the flow meter/sensor to control irrigation if flows are abnormal; (g) Sensors (rain, freeze, wind, soil moisture etc.), either integral or auxiliary, that suspend or alter irrigation operation during unfavorable weather conditions or when sufficient soil moisture is present, as appropriate for local climatic conditions; (h) designed to prevent runoff, low head drainage, overspray, or other similar conditions where irrigation water flows onto non-targeted areas, such as adjacent property, non-irrigated areas, hardscapes, roadways, or structures; (i) The design of the irrigation system shall conform to the hydrozones of the landscape design plan; (j) All irrigation shall be subject to the watering schedule as imposed by the Eagle River Water and Sanitation District (ERWSD). (k) designed with valve pressure regulators, sprinkler head pressure regulators, inline pressure regulators, booster pumps, or other devices to meet the required operating pressure of the emission devices to ensure that the operating pressure at each emission device is within the manufacturer's recommended pressure range for optimal performance. (l) The pressure and flow measurements identified at the design stage and verified prior to the installation of the system; (m) All irrigation emission devices shall meet the requirements set in the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) standard, ASABE/ICC 802-2014 "Landscape Irrigation Sprinkler and Emitter Standard authored by the American Society of Agricultural and Biological Engineers and the International Code Council and verified by an independent third-party; (n) Sprinklers within a zone shall have matched precipitation rates, unless otherwise directed by the manufacturer's recommendations; (o) Sprinkler spacing shall be designed to achieve the highest possible distribution uniformity using the manufacturer's recommendations. All sprinkler head installed in the turfgrass areas shall have a distribution uniformity of 0.65 or higher using the protocol defined in ASABE/ICC 802-2014 standard; (ii) The following table shall be provided on all landscape plans: Landscape Area Provided % of Lot/ Square Footage Should we mention zones etc. here? Page 9 Total irrigated area % of landscaped area/ square footage Spray area % of irrigated area/ square footage Drip area % of irrigated area/ square footage (iii) All irrigation shall be subject to the watering schedule as imposed by the Eagle River Water and Sanitation District (ERWSD). (iv) A rain sensor shall be installed with each new irrigation system. (v) Above ground Ttemporary sprinkler irrigation may be used to re-establish vegetation on otherwise non-irrigated portions of the landscaped areas; however, such temporary systems must be removed upon sufficient vegetation establishment as determined by the Director, which shall not exceed one (1) year for ground cover, two (2) years for shrubs or three (3) years for trees. (5) Revegetation Required: (i) All disturbed areas must be adequately reseeded and restored on all projects. A revegetation bond, satisfactory to the Director, must be furnished as a condition of certificate of occupancy and shall remain in full force and effect until the landscaping pl an is completed, vegetation is sufficiently established and structural best management practices (BMPs), such as silt fence and straw bales, are removed from the site. (ii) In all disturbed areas, soil must be prepared with tilling and the addition of dec omposed organic matter such as, but not limited to, compost, composted horse manure or composted chopped straw or hay. Straw tackifier or matting on steep slopes is required to prevent soil erosion. The addition of decomposed organic matter is also requ ired prior to turf installation. (6) Guarantee of Installation. Required landscape improvements shall be installed prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy for all structures. If weather conditions prevent installation, the property owner shall post a financial guarantee for the improvements. The guarantee shall be released upon completion and acceptance of the installation of the landscape improvements. (7) Maintenance. All landscape improvements shall be maintained and replaced by the property owner as necessary. All property owners shall be responsible for maintenance of landscape improvements within the public ROW between the back of curb or street pavements and the adjacent property. (Ord. 10-14 §3) Now included in Irrigation Plan Include more language on soil mods? 8.36.100 - Abatement of noxious weeds and diseased trees. (a) Entry and inspection. The Town shall have the right to enter upon any property for the purpose of inspection if verbal permission is granted by the property owner to enter such property. If verbal permission is not granted to the Town by the property owner, the Town shall have the right to enter upon any property after providing notice to the property owner by sending such notice via certified mail to the address of record according to the County Assessor's Office. In addition to sending notice of inspection by certified mail, the Town may send such notice by other practical means. If, after ten (10) days, the property owner does not respond or denies access, the Town may seek an inspection warrant in accordance with Section 35-5.5-108.5(4)(b), C.R.S. Upon obtaining a valid inspection warrant, the Town may enter the property between the hours of 7:00 a.m. and 8:00 p.m. (b) Notice of eradication of noxious weeds. If the Town finds the presence of noxious weeds upon inspection of the property, the Town shall provide a notice of eradication to the property owner. The notice of eradication shall be sent by certified mail to the address of record according to the County Assessor's Office. In addition to sending notice of eradication by certified mail, the Town may send such notice by other practical means. The notice of eradication shall name the noxious weeds, shall identify eradication as the required management objective, shall advise the property owner to commence eradication efforts with a specified period or condition, shall state the integrated noxious weed management techniques prescribed in the Town of Avon Noxious Weed Management Plan and shall advise the property owner that the property has five (5) days from the date of mailing notice of eradication to submit a plan and schedule acceptable to the Town for the completion of the management objective. (c) Eradication of noxious weeds by property owner. Within five (5) days after the Town sends the notice of eradication, the property owner shall comply with the terms of the notification of eradication or shall submit a plan and schedule which is acceptable to the Town for the completion of the management objective. An essential component of any plan and schedule for completion of the management objective shall be to eradicate noxious weeds prior to the seasonal time in which such noxious weeds create and disburse seeds or otherwise spread or propagate. Notice of correction of diseased trees. If the Town finds the presence of diseased trees which risk infecting other trees upon inspection of the property, the Town shall provide a notice stating the existing conditions and the necessary corrections to the property owner. The notice of correction shall be sent by certified mail to the address of record according to the County Assessor's Office. In addition to sending notice of eradication by certified mail, the Town may send such notice by other practical means. The notice of correction shall identify the impacted trees, shall advise the property owner of the management objective within a specified period or condition, and shall advise the property owner that the property has fifteenthirty (3015) days from the date of mailingreceiving notice of eradication to submit a plan and schedule acceptable to the Town for the completion of the management objective. Eradication of diseased trees by property owner. Within fifteenthirty (3015) days after the Town sends theproperty owner receives notice of correction, the property owner shall comply with the terms of the notification of correction or shall submit a plan and schedule which is acceptable to the Town for the completion of the management objective. An essential component of any plan a nd schedule for completion of the management objective shall be to limit the spread of infections to other trees and to preserve the esthetic of the Town. (d) Abatement. In the event the property owner fails to comply with the notice to eradicate correct the identified issue noxious weeds and implement an appropriate noxious weed eradication program or correction program for diseased trees, the Town may enter upon the property, take such actions as deemed necessary to eradicate the noxious weeds, or treat, or otherwise remove the diseased tree(s) and abate the public nuisance. The Town may assess the whole cost of eradication and abatement, including up to one hundred percent (100%) of inspection, eradication , treatment, and other incidental costs, including but not limited to administrative and legal costs. In addition, the Town may assess an additional five percent (5%) of the whole costs of eradication and abatement in Attachment B accordance with Section 31-15-401(1)(d), C.R.S. The assessment shall be a lien on the property and may be certified to the Clerk of the County Treasurer, who shall collect the assessment in the same manner as other taxes, in accordance with Sections 31-15-401 and 31-20-105, C.R.S. (Ord. 10-06 §3) Town of Avon Guidelines for Tree Removal This document is intended to serve as a template for approval of tree removal in the event that the 2:1 replacement protocol, as outlined in the Avon Municipal Code Chapter 7.28.050(h)(iv) is not feasible. Acceptable reasons for infeasibility include limited area for the number of trees required, risk of disease due to overcrowding, high fire danger, proximity to structures, or potential encroachments into easements. If a property is found to qualify under these circumstances or others determined by the Community Development Director, the applicant is expected to replace any given tree on the property with the equivalent or higher Landscape Unit rate for the tree’s retention, as defined in Table 7.28-7. For example, a deciduous tree with a 4-8 inch caliper is worth 14 Landscaping Units, and could be replaced by twelve (12) 5 gallon shrubs, worth 1.2 Landscaping Units each. Attachment C GREENCO PLANT LIST The Plant Water Use Category (VL = Very Low, L = Low; M = Medium; H = High) represents predicted evapotanspiration of the plant. Plants with similar water uses should be selected from the plant list provided in the “Green Industry Best Management Practices (BMPs) for the Conservation and Protection of Water Resources in Colorado: Moving Toward Sustainability” Appendix E, Third Release, May 2008. Species with similar water use should be grouped together, creating hydrozones where water application can be uniform. GreenCO’s Appendix E plant list categorizes plant water needs for various regions of Colorado based on elevation, including the East Slope (<6,500 ft), West Slope (6,500 to 8,500 ft), and Mountain Areas (>8,500 ft). Accordingly, Avon is located in the “West Slope” category. Relevant pages from the GreenCO Appendix E are included below. Applicant shall provide references for the Plant Water Use Category for any plant that is not included in this plant list. Attachment D East Slope West Slope All Regions Botanic Name Common Name Plant Type Mountain Abeliophyllum distichum Forsythia, White S M M Abies balsamea 'Nana' Fir, Dwarf Globe Balsam T M M M M Abies concolor Fir, White T M M M M Abies fraseri Fir, Fraser T M M M M Abies koreana 'Horstmann's Silberlocke' Fir, Silver Korean T M M M M Abies lasiocarpa Fir, Subalpine T M M M M Acer campestre Maple, Hedge T M L M M Acer ginnala Maple, Amur S T L L L L Acer glabrum Maple, Rocky Mountain S L L L L Acer grandidentatum Maple, Bigtooth S T L L L L Acer griseum Maple, Paperbark T M M M M Acer japonicum 'Aconitifolium' Maple, Cutleaf Fullmoon S H L M M Acer miyabei Maple, Miyabi T M M L M Acer negundo Box Elder T L M L L Acer nigrum 'Greencolumn' Maple, Greencolumn Black T M M M M Acer palmatum Maple, Japanese T M H H H Acer platanoides Maple, Norway T M M M M Acer pseudoplatanus Maple, Sycamore T M M M M Acer rubrum Maple, Red T M M M M Acer saccharinum Maple, Silver T M M M M Acer saccharum Maple, Sugar T M M M M Acer tataricum Maple, Tatarian S T L L L L Acer truncatum Maple, Shantung T M M M M Acer x freemanii Maple, Freeman T M M M M Achillea 'Coronation Gold' Yarrow, Golden Yellow P L L L L Achillea 'Moonshine' Yarrow, Moonshine P L L L L Achillea 'Summer Pastels' Yarrow, Mixed Pastels P L L L L Achillea ageratifolia Yarrow, Greek P L L L L Achillea filipendulina Yarrow, Tall Yellow P L L VL L Achillea lanulosa Yarrow, Wooly White P L L L L Achillea millefolium Yarrow, Common White P L L L L Achillea ptarmica 'The Pearl' Yarrow, The Pearl P L L L L Achillea serbica Yarrow, Serbian P L L L L Achillea tomentosa Yarrow, Wooly Yellow P L L L L Aconitum columbianum Monkshood, Columbian P H M H H Aconitum napellus Monkshood, Garden P M H H H Aconitum x cammarum Monkshood, Bicolor P M M Actinidia arguta Kiwi, Hardy P M M Actinidia kolomikta Kiwi, Variegated V M M Adiantum pedatum Fern, Western Maidenhair P H H H Aegopodium podograria Bishop's Weed GCP M M M M Aesculus glabra Buckeye, Ohio T M M M M Aesculus hippocastanum Horsechestnut T M M H M Aesculus octandra Buckeye, Yellow T M M L M Aesculus parviflora Buckeye, Bottlebrush S M M H M Aesculus x carnea Horsechestnut, Red T M M M M Aethionema coridifolium Stonecress, Lebanon P L M M L Aethionema grandiflorum Stonecress, Persian P L L L Agapanthus africanus Lily of the Nile A M M M Agastache 'Blue Fortune' Hyssop, Blue Fortune Anise P L L L L Agastache aurantiaca 'Coronado' Hyssop, Coronado P L L L L Agastache barberi Giant Hummingbird's Mint P L L L L Agastache cana Double Bubblemint P L L L L Agastache foeniculum Hyssop, Anise P L L L L Agastache rupestris Hyssop, Sunset P L L L L Ageratum houstonianum Ageratum A M L M M Agropyron cristatum Crested Wheatgrass TU L L L L Agrostis palustris Bentgrass TU H H H Ajania pacifica Daisy, Pacific P L L L L Ajuga genevensis 'Pink Beauty' Carpet Bugle, Pink Beauty GC M M L M Ajuga pyramidalis 'Metallica Crispa' Carpet Bugle, Pyramid GC M M M Ajuga reptans Carpet Bugle, Green GC M M M M Akebia quinata Chocolate Vine V M M Alcea rosea Hollyhock P L L L L Alchemilla alpina Lady's Mantle, Alpine P M L L M Alchemilla erythropoda Lady's Mantle, Red P M M M Alchemilla mollis Lady's Mantle P M M L M Allium cernuum Nodding Onion P L L L L Allium geyeri Geyer Onion P L L M L Allium schoenoprasum Chives P L M M L Alnus glutinosa Alder, Black S T H M M M Alnus rubra Alder, Red S H H H H Alnus tenuifolia Alder, Thinleaf S T M M M M Alyssum montanum 'Mountain Gold' Basket of Gold, Mountain P L L L L Alyssum sp. Alyssum A M L L M Amaranthus spp. Amaranth A L M L L Amelanchier alnifolia Serviceberry, Saskatoon S L L L L Amelanchier canadensis Serviceberry, Shadblow S T L L L L Amelanchier laevis Serviceberry, Allegheny S T M L L L Amelanchier lamarckii Serviceberry, Lamarck S T L L L L Amelanchier stolonifera Serviceberry, Running S L L L L Amelanchier utahensis Serviceberry, Utah S L L L L Amelanchier x grandiflora Serviceberry, Apple S T M L L L Amorpha canescens Leadplant S VL VL VL VL Amorpha fruticosa False Indigo S L L L L Amorpha nana Fragrant False Indigo S VL VL VL VL Ampelopsis brevipendunculata Porcelain Berry Vine V M M M Amsonia jonesii Jones' Bluestar P L M L Anacyclus pyrethrum var. depressus Daisy, Mt. Atlas P L L M L Anaphalis margaritacea Pearly Everlasting P L L L L Anchusa spp. Bugloss A P M L L M Andropogon gerardii Bluestem, Big P L L L L Andropogon saccharoides Bluestem, Silver P L L L L Anemone biarmiensis Anemone, Yellow P M M L M Anemone canadensis Anemone, Meadow P M M L M Anemone cylindrica Thimbleweed P M M M M Anemone multifida Windflower P M M M M Anemone sylvestris Anemone, Snowdrop P M L M M Anemone tomentosa 'Robustissima' Anemone, Grape-leaved P M M M M Anemone x hybrida Anemone, Hybrid P M M M M Angelonia spp. Summer Snapdragon A M M Antennaria dioica 'Rubra' Pussytoes, Pink P L VL VL L Antennaria parvifolia Pussytoes, Dwarf P L VL VL VL Anthemis marschalliana Daisy, Filigree P L L L Anthemis tinctoria Daisy, Marguerite P L L L L Antirrhinum majus Snapdragon A M L M M Aquilegia alpina Columbine, Alpine P M M L M Aquilegia barnebyi Columbine, Barneby's P L L M M Aquilegia caerulea Columbine, Rocky Mountain P M M M M Aquilegia canadensis Columbine, Dwarf Red P M M L M Aquilegia chrysantha Columbine, Yellow P L M L L Aquilegia cultivars Columbine P M M M M Aquilegia discolor Columbine, Spanish P M M M M Aquilegia elegantula Columbine, Dwarf Red P M M M M Aquilegia flabellata 'Kurilensis' Columbine, Compact Pink P M M M M Aquilegia formosa Columbine, Western Red P M M M M Aquilegia saximontana Columbine, Dwarf Blue P M M M M Aquilegia vulgaris Columbine, Garden P M M M M Arabis blepharophylla 'Spring Charm' Rockcress, Spring Charm P M L L L Arabis caucasica 'Snowcap' Rockcress, White Alpine P L L L L Arctostaphylos nevadensis Bearberry, Nevada GCP S L L L L Arctostaphylos patula Manzanita, Greenleaf S L L VL L Arctostaphylos uva- ursi Kinnikinnick GCP S L L L L Arenaria montana Sandwort, Mountain P L L L L Argyranthemum Marguerite Daisy A M M M Aristolochia durior Dutchman's Pipe V M M Armeria 'Victor Reiter' Sea Pinks, Victor Reiter P M L M M Armeria maritima Sea Pinks P M M M M Armeria pseudarmeria Sea Pinks, Wide-leaved P M L M Arnica cordifolia Arnica, Heartleaf P M L L M Aronia arbutifolia 'Brilliantissima' Chokeberry, Brilliant Red S M L L M Aronia melanocarpa Chokeberry, Black S L L L L Aronia x prunifolia Chokeberry, Purple S L L L L Artemisia 'Powis Castle' Sage, Powis Castle P L L L L Artemisia abrotanum Sage, Southernwood S L VL VL VL Artemisia absinthium Sage, Common Wormwood P VL VL VL VL Artemisia cana Sagebrush, Silver S VL VL VL VL Artemisia filifolia Sagebrush, Sand S VL VL VL VL Artemisia frigida Sage, Fringed P S VL VL VL VL Artemisia ludoviciana Sagewort, Prairie S VL VL VL VL Artemisia schmidtiana Sage, Silver Mound P L VL VL L Artemisia stellerana 'Silver Brocade' Sage, Silver Brocade P L L VL L Artemisia tridentata Sagebrush, Tall Western S VL VL VL VL Artemisia tripartita Sagebrush, Three Parted S VL VL VL VL Aruncus dioicus Goats Beard P M L M Arundo donax Grass, Giant Reed P M H M Asclepias incarnata Milkweed, Swamp P M H H M Asclepias speciosa Milkweed, Showy P L L L L Asclepias tuberosa Gay Butterfly P L L L L Aster 'Wood's Purple' Aster, Wood's Purple P M M M M Aster alpinus Aster, Alpine P L L L L Aster bigelovii Aster, Plains P L L M L Aster laevis Aster, Smooth P L L L L Aster novae-angliae Aster, New England P M M M M Aster novi-belgii Aster, Dwarf Fall P M M VL M Aster porteri Aster, Porter P L L L Aster tongolensis 'Wartburg Star' Aster, Purple P M L M Aster x frikartii 'Monch' Aster, Monch Frikart's P M L M M Astilbe chinensis False Spirea, Chinese P H M H H Astilbe x arendsii False Spirea P H M H H Astilbe x japonica False Spirea P H M M H Astilbe x simplicifolia ' False Spirea, Star P H M H H Astilbe x thunbergii False Spirea P H H H H Astrantia carniolica Masterwort, Giant P M H M Astrantia major Masterwort P M H M Athyrium filix-femina Fern, Lady P H H H H Athyrium nipponicum 'Pictum' Fern, Japanese Painted P H H M H Atriplex canescens Saltbush, Four Wing S VL VL VL VL Atriplex confertifolia Saltbush, Spiny S VL VL VL VL Atriplex corrugata Saltbush, Mat S VL VL VL VL Atriplex garderni Saltbush, Gardner's S VL VL VL VL Aubrieta deltoidea 'Purple Gem' Rockcress, Purple P L L L L Aubrieta x cultorum Rockcress, Hybrid P L M L Aurinia saxatilis 'Gold Ball' Basket-of-Gold Alyssum P L L L L Baccharis glutinosa Seep-Willow S L H H M Baccharis pilularis Coyote Brush S L H H M Bacopa spp. Water Hyssop A M M M Baileya multiradiata Desert Marigold P VL L L VL Baptisia australis False Indigo P L L L L Begonia semperflorens Wax Begonia A H H H Belamcanda chinensis Lily, Blackberry P L M L Bellis perennis Daisy, English A P M M M Bellium minutum Daisy, Miniature Mat P M M Berberis koreana Barberry, Korean S L L L L Berberis thunbergii Barberry, Japanese S L L L L Berberis x 'Tara' Barberry, Emerald Carousel S L L L L Berberis x gladwynensis 'William Penn' Barberry, William Penn S M L M M Berberis x mentorensis Barberry, Mentor S L L L L Bergenia cordifolia Bergenia, Heart-Leaved P M L M Berlandiera lyrata Chocolate Flower P L VL L L Betula 'Crimson Frost' Birch, Crimson Frost S T H H M H Betula fontinalis /occidentalis Birch, Native River S T H M M M Betula jacquemontii Birch, Himalayan White S T H M M H Betula maximowicziana Birch, Monarch Clump T H H H H Betula nigra Birch, River T H H M H Betula papyrifera Birch, Paper T H H M H Betula pendula Birch, Weeping T H H M H Betula platyphylla Birch, White T H H H H Betula x 'Rocky Mountain Splendor' Birch, Rocky Mt Splendor T M M H M Boltonia asteroides Boltonia P M L L M Bouteloua curtipendula Grass, Side Oats Grama P L L L L Bouteloua gracilis Grass, Blue Grama P TU VL VL VL VL Brachycome iberidifolia Daisy, Swan River A M M M Brassica oleracea Ornamental Cabbage or Kale A M M M Bromus inermis Smooth Brome TU L VL M L Browallia speciosa Bush Violet A M H M Brunnera macrophylla False Forget- Me-Not P M L M M Buchloe dactyloides Buffalograss TU VL VL VL VL Buddleja alternifolia Butterfly Bush, Alternate S L L L L Buddleja davidii Butterfly Bush S M L L M Buddleja x weyeriana Butterfly Bush, Yellow S M L L L Buxus microphylla Boxwood, Littleleaf S M M M M Buxus sempervirens Boxwood, Common S M M M M Calamagrostis acutiflora Grass, Feather Reed P L M M L Calamagrostis brachytricha Grass, Korean Feather Reed P L M M L Calandrinia umbellata 'Ruby Tuesday' Rock Purslane P L L Calendula officinalis Calendula A M M L M Callicarpa japonica Beautyberry, Japanese S M M M M Callirhoe alcaeoides 'Logan Calhoun' Prairie Winecups, White P L L L Callirhoe involucrata Prairie Winecups P L VL L L Calocedrus decurrens Cedar, Incense T M L L M Calochortus gunnisonii Mariposa Lily P VL VL L L Caltha leptosepala Marsh Marigold, White P H H H H Caltha palustris Marsh Marigold, Yellow P H H H H Calycanthus floridus Carolina Allspice S H H H H Calylophus hartwegii fendleri Sundrops, Fendler's P L VL L L Calylophus serrulatus Shrubby Evening Primrose P L L Campanula carpatica Harebell, Carpathian P M M M M Campanula cochleariifolia Bluebells, Little P M M M M Campanula garganica Bellflower, Greek P M M M M Campanula glomerata Bellflower, Clustered P M M M M Campanula lactiflora Bellflower, Milky P M L M Campanula medium Canterbury Bells A P M M H M Campanula persicifolia Bellflower, Peach-Leaved P M M M M Campanula portenschlagiana Bellflower, Dalmatian P M L M M Campanula poscharskyana Blue Bells, Adriatic P M L M M Campanula punctata 'Cherry Bells' Bellflower, Cherry Bells P M L M Campanula rotundifolia Harebell, Blue Native P L L L L Campsis radicans Trumpet Vine P V L L Campsis x tagliabuana Trumpet Vine P V L L Canna x generalis Canna A H H H H Caragana arborescens Peashrub, Siberian S L VL L L Caragana frutex Peashrub, Russian S L VL L L Caragana maximowicziana Peashrub, Maximowics S VL L L VL Caragana microphylla Peashrub, Littleleaf S VL VL L VL Caragana pygmaea Peashrub, Pygmy S L VL VL L Carex aquatilis Sedge, Water P H H H H Carex buchananii Sedge, Leatherleaf P M M M Carex comans Sedge, New Zealand Hair A M M Carex conica Sedge, Dwarf P M M M Carex elata Sedge, Tufted P M M H M Carex flacca Sedge, Blue Green P M M Carex flagelifera Sedge, Copperleaf P M H M Carex glauca Sedge, Blue P M M M Carex lanuginosa Sedge, Hairy P H H H H Carex morrowii Sedge, Japanese P M H M Carex muskingumensis Sedge, Palm P M H M Carex nebraskensis Sedge, Nebraska P H H H H Carex rostrata Sedge, Beaked P H H H H Carpinus betulus Hornbeam, European T M M M M Carpinus caroliniana Hornbeam, American T M M M M Carpinus japonica Hornbeam, Japanese T M M M M Caryopteris incana Spirea, Blue Mist S L L VL L Caryopteris x clandonensis Spirea, Blue Mist S L L VL L Castilleja integra Indian Paintbrush, Orange P L VL L L Castilleja linariaefolia Indian Paintbrush, Wyoming P L VL L L Castilleja miniata Indian Paintbrush, Scarlet P L VL M L Castilleja rhexifolia Indian Paintbrush, Rose P L VL H L Catalpa ovata Catalpa, Chinese T M L L L Catalpa speciosa Catalpa, Western T L L L L Catananche caerulea Cupid's Dart P L L L Catharanthus roseus Periwinkle, Madagascar A L L L L Ceanothus fendleri Deerbrush S L VL L L Ceanothus gloriosus Point Reyes Creeper S L L L L Ceanothus velutinus Snowbrush S L M M M Cedrus deodora Cedar, Deodar T M M L L Cedrus libani atlantica Cedar, Blue Atlas T M M M M Celastrus scandens American Bittersweet S V L L L L Celosia argentea plumosa Cockscomb A M M L M Celtis laevigata Sugarberry T L L L L Celtis occidentalis Hackberry, Western T L L L L Celtis reticulata Hackberry, Canyon S T L L L L Centaurea cyanus Bachelor Button A L L L L Centaurea dealbata Bachelor Button, Pink P L L L L Centaurea montana Bachelor Button, Perennial P M VL M L Centranthus ruber Valerian, Red P L L L L Cerastium alpinum lanatum Wooly Cerastium P L L L Cerastium arvense Chickweed, Mouse-ear P L L L L Cerastium tomentosum Snow-In- Summer P L VL VL L Ceratostigma plumbaginoides Plumbago P L M L Cercidiphyllum japonicum Katsura Tree T M H H M Cercis canadensis Redbud, Eastern S T M M L M Cercocarpus breviflorus Mountain Mahogany, Little Flowe S VL VL VL VL Cercocarpus ledifolius Mountain Mahogany, Curlleaf S T VL VL VL VL Cercocarpus montanus Mountain Mahogany, Common S T VL VL VL VL Chaenomeles japonica Quince, Japanese Flowering S M L L L Chaenomeles speciosa Quince, Flowering S M L L L Chaenomeles x superba Quince, Hybrid Flowering S L L L L Chamaebatiaria millefolium Fernbush S VL VL VL VL Chamaecyparis obtusa Cypress, Hinoki S M M M M Chamaecyparis pisifera Cypress, Japanese False T M L L M Chamaemelum nobile Chamomile P L L M L Chamerion angustifolium Fireweed P L L L L Chasmanthium latifolium Sea Oats, Northern P M M M Chilopsis linearis Desert Willow S L VL L L Chionanthus retusus Fringe Tree, Chinese S T M L L M Chionanthus virginicus Fringe Tree, White S T M L M M Chitalpa tashkentensis Chitalpa S L L L L Chrysanthemum x morifolium Garden Mum P M M M M Chrysothamnus nauseosus Rabbitbrush S VL VL VL VL Chrysothamnus viscidiflorus Rabbitbrush, Sticky S VL VL VL VL Cimicifuga racemosa Black Snakeroot P M M M Cimicifuga simplex 'White Pearl' White Bottlebrush P M M M Cladrastis lutea Yellowwood T M M L M Clematis alpina Clematis, Alpine P V M M M Clematis columbiana Clematis, Columbian Virgin's Bow P V M M M Clematis cultivars Clematis P V M L M M Clematis hirsutissima Clematis, Woolly P L VL L L Clematis integrifolia Clematis, Bush P M L M Clematis ligusticifolia Clematis, Western Virgin's Bower P V L VL L L Clematis montana rubens Clematis, Pink Anemone P V M M Clematis paniculata Clematis, Spring P V M M M M Clematis pitcheri Clematis, Purple Leatherflower P V M M Clematis tangutica Clematis, Yellow Lantern P V L L L Clematis terniflora Clematis, Sweet Autumn P V L L M L Clematis texensis Clematis, Scarlet P M M Clematis virginiana Clematis, Virgin's Bower P V L H M Clematis viticella Clematis, Italian P V M M Cleome hassleriana Spiderflower A M M H M Cleome serrulata Rocky Mountain Beeplant A L L L L Clethra alnifolia Summersweet S H H H H Coleus spp. Coleus A M M M Colutea arborescens Bladder Pod S L L M L Convallaria majalis Lily-of-the- Valley GCP M M M M Coreopsis 'Limerock Ruby' Coreopsis, Limerock Ruby P M M Coreopsis auriculata Coreopsis, Eared P L VL L Coreopsis grandiflora Coreopsis, Large-flowered P L L L L Coreopsis lanceolata Coreopsis, Lance-leaf P L L L L Coreopsis rosea Coreopsis, Pink P M L L M Coreopsis tinctoria Coreopsis, Plains A L L L L Coreopsis verticillata Coreopsis, Thread Leaf P L L L L Cornus alba Dogwood, Tatarian S M M M M Cornus alternifolia Dogwood, Pagoda S T M M M M Cornus anomum Dogwood, Silky S M H H H Cornus canadensis Dogwood, Bunchberry S M M M M Cornus florida Dogwood, Flowering T H H M M Cornus kousa Dogwood, Kousa S T M H M M Cornus mas Dogwood, Cornelian Cherry S T M M M M Cornus pumila Dogwood, Dwarf Red Tipped S M H H M Cornus racemosa Dogwood, Gray S T M M M M Cornus sericea (stolonifera) Dogwood, Redosier S M M H M Cornus stolonifera 'Kelseyi' Dogwood, Kelsey Dwarf S M M M M Cortaderia selloana Grass, Pampas P L L Corylus americana Filbert, American T M M M M Corylus avellana 'Contorta' Harry Lauder's Walkingstick S M M M M Corylus colurna Filbert, Turkish T L M L L Corylus cornuta Filbert, Beaked S M M M M Cosmos bipinnatus Cosmos A L L L L Cotinus coggygria Smoke Tree S M L L M Cotoneaster adpressa praecox Cotoneaster, Creeping S M M L M Cotoneaster apiculatus Cotoneaster, Cranberry S L M L L Cotoneaster congestus Cotoneaster, Pyrenees S L L L L Cotoneaster dammeri Cotoneaster, Bearberry S M M L M Cotoneaster divaricatus Cotoneaster, Spreading S L L L L Cotoneaster glaucophyllus Cotoneaster, Grey S L L L L Cotoneaster horizontalis Cotoneaster, Rock S M L L M Cotoneaster lacteus /parneyi Cotoneaster, Parney's Red S M L L M Cotoneaster lucidus /acutifolius Cotoneaster, Peking S L L L L Cotoneaster multiflorus Cotoneaster, Many Flowered S L L L L Cotoneaster nanshan Cotoneaster, Creeping S L L L L Cowania mexicana Cliffrose S VL VL VL VL Crambe cordifolia Colewort P M M Crataegus 'Skinner Dwarf' Hawthorn, Skinner Dwarf T L L L L Crataegus ambigua Hawthorn, Russian S T L L L L Crataegus arnoldiana Hawthorn, Arnold T M L L L Crataegus chrysocarpa Hawthorn, Fire Berry S T L L L L Crataegus crus-galli Hawthorn, Cockspur S T L L L L Crataegus crus-galli 'Inermis' Hawthorn, Thornless Cockspur S T L L L L Crataegus douglassii Hawthorn, Douglas S T L L L L Crataegus laevigata Hawthorn, English T M L L L Crataegus mollis Hawthorn, Downy S T L L L L Crataegus phaenopyrum Hawthorn, Washington S T L L L L Crataegus punctata Hawthorn, Thicket T L L L Crataegus rivularis Hawthorn, River S T M L L L Crataegus succulenta Hawthorn, Colorado S T L L L L Crataegus x mordenensis Hawthorn, Morden T L L L L Cuphea spp. Cigar Flower A M M M Cupressocyparis leylandii Cypress, Leyland T M L L M Cupressus arizonica Cypress, Arizona T L L L L Cytisus purgans 'Spanish Gold' Broom, Spanish Gold S L VL L L Cytisus scoparius Broom, Scotch S L L L L Cytisus x praecox Broom, Warminster S L L L L Dahlia pinnata Dahlia A M M M Dalea formosa Indigo Bush P L L Dalea purpurea Clover, Purple Prairie P L M L Daphne cneorum Daphne, Rose S M L M M Daphne x burkwoodi Daphne, Burkwood S M L M M Dasylirion wheeleri Sotol Yucca S L L M L Datura sp. Angel's Trumpet A L M L Davidia involucrata Dove Tree T M M M M Delosperma Mesa Verde Iceplant, Mesa Verde P L L L L Delosperma Table Mountain Iceplant, Table Mountain P L L L L Delosperma cooperi Iceplant, Purple P L L L L Delosperma floribundum 'Starburst' Iceplant, Starburst P L L L L Delosperma nubigenum Iceplant, Yellow Hardy P L L L L Delphinium grandiflorum Larkspur, Chinese P M M L M Delphinium nelsonii Larkspur, Nelson P L M M L Delphinium species Larkspur, P M M M M Delphinium x Pacific Giant Larkspur, Mixed P M M M M Dendranthema weyrichii 'Pink Bomb' Daisy, Pink Bomb P M M M M Dendranthema x rubellum 'Clara Curtis' Daisy, Rose Pink P M M M M Deschampsia cespitosa Grass, Tufted Hair P M M H M Deutzia gracilis Deutzia, Slender S M M M M Dianthus anatolicus Pinks, Anatolian P L L L L Dianthus barbatus Sweet William P M L M M Dianthus caryophyllus Carnation, Hardy P M L L M Dianthus cultivars Pinks A P M L L M Dianthus deltoides Pinks, Maiden P M L L M Dianthus graniticus Pinks, Granite P M L M M Dianthus gratianopolitanus Pinks, Pincushion P M L L M Dianthus plumarius (lumnitzer) Pinks, Cottage P M L L M Dianthus x chinensis Border Pink A M L M Diascia barberae Twinspur A M L L Diascia integerrima 'Coral Canyon' Twinspur, Coral Canyon A P L L L L Dicentra eximia Bleeding Heart, Fringed P M H H M Dicentra formosa Bleeding Heart, Fringed P M M M M Dicentra spectabilis Bleeding Heart, Old Fashioned P M M M M Dictamnus albus Gas Plant P M M Diervilla lonicera Honeysuckle, Bush S L L L L Digitalis 'Mertonensis' Foxglove, Perennial Pink P M M M M Digitalis grandiflora Foxglove, Perennial Yellow P M L M M Digitalis purpurea Foxglove, Common P M M M M Digitalis thapsi Foxglove, Spanish P M M M M Dodecatheon pulchellum Shooting Star P M M M Doronicium grandiflorum Leopard's Bane P M L L M Draba hispanica Draba, Spanish P L L Dracocephalum botryoides Dragonhead, Evergreen P L L Dryopteris dilatata Fern, Broad Buckler P H H Dryopteris erythrosora Fern, Autumn P M M M Dryopteris filix-mas Fern, Leatherwood Male P M M M Dryopteris marginalis Fern, Leatherwood P H H Duchesnea indica Strawberry, Mock P L L L L Dyssodia tenuiloba Daisy, Dahlberg A L L Echinacea angustifolia Coneflower, Narrow Leaf Purple P L L L L Echinacea purpurea Coneflower, Purple P L L M L Echinops ritro Globe Thistle P L L L L Elaeagnus commutata Silverberry S L L L L Eleagnus umbellata Autumn Olive S T L VL L L Ephedra torreyana Joint Fir, Torrey S VL VL VL VL Ephedra viridis Mormon Tea S VL VL VL VL Epilobium fleischeri Willowherb, Alpine P M L L M Epimedium x cantabrigiense Bishop's Hat P M M Equisetum hyemale Rush, Scouring P H H H Eragrostis trichodes Grass, Sand Love P L L L Erica carnea (herbacea) Heath, Winter P M M Erigeron compositus Daisy, Cut- Leaf P L VL VL L Erigeron divergens Daisy, Spreading P L VL L L Erigeron flagelleris Daisy, Whiplash P L VL L L Erigeron speciosus Fleabane, Showy P L L L L Erigeron subtrinervis Fleabane, Three-nerved P L L L Erigeron vetensis Daisy, Early Bluetop P L L L Eriogonum jamesii Sulphur Flower, Creamy P L L L L Eriogonum umbellatum Sulphur Flower P VL L VL VL Erodium reichardii Heron's Bill P M L M Eryngium alpinum 'Superbum' Sea Holly P L L L L Eryngium amethystinum Sea Holly, Amethyst P L L L L Eryngium planum 'Blaukappe' Sea Holly, Blue Cap P L L L L Eryngium variifolium Sea Holly, Moroccan P L L L L Eryngium yuccifolium Button- Snakeroot P L L L L Erysimum asperum Wallflower P L M L L Erysimum kotschyanum Wallflower, Alpine P M M M M Eschscholzia californica Poppy, California P L VL L L Euonymus alatus Burning Bush S M M M M Euonymus europaeus Spindle Tree S T M M M M Euonymus fortunei 'Coloratus' Wintercreeper, Purpleleaf GCP L L M L Euonymus fortuneii Euonymus S M M M M Euonymus kewensis Eyonymus, Kew GC M M M Euonymus kiautschovica 'Manhattan' Euonymus, Manhattan S M M M M Eupatorium purpureum Joe-Pye Weed P M M Euphorbia amygdaloides Spurge, Wood P L VL L L Euphorbia polychroma Spurge, Cushion P L L L Eurotia lanata Winterfat S VL VL VL VL Fagus sylvatica Beech, European T M H M M Fallopia japonica compacta Fleeceflower, Dwarf P L VL VL L Fallugia paradoxa Apache Plume S VL VL VL VL Fendlera rupicola Mockorange, False S VL VL VL VL Festuca arundinacea Tall Fescue TU M M M M Festuca glauca Fescue, Blue P L L L L Festuca idahoensis Fescue, Idaho P L M L Festuca ovina Fescue, Sheep P TU L M M L Festuca ovina duriuscula Hard Fescue TU M H H M Festuca rubra Fescue, Red TU M M H M Festuca rubra commutata Fescue, Chewings P TU L H H M Filipendula rubra Meadowsweet P M M Filipendula ulmaria Meadow Sweet P M M Forestiera neomexicana Privet, New Mexico S L VL VL L Forsythia cultivars Forsythia S M M M M Forsythia viridissima 'Broxensis' Forsythia, Dwarf S M M L M Forsythia x intermedia Forysthia S M M M M Fothergilla gardenii Fothergilla, Dwarf S M L L M Fothergilla major Fothergilla, Large S M VL L M Fragaria americana Strawberry, Wild GCP L L L L Fragaria cultivars Strawberry GCP M M M M Fragaria vesca Strawberry, Runnerless GCP M M M Fragaria virginiana glauca Strawberry, Scarlet P L M M Frasera speciosa Gentian, Green P M H M Fraxinus americana Ash, White T M M M M Fraxinus angustifolia 'Raywood' Ash, Raywood T M M M M Fraxinus anomala Ash, Single- Leaf S T L L L L Fraxinus excelsior Ash, European T M M M M Fraxinus latifolia Ash, Oregon T M M M M Fraxinus mandshurica 'Mancana' Ash, Mancana Manchurian T M M M M Fraxinus nigra Ash, Black T M M M M Fraxinus pennsylvanica Ash, Green T M M M M Fraxinus quadrangulata Ash, Blue T M M M M Fraxinus velutina Ash, Arizona T M M L M Gaillardia aristata Blanket Flower, Native P L VL L L Gaillardia x grandiflora Blanket Flower P L VL L L Galium boreale Northern Bedstraw P L L Galium odoratum Sweet Woodruff P M L VL M Gaura lindheimeri Whirling Butterflies P L L L Gazania krebsiana Tanager Gazania, Orange Hardy A P L L L Gazania linearis 'Colorado Gold' Gazania, Colorado Gold Hardy P L L L Gazania rigens Treasure Flower A L L L Genista pilosa 'Vancouver Gold' Broom, Vancouver Gold S L L L L Genista tinctoria 'RoyalGold' Woadwaxen, Royal Gold S L L L L Gentiana affinis Gentian, Northern Pleated P M H M Gentiana cachemirica Gentian, Himalayan P M M Gentiana calycosa Gentian, Explorer's P M L L Gentiana septemfida lagodechiana Gentian, Crested P M H M Geranium caespitosum Cranesbill, Purple Wild P L M L Geranium cinereum 'Ballerina' Cranesbill, Ballerina Grayleaf P M M M Geranium cultivars Cranesbill P M M M M Geranium dalmaticum Cranesbill, Compact Rose P M M M Geranium endressii 'Wargrave Pink' Cranesbill, Pink P M M M M Geranium himalayense Cranesbill, Lilac P M M M Geranium macrorrhizum Cranesbill, Adriatic P L VL L L Geranium maculatum Geranium, Wild P L M M Geranium magniflorum La Veta Lace Geranium, La Veta Lace P M M Geranium platypetalum Cranesbill, Broad-petaled P M M M Geranium psilostemon Cranesbill, Armenian P M M M Geranium sanguineum Cranesbill, Bloody P M L M M Geranium viscosissimum Geranium, Sticky P L L M L Geranium x cantabrigiense Cranesbill, Cambridge GCP L M M M Geranium x magnificum Cranesbill, Showy P M M M M Geranium x oxonianum 'Claridge Druce' Cranesbill, Lilac Pink P M L M Geum chiloense Avens, Chilean P M M L M Geum coccineum 'Borisii' Avens, Orange P M L M Geum triflorum Avens, Prairie Smoke P L M L L Ginkgo biloba Maidenhair Tree T M M M M Glechoma hederacea Ivy, Ground GCP M L M Gleditsia triacanthos inermis Honeylocust, Thornless T L L L L Globularia cordifolia Daisy, Dwarf Globe GCP L L L Gomphrene globosa Globe Amaranth A L L L Grindelia squarrosa Gumweed, Curly-cupped P L VL L Gutierrezia sarothrae Snakeweed P VL VL L VL Gymnocarpium dryopteris Fern, Oak P L L Gymnocladus dioica Kentucky Coffeetree T L L L L Gypsophila paniculata Baby's Breath P L M VL L Gypsophila repens Baby's Breath, Creeping P L M L M Hakonechloa macra Grass, Japanese Forest P H H Hamamelis vernalis Witchhazel, Vernal S T M M M M Hamamelis virginiana Witchhazel, Common S T M M M M Haplopappus glutinosus Golden Star P L VL L Hebe albicans Hebe P M M Hedera helix Ivy, English V M L M M Helenium autumnale Sneezeweed P M M L M Helianthemum Sunrose P L M L L Helianthus maximiliana Sunflower, Maximilian P L L VL L Helianthus pumilus Sunflower, Dwarf P L L Helichrysum bracteatum Strawflower A L L L Helichrysum sibthorpii Everlasting P L L Helictotrichon sempervirens Grass, Blue Avena P L L M L Heliopsis helianthoides False Sunflower P M L M Heliotropium arborscens Heliotrope A M M M M Helleborus argutifolius Hellebore P M M Helleborus orientalis Lenten Rose P M M M Hemerocallis Daylily P L L M L Hesperaloe parviflora Yucca, Red S VL VL VL VL Heterotheca horrida Aster, Golden P L L Heterotheca villosa Aster, Hairy Golden P L VL L Heuchera americana Coral Bells, American P M M M Heuchera cultivars Coral Bells P M L M M Heuchera micrantha Coral Bells, Smallflowered P M M M Heuchera sanguinea Coral Bells P M M M M Heuchera x brizoides Coral Bells, Hybrid P M M Heucherella alba Heucherella, White P M M M Hibiscus moscheutos Rose Mallow P M M Hibiscus syriacus Althea S M M M M Hieracium lanatum Hawkweed, Felted P L L L Hierochloe odorata Grass, Indian Sweet P L L Hippophae rhamnoides Sea Buckthorn S T L VL VL L Holodiscus discolor Ocean-Spray S L VL VL L Holodiscus dumosus Rock Spirea S L VL VL L Hosta cultivars Hosta P M L M M Hosta sieboldiana Hosta, Sieboldiana P M M M M Hosta x fortunei Hosta, Fortunei P M M M Hosta x tardiana 'Halcyon' Hosta, Halcyon P M M Hosta x undulata Hosta, Wavy P M M M M Houttuynia cordata 'Chameleon' Chameleon Plant P M M Humulus lupulus neomexicanus Hop Vine, Native P V L L L L Hydrangea anomala Hydrangea, Climbing S M L L M Hydrangea anomala petiolaris Hydrangea, Climbing V M M Hydrangea arborescens 'Annabelle' Hydrangea, Annabelle Smooth S M M M M Hydrangea macrophylla Hydrangea, Bigleaf S M M M M Hydrangea paniculata Hydrangea, Panicle S M L L M Hydrangea quercifolia Hydrangea, Oakleaf S M L L M Hymenoxys acaulis Daisy, Angelita P L L L Hypericum 'Hidcote' St. John's Wort, Hidcote P S M L L M Hypericum calycinum St. John's Wort, Mounding GCP M M M Hypericum kalmianum St. John's Wort, Kalm S L M L M Hypericum patulum St. John's Wort, Goldencup P M M M Hypericum reptans St. John's Wort, Creeping GCP L M L Hyssopus officinalis Hyssop P L L Iberis gibraltarica Candytuft, Lilac GCP L M L Iberis sempervirens Candytuft, Evergreen GCP L M M L Ilex glabra 'Compacta' Holly, Compact Inkberry S M M M M Ilex x meserveae Holly, Blue S M M M M Ilex x verticillata 'Winter Red' Holly, Winter Red S H M M M Impatiens wallerana Impatiens A H H M H Imperata cylindrica 'Red Baron' Grass, Japanese Blood P M M Incarvillea delavayi Gloxinia, Hardy P M M Ipomea batatas Sweet Potato Vine A M L M Ipomopsis aggregata Gilia, Scarlet P L L L L Ipomopsis candida Fairy Trumpet, White P L L L Iris ensata (kaempheri) Iris, Japanese P M M M M Iris missouriensis Iris, Western Blue Flag P M L L L Iris orientalis Iris, Yellow Butterfly P L L Iris pallida 'Variegata' Iris, Variegated Sweet P L M L Iris pseudacorus Iris, Yellow Flag P M H M Iris setosa artica Iris, Dwarf Blue Flag P M M M Iris siberica Iris, Siberian P M L L M Iris x germanica Iris, Bearded P L L L L Iris x pumila Iris, Dwarf Bearded P L M M L Itea virginica Sweetspire S M M M M Jamesia americana Waxflower S L L L L Jasminum fruticans Jasmine, Evergreen Yellow P M M Juglans nigra Walnut, Black T L L L L Juncus balticus Rush, Baltic P H H H Juncus compressus Rush, Round- fruit P H H H Juncus effusus Rush, Corkscrew P H H H Juncus torreyi Rush, Torrey P H H H Juniperus chinensis Juniper, Chinese S T L L L L Juniperus communis Juniper, Common S L L L L Juniperus horizontalis Juniper, Creeping S L L L L Juniperus monosperma Juniper, One Seed S T VL VL VL VL Juniperus procumbens Juniper, Japanese Garden S L L L L Juniperus sabina Juniper, Savin S L L L L Juniperus scopulorum Juniper, Rocky Mountain S T VL VL VL VL Juniperus squamata Juniper, Flaky S L L L L Juniperus utahensis Juniper, Utah S T VL VL VL VL Juniperus virginiana Juniper, Eastern Red Cedar T L L L L Juniperus x media Juniper, Hybrid Spreading S L L L L Kerria japonica 'Pleniflora' Kerria, Japanese S M L L M Knautia macedonica Knautia, Purple P L M L Kniphofia Torch Lily P L L L Koelreuteria paniculata Golden Rain Tree T L L L L Kolkwitzia amabilis Beauty Bush S L L L L Laburnum x watereri Golden-Chain Tree T M H M M Lamiastrum galeobdolon Yellow archangel GCP M M M M Lamium maculatum Nettle, Spotted GCP M M M M Lantana spp. Lantana A L L L Larix decidua Larch, European T M M M M Lathyrus latifolius Sweet Pea, Perennial P L L L Lathyrus odoratus Sweet Pea, Annual A M M M Lavandula angustifolia Lavender, English P L L L L Lavandula dentata Lavender, French P L L Lavandula x intermedia Lavender, Hybrid P L L Lavatera thuringiaca Shrub Mallow P L M M L Leontopodium alpinum Edelweiss P L M L L Lespedeza thunbergii Japanese Bush-clover P L L Leucanthemum x superbum Daisy, Shasta P M M M M Lewisia cotelydon Bitterroot P L L L L Leymus arenarius 'Glauca' Grass, Blue Lyme P L L Liatris punctata Gayfeather, Native P L L L L Liatris pycnostachya Gayfeather, Thickspike P L L Liatris spicata Gayfeather, Spike P L L L L Ligularia dentata 'Othello' Groundsel, Golden P H H Ligularia przewalskii Groundsel, Shavalski's P H H Ligularia stenocephala 'The Rocket' Ragwort, The Rocket P H H Ligustrum obtusifolium 'Regalianum' Privet, Regal S L L L L Ligustrum vulgare Privet, Common S L L L L Ligustrum x vicaryi Privet, Golden Vicary S M M M M Lilium cultivars Lily cultivars P M M M Limonium latifolium Sea Lavender, Wide-leaved P L L Limonium sinuatum Statice A L L L L Linum flavum Flax, Yellow P L L L Linum perenne Flax, Blue P L VL VL L Liquidambar styraciflua Sweetgum, American T M M L M Liriodendron tulipifera Tulip Tree T M M L M Liriope muscari Lily Turf A M M M Lithospermum incisum Puccoon, Narrow-leaf P L L Lithospermum multiflorum Puccoon, Many-flowered P L L Lobelia cardinalis Cardinal Flower P H L H Lobelia fulgens 'Queen Victoria' Lobelia, Scarlet P M M Lobelia sp. Lobelia A M M M Lobularia martitma Sweet Alyssum A M M Lolium perenne Perennial Ryegrass TU M M H M Lonicera caerulea edulis Honeysuckle, Bearberry S M L L M Lonicera fragrantissima Honeysuckle, Winter S M L L M Lonicera involucrata Honeysuckle, Twinberry S M L L M Lonicera japonica Honeysuckle, Japanese S V L M L L Lonicera korolkowii v. floribunda 'Blue Velv Honeysuckle, Blue Velvet Bluelea S L L L L Lonicera periclymenum Woodbine, Yellow Flowering V M M Lonicera sempervirens 'Magnifica' Honeysuckle, Scarlet Trumpet V M L L M Lonicera syringantha 'Wolfii' Honeysuckle, Tiny Trumpet S M L L M Lonicera tartarica 'Arnold's Red' Honeysuckle, Arnold's Red Tartar S L L L L Lonicera x 'Honeyrose' Honeysuckle, Honeyrose S M M L M Lonicera x brownii 'Dropmore Scarlet' Honeysuckle, Dropmore Scarlet B V M L L M Lonicera x heckrotti 'Goldflame' Honeysuckle, Goldflame P S V M L L M Lonicera x xylosteoides Honeysuckle, European Fly S L L L L Lunaria annua Money Plant A L L L Lupinus Lupine P M L L M Lupinus argenteus Lupine, Silvery P L L L Lychnis chalcedonica Maltese Cross P M M L M Lychnis coronaria Rose Campion P L M VL L Lysimachia clethroides Loosestrife, Gooseneck P M H M Lysimachia nummularia Moneywort P M H M M Lysimachia punctata Loosestrife, Yellow P M M M Maackia amurensis Amur Maackia T M M L M Machaeranthera bigelovii Aster, Santa Fe P L L L Machaeranthera pattersoni Aster, Patterson P L L Macleaya cordata Poppy, Plume P M M Macleaya microcarpa Poppy, Plume P M M Magnolia grandiflora Magnolia, Large-flowered S M M M M Magnolia kobus Magnolia, Kobus S M M M M Magnolia stellata Magnolia, Star S T M M M M Magnolia virginiana Magnolia, Sweetbay S M M M M Magnolia x loebneri Magnolia, Loebner S M M M M Magnolia x soulangiana Magnolia, Saucer S T M M M M Mahonia aquifolium Oregon Grape Holly S L L L L Mahonia fremonti Fremont Holly Grape S L VL L VL Mahonia repens Creeping Colorado Holly GCP S L L L L Malus crabapple Crabapple T M M L M Malus sylvestris Apple, Orchard T M L L M Malus x zumi 'Calocarpa' Crab, Zumi T M L L M Malva alcea 'Fastigiata' Hollyhock, Miniature P M M L M Marrubium rotundifolium Horehound, Silvery GCP VL VL Matteuccia struthiopteris Fern, Ostrich P H M H Mazus reptans Mazus GCP M M Melampodium leucanthum Daisy, Blackfoot P L VL VL Melinis (Rhynchelytrum) nerviglumis Grass, Ruby A M M M Mentha requienii Mint, Corsican P L L Mentha spicata Spearmint P M M M Mentzelia decapetala Evening-star P VL VL Mertensia lanceolata Chiming Bells P M M Mertensia virginica Bluebells P M H M Metasequoia glyptostroboides Redwood, Dawn T M M M M Microbiota decussata Cypress, Siberian S M L M M Mimulus cardinalis Monkey Flower, Scarlet P H H Mimulus guttatus Monkey Flower, Yellow P H H H Mimulus lewisii Monkey Flower, Pink P M H M Mimulus spp. Monkey Flower, Annual A H H H Mirabilis jalapa Four O'Clock, Annual A L L VL L Mirabilis multiflora Four-O'-Clock, Desert P VL VL VL VL Miscanthus floridulus Grass, Giant Chinese Silver P M M Miscanthus sinensis Grass, Maiden P M L M M Molinia caerulea Grass, Purple Moor P M L M Molucella laevis Bells of Ireland A M M M Monarda didyma Bee-Balm P M L L M Monarda fistulosa menthaefolia Bee-Balm, Native Lavender P L L L L Moneses uniflora One-Flowered Wintergreen P M H M Morus alba Mulberry T M M M M Muhlengergia capillaris Grass, Muhly P L M L Myosotis alpestris Forget-Me-Not P M M M M Myrica pennsylvanica Bayberry S M L L M Nandina domestica Bamboo, Heavenly S M M M M Nepeta racemosa Catmint P L L L Nepeta x faassenii Catmint, Faassen's P L L VL L Nicotiana spp. Flowering Tobacco A M M M Nierembergia hippomanica Cup Flower A M M M Nolina microcarpa Grass, Bear P L M L Nyssa sylvatica Sourgum T H H M M Ocimum basilicum Basil A M M M Oenothera berlandieri 'Siskiyou' Primrose, Siskiyou P L VL L L Oenothera brachycarpa Primrose, Leatherleaf P L VL M L Oenothera caespitosa Primrose, White Evening P VL VL L VL Oenothera fruticosa glauca Sundrops P L VL M L Oenothera macrocarpa Primrose, Missouri Evening P L VL M L Oenothera speciosa 'Rosea' Primrose, New Mexico Evening P L VL L L Oenothera strigosa Evening Primrose, Common P L VL L Opuntia polyacantha Cactus, Prickly Pear P VL VL VL Origanum lavevigatum 'Herrenhausen' Oregano, Purple P L L Origanum vulgare Oregano, Common P L M L Oryzopsis hymenoides Grass, Indian Rice P L VL L L Osteospermum 'Lavender Mist' Sun Daisy, Lavender Mist P L VL L Osteospermum barberiae compactum 'Purp Sun Daisy, Purple Mountain P L VL L Ostrya virginiana American Hophornbeam T M M M M Oxytropis lambertii Loco Weed, Lambert's P VL L L Pachysandra terminalis Spurge, Japanese GCP M M M M Paeonia lactiflora Peony P M M M M Panicum virgatum Grass, Switch P L L M L Papaver alpinum Poppy, Alpine P M L L L Papaver miyabeanum Poppy, Japanese Alpine P M M M Papaver nudicaule Poppy, Iceland P M L M M Papaver orientale Poppy, Oriental P L L M L Parrotia persica Persian Parrotia T M M L M Parthenocissus quinquefolia Virginia Creeper V L L L L Parthenocissus tricuspidata Ivy, Boston P V M M M Paxistima canbyi Mountain Lover P L L M M Paxistima myrtifolia Mountain Lover P L M L Pedicularis groenlandica Elephant's Head P M H H Pelargonium hybrids Geranium A M M M Pennisetum alopecuroides Grass, Fountain P L L L Pennisetum orientale Grass, Oriental Fountain P L L L Pennisetum setaceum Grass, Annual Fountain A M L M Penstemon 'Elfin Pink' Penstemon, Pink P L VL L L Penstemon 'Hyacinth Flowered' Penstemon, Hyacinth Flowered P M M Penstemon acuminatus Penstemon, Sand Dune P L L Penstemon alpinus Penstemon, Alpine P L L L L Penstemon ambiguus Penstemon, Sand P VL L VL Penstemon angustifolius Penstemon, Narrowleaf P VL VL Penstemon attenuatus Penstemon, Taper-leaved P L L Penstemon barbatus Penstemon, Scarlet Bugler P L VL L L Penstemon caespitosus Penstemon, Mat P L L L L Penstemon cardinalis Penstemon, Crimson P L VL M L Penstemon clutei Penstemon, Sunset P L L L Penstemon cyananthus Penstemon, Wasatch P L L L Penstemon davidsonii Penstemon, Davidson's P L L Penstemon deustus Penstemon, Hotrock P VL VL VL Penstemon digitalis 'HuskerRed' Penstemon, Husker Red P L VL M L Penstemon eatonii Penstemon, Firecracker P L VL M L Penstemon ellipticus Penstemon, Rockvine P VL VL Penstemon fruticosus Penstemon, Shrubby P L L Penstemon glaber Penstemon, Saw-sepal P L L Penstemon gracilis Penstemon, Slender P L L Penstemon grandiflorus Penstemon, Shell Leaf P L VL L Penstemon hirsutus 'Pygmaeus' Penstemon, Pygmy Purple P L L L L Penstemon jamesii Penstemon, James P VL L VL Penstemon linarioides Penstemon, Blue Mat P VL L VL Penstemon neomexicanus Penstemon, New Mexican Blue P L L Penstemon nitidus Penstemon, Smooth Blue P VL VL Penstemon palmeri Penstemon, Palmer P L VL L Penstemon parryi Penstemon, Parry P L L Penstemon pinifolius Penstemon, Pineleaf P L VL L L Penstemon procerus Penstemon, Small- Flowered P L L L Penstemon pseudospectabilis Penstemon, Desert P L L L Penstemon rostriflorus Bridge's Penstemon P L L Penstemon secundiflorus Penstemon, One-sided P L L Penstemon strictus Penstemon, Rocky Mountain P L VL L L Penstemon teucrioides Penstemon, Grayleaf Creeping P L L Penstemon triphyllus Penstemon, Whorled P VL VL Penstemon utahensis Penstemon, Utah P L L Penstemon venustus Penstemon, Blue Mountain P VL VL Penstemon virens Penstemon, Blue Mist P L VL L L Penstemon virgatus asagrayi Penstemon, Tall P VL VL Penstemon whippleanus Penstemon, Whipple's P L L L Penstemon wilcoxii Penstemon, Wilcox P VL VL Penstemon x mexicali Penstemon, Mexicali Hybrids P L VL L Perovskia atriplicifolia Sage, Russian S L VL VL VL Persicaria affinis Himalayan Border Jewel P L L L L Persicaria virginiana 'Painter's Palette Border Jewel, Painter's Palette P L L Petrophytum caespitosum Rock Spirea P L L Petunia x hybrida Petunia A M L M M Phacelia campanularia California Bluebell A L L L Phalaris arundinacea Grass, Ribbon P M M M M Philadelphus coronarius Mockorange, Sweet S L L L L Philadelphus lewisii Mockorange, Lewis S L L L L Philadelphus microphyllus Mockorange, Littleleaf S L VL L L Philadelphus x 'Buckley's Quill' Mockorange, Buckley's Quill S M L L M Philadelphus x 'Snowbelle' Mockorange, Snowbelle S M L L L Philadelphus x cymosus 'Bouquet Blanc' Mockorange, Bouquet Blanc S M L L M Philadelphus x virginalis Mockorange, Virginal S M L L M Phlomis cashmeriana Sage, Himalayan P M M M Phlomis russeliana Sage, Jerusalem P L L L Phlox borealis Phlox, Artic P M M M Phlox divaricata Phlox, Wild Sweet William P M M Phlox douglasii Phlox, Cushion GCP L L L Phlox paniculata Phlox, Garden P M M M M Phlox procumbens Phlox, Creeping GCP L M M M Phlox stolonifera Phlox, Creeping GCP M M Phlox subulata Phlox, Creeping GCP L M L L Phyllostachys aurea Bamboo, Golden P M M Phyllostachys aureosulcata Bamboo, Yellow Groove P M M Physocarpus monogynus Ninebark, Native S L VL L L Physocarpus opulifolius Ninebark S L L L L Physostegia virginiana Obedient Plant P M L M Picea abies Spruce, Norway S T M L L M Picea engelmannii Spruce, Engelmann T M L M M Picea glauca 'Conica' Spruce, Dwarf Alberta S T M M M M Picea glauca 'Densata' Spruce, Black Hills T M M M M Picea omorika Spruce, Serbian T M M M M Picea orientalis Spruce, Oriental T M M M M Picea pungens Spruce, Colorado S T M L M M Pieris japonica Pieris, Japanese S H M M M Pieris taiwanensis Pieris, Taiwan S H M M M Pinus aristata Pine, Bristlecone S T L L VL L Pinus bungeana Pine, Lacebark T L M L L Pinus cembra Pine, Compact Swiss Stone S L L L L Pinus contorta latifolia Pine, Lodgepole T L L L L Pinus densiflora Pine, Tanyosho S T L L L L Pinus edulis Pine, Pinon T VL VL VL VL Pinus flexilis Pine, Limber T L L L L Pinus heldreichii (leucodermis) Pine, Bosnian S T L L L L Pinus mugo Pine, Mugo S L L L L Pinus nigra Pine, Austrian T L L L L Pinus parviflora Pine, Lacebark T L L L L Pinus ponderosa Pine, Ponderosa T L L L L Pinus resinosa Pine, Red T M L L M Pinus strobiformis Pine, Border T L L L L Pinus strobus Pine, Eastern White T M L M M Pinus sylvestris Pine, Scotch T L L L L Pinus thunbergii Pine, Japanese Black T L L L L Pinus virginiana 'Wates Golden' Pine, Wates Golden Virginia Scru T M M M M Platanus occidentalis Sycamore T M M M M Platanus x acerifolia Planetree, London T M M M M Platycladus orientalis 'Aurea Nana' Arborvitae, Dwarf Golden Orienta S M M M M Platycodon grandiflorus Balloon Flower P M M M M Plectranthus argentatus Silver Dollar Plant A L VL L Poa praetensis Bluegrass TU H H M H Polemonium caeruleum Jacob's Ladder P M M M M Polemonium carneum Jacob's Ladder, Salmon P M M Polemonium reptans Jacob's Ladder, Creeping P M M Polemonium viscosum Sky Pilot P L M L Polygonum aubertii Vine, Silver Lace P V L L L L Polystichum polyblepharum Fern, Tassle P H H Polystichum setiferum Fern, English Hedge P H H Populus alba Poplar, Silver T M M L M Populus angustifolia Cottonwood, Narrowleaf T M M M M Populus balsamifera Poplar, Balsam T M H H H Populus deltoides 'Siouxland' Cottonwood, Soiuxland T M M M M Populus fremontii Cottonwood, Fremont T M M M M Populus nigra Poplar, Lombardy Black T H H H H Populus sargentii Cottonwood, Plains T M M M M Populus tremuloides Aspen T M M M M Populus x acuminata Cottonwood, Lanceleaf T M M M M Populus x canescens Cottonwood, Gray T M M M M Portulaca grandiflora Moss Rose, Portulaca A L VL L L Potentilla (Drymocallis) fissa Cinquefoil, Leafy P L L L Potentilla atrosanguinea Cinquefoil, Red P L M L L Potentilla fruticosa Potentilla, Shrub S L L L L Potentilla hippiana Cinquefoil, Wooly P L L VL L Potentilla nepalensis 'Miss Willmott' Cinquefoil, Miss Wilmott P M M L M Potentilla neumanniana Cinquefoil, Creeping GCP L L L L Potentilla nevadensis Cinquefoil, Native Silvery GCP L L L L Potentilla pensylvanica Cinquefoil, Prairie P L L Potentilla species Cinquefoil, Creeping GCP S L L L L Potentilla thurberi Cinquefoil, Silver P L L Primula 'Colossea' Primrose, Hardy English P M M Primula denticulata Primrose, Drumstick P M M Primula elatior Primrose, Oxlip P M M Primula parryi Primrose, Rocky Mountain P H M H H Primula veris Primrose, Cowslip P M M Primula vulgaris Primrose, English P M M Prinsepia sinensis Prinsepia, Cherry S M M M M Prunella grandiflora Self-Heal P M M Prunella laciniata Lacy Self-Heal P L L M L Prunus americana Plum, American S T L L L L Prunus armeniaca Apricot T M L L M Prunus avium Cherry, Sweet T M L L M Prunus besseyi Cherry, Western Sand S L L L L Prunus cerasifera Plum, Cherry T M L L M Prunus cerasus Cherry, Sour T M L L M Prunus fruticosa Cherry, European Dwarf S M L L L Prunus glandulosa 'Rosea Plena' Almond, Pink Flowering S M L L M Prunus maackii Chokecherry, Amur T M L L M Prunus maritima Plum, Beach T M L L M Prunus nigra 'Princess Kay' Plum, Princess Kay Canadian T M L L M Prunus padus Mayday Tree T M L L M Prunus pensylvanica saximontana Cherry, Pin S M L L M Prunus pesica Peach T M M L M Prunus sargentii Cherry, Sargent T M L L M Prunus serrulata 'Kwanzan' Cherry, Kwanzan Japanese Flow T M M M M Prunus subhirtella 'Pendula' Cherry, Weeping Spring T M M L M Prunus tenella Almond, Dwarf Russian S L L L L Prunus tomentosa Cherry, Nanking S L L L L Prunus triloba Rose Tree of China S M L L M Prunus virginiana 'Shubert' Chokecherry, Canada Red S T M L L L Prunus virginiana melanocarpa Chokecherry S L L L L Prunus x 'Snow Fountains' Cherry, Weeping White S M L L M Prunus x americana 'Toka' Plum, Toka T M M L M Prunus x cistena Plum, Purple- Leaf S T M L L M Prunus x domestica 'Stanley' Plum, Stanley Prune T M L L M Pseudotsuga menziesii Fir, Douglas S T M L L M Psilostrophe tagetina New Mexico Paper Flower P VL L L VL Ptelea trifoliata Ash, Wafer T L L L L Pulmonaria 'Roy Davidson' Bethlehem Sage, Roy Davidson' P M M Pulmonaria rubra 'Redstart' Lungwort, Redstart P M M M Pulmonaria saccharata Bethlehem Sage P M M Pulsatilla patens Pasqueflower, Lavender P L L L Pulsatilla vulgaris Pasqueflower, European P L L L L Purshia tridentata Bitterbrush Antelope S VL VL VL VL Pyracantha angustifolia Firethorn, Narrowleaf S M L L L Pyracantha coccinea Firethorn, Scarlet S L L L L Pyrus calleryana Pear, Ornamental T M L L M Pyrus communis Pear, Orchard T M L L M Pyrus fauriei Pear, Korean Wild Pear T L L L L Pyrus ussuriensis Pear, Ussurian T L L L L Quercus acutissima Oak, Sawtooth T M M L M Quercus alba Oak, White T M L L M Quercus bicolor Oak, Swamp White T L L L L Quercus coccinea Oak, Scarlet T M L L M Quercus ellipsoidalis Oak, Northern Pin T M L L M Quercus gambelii Oak, Gambel S T L VL VL VL Quercus imbricaria Oak, Shingle T M L L M Quercus macrocarpa Oak, Bur T L L L L Quercus muehlenbergii Oak, Chinkapin T L M L L Quercus palustris Oak, Pin T M M L M Quercus phellos Oak, Willow T M L L M Quercus prinus Oak, Chestnut T M L L M Quercus robur Oak, English T M L L M Quercus rubra Oak, Northern Red T M L L M Quercus shumardi Oak, Shumard Oak T M M L L Quercus turbinella Oak, Shrub Liveoak S VL L L VL Quercus undulata Oak, Wavyleaf T L L L L Ranunculus gramineus Buttercup, European P M M M Ranunculus repens Creeping Buttercup P M H M Ratibida columnifera Coneflower, Prairie P L VL L VL Rhamnus catharticus Buckthorn, Common S L L L L Rhamnus frangula 'Asplenifolius' Buckthorn, Glossy Cutleaf S M L L L Rhamnus frangula 'Columnaris' Buckthorn, Tall Hedge S L L L L Rhamnus saxitile Buckthorn, Rock S L L L L Rhamnus smithii Buckthorn, Smith's Alder S L VL L L Rheum rhabarbarum Rhubarb P M M M Rhododendron Rhododendron S H M H H Rhus aromatica Sumac, Fragrant S L L L L Rhus glabra Sumac, Smooth S L L L L Rhus lanceolata Sumac, Flameleaf S L L L L Rhus microphylla Sumac, Little Leaf Desert S VL L L VL Rhus trilobata Sumac, Three- Leaf S VL L VL VL Rhus typhina Sumac, Staghorn S L L L L Ribes alpinum Currant, Alpine S L L L L Ribes aureum Currant, Yellow Flowering S L L L L Ribes cereum Currant, Squaw S L L L L Ribes hirtellum 'Pixwell' Gooseberry, Pixwell S L L L L Ribes inerme Gooseberry, Whitestem S L L L L Ribes leptanthum Currant, Black S L L L L Ribes nigrum Currant, Black S L L L L Ribes odoratum Currant, Clove S L L L L Ribes sanguineum Currant, Red Flowering S L L L L Ribes silvestre 'Red Lake' Currant, Red Lake S L L L L Ribes uva-crispa 'Red Jacket' Gooseberry, Red Jacket S L L L L Ricinus communis Castor Bean A M M Robinia neomexicana Locust, New Mexico S T L VL VL L Robinia pseudoacacia Locust, Black T L L L L Rosa Rose, Shrub S M L L M Rosa foetida 'Bicolor' Rose, Austrian Copper S L L L L Rosa foetida 'Persiana' Rose, Persian Yellow S L L L L Rosa glauca Rose, Red- Leaved S L L L L Rosa pomifera Rose, Apple S L L L L Rosa rugosa Rose, Rugosa S L L L L Rosa woodsii Rose, Native Pink S L L L L Rosa xanthina hugonis Rose, Yellow Shrub S L L L L Rosmarinus officinalis Rosemary A P L L L Rosularia globulariifolia Rosularia, Roundleaf P L L Rubus deliciosus Boulder Raspberry S L L L L Rubus idaeus Raspberry S M L L M Rubus odoratus Raspberry, Purple- flowering S L L L L Rubus parviflorus Thimbleberry S M L L L Rudbeckia fulgida Black-Eyed Susan P L L L L Rudbeckia hirta Black-Eyed Susan P M L M M Rudbeckia laciniata 'Double Gold' Black Eyed Susan, Double Gold P M H M Saccharum ravennae Grass, Plume P M M Sagina subulata Pearlwort GCP M M M Sagittaria latifolia Arrowhead, Broadleaf P H H H Salix 'Prairie Cascade' Willow, Prairie Cascade Weeping T H H H H Salix alba 'Tristis' Willow, Golden Weeping S T H H M H Salix alba vitellina Willow, Russian Golden S T H M M H Salix amygdaloides Willow, Peach Leaf S T M M M M Salix arenaria Willow, Silver Creeping S M M M M Salix bebbiana Willow, Bebb's S M M M M Salix caprea Willow, Goat S H H H H Salix discolor Willow, Pussy S H H M H Salix drummondiana Willow, Drummond S H M M M Salix exigua Willow, Coyote S M M H M Salix fragilis Willow, Crack S H M H H Salix geyeriana Willow, Geyer's S H M M M Salix integra 'Hakuro Nishiki' Willow, Dappled S H H H H Salix irrorata Willow, Blue Stem S M M M M Salix lutea ligulifolia Willow, Strapleaf Yellow S M M M M Salix matsudana 'Umbraculifera' Willow, Globe S T H H M H Salix monticola Willow, Yellow Mountain S H M M M Salix pentandra Willow, Laurel Leaf T H M M M Salix purpurea Willow, Basket S H M M M Salix repens Willow, Creeping S M M M M Salix scouleriana Willow, Scoulers S M M M M Salix x sepulcralis chrysocoma Willow, Niobe Weeping T H M M H Salvia argentea Salvia, Silver P L L L L Salvia azurea grandiflora Salvia, Blue P L L L Salvia farinacea Mealycup sage A M L M Salvia greggii Sage, Autumn P L L L Salvia jurisicii Salvia, Cutleaf P L L Salvia leucantha Sage, Mexican Bush P L L Salvia lyrata Sage, Lyre- leaf P L L Salvia microphylla Salvia, Red Baby P L L Salvia nemorosa Salvia, Blue P L L M L Salvia officinalis Sage, Garden P L L L Salvia pitcheri Sage, Pitcher P L L Salvia sclarea Clary Sage A P L VL M L Salvia splendens Scarlet Salvia A M L M Salvia superba Salvia, Hybrid P L M L Sambucus canadensis Elder, American S M M M M Sambucus nigra 'Marginata' Elder, Variegated S M M M M Sambucus pubens Elder, Native Red Berried S M L L M Sambucus racemosa Elder, European Red S M M M M Santolina chamaecyparissus Lavender Cotton P L L VL L Santolina rosmarinifolia Lavender Cotton, Green P L VL VL L Sanvitalia procumbens Creeping Zinnia A L L L Sapindus drummondii Soapberry, Western S T L L L L Saponaria ocymoides Rock Soapwort P L L M L Saxifraga oppositifolia 'Purple Robe' Saxifrage, Purple Robe P M M H M Saxifraga x arendsii Saxifrage, Rose Mound P M H M Scabiosa caucasica Pincushion Flower P M M L M Scabiosa columbaria Pincushion Flower P L L L Scabiosa lucida Pincushion Flower, Dwarf P L M L L Scabiosa ochroleuca Pincushion, Yellow P L L Scaevola aemula Fan Flower A M M M Schizachyrium scoparium Bluestem, Little P L VL L L Schizophragma hydrangeoides Vine, Japanese Hydrangea P M M Schoenoplectus lacustris Bulrush, Common P H H Schoenoplectus validus Bulrush, Softstem Great P H H Scirpus acutus Bulrush, Hardstem P H H H Scirpus americanus Bulrush, Three-square P H H H Scirpus microcarpus Bulrush, Small-fruited P H H H Scutellaria alpina 'Arcobaleno' Skull Cap, Rainbow P M M M Scutellaria resinosa Skull Cap, Prairie P L L Sedum 'Autumn Joy' Stonecrop, Autumn Joy P L L L L Sedum 'Blue Spruce' Stonecrop, Blue Creeping GCP L L L L Sedum 'Robustum' Stonecrop, Red-leaf Showy P L L L Sedum 'Vera Jameson' Stonecrop, Vera Jameson P L L M L Sedum acre evergreen Stonecrop, Goldmoss- Utah GCP L L VL L Sedum hybridum Stonecrop, Oak-leaf GCP L VL L L Sedum kamtschaticum Stonecrop, Russian P L L VL L Sedum lanceolatum Stonecrop, Native P VL VL VL Sedum populifolium Stonecrop, Herbacious P L L Sedum sieboldii 'October Daphne ' Stonecrop, October Daphne P L L Sedum spectabile 'Indian Chief' Stonecrop, Russet Showy P L L L L Sedum spurium Stonecrop, Two-row GCP L L VL L Sempervivum species Hens and Chicks GCP VL VL L VL Senecio cineraria Dusty Miller A L L L L Senecio longilobus Groundsel, Threadleaf P L L L Senecio spartioides Groundsel, Broom P L L L Sequoiadendron giganteum Giant Sequoia T M M L M Shepherdia argentea Buffaloberry S T L VL VL VL Shepherdia canadensis Buffaloberry, Russet S L VL L L Shepherdia rotundifolia Buffaloberry, Roundleaf S VL VL VL VL Sibiraea laevigata Sibiraea S L L L L Sidalcea malviflora Mallow, Prairie P M M M Silene acaulis Moss Campion P M M M Silene alpestris Alpine Catchfly P M M M Silphium perfoliatum Cup Flower P M M Sisyrinchium angustifolium Grass, Blue- Eyed P M M M Sisyrinchium macrocephalum Grass, Yellow- Eyed P M M Sisyrinchium montanum Grass, Blue- Eyed P M M M Solidago 'Golden Baby' Goldenrod, Golden Baby P L L L Solidago decumbens Goldenrod, Dwarf P L H L Solidago missouriensis Goldenrod, Prairie P L M L Sophora japonica Japanese Pagoda Tree T M L M M Sorbaria sorbifolia Spirea, Ural False S L M M M Sorbus alnifolia Mountain Ash, Korean T M L L M Sorbus aucuparia Mountain Ash, European S T M M L M Sorbus decora Mountain Ash, Showy T M L L M Sorbus hybrida Mountain Ash, Oak Leaf S M L L M Sorbus intermedia Whitebeam, Swedish T M M M M Sorbus mougeotii Whitebeam, Austrian T M M M M Sorbus scopulina Mountain Ash, Native S T M M M M Sorghastrum nutans Grass, Indian P L L L Spartina pectinata Grass, Prairie Cordgrass P M L H M Sphaeralcea coccinea Prairie Mallow P VL VL VL VL Sphaeralcea munroana Globe Mallow, Orange P VL VL Spiraea albiflora Spirea, Japanese White S M M M M Spiraea argunta 'Compacta' Spirea, Compact Garland S L M M M Spiraea decumbens Spirea, White Lace S L M M L Spiraea fritschiana Spirea, Fritschiana S L M M M Spiraea japonica Spirea, Japanese S M L M M Spiraea nipponica Spirea, Snowmound S L M M M Spiraea prunifolia Spirea, Bridalwreath S L M M L Spiraea thunbergii Spirea, Thunberg S L M M L Spiraea trilobata Spirea, Threelobe S L M M M Spiraea x 'Goldmound' Spirea, Goldmound S M M M M Spiraea x billardii Spirea, Billard S M M M M Spiraea x bumalda Spirea, Bumald S M M M M Spiraea x cineria 'Grefsheim' Spirea, Grefsheim S M M M M Spiraea x vanhouttei Spirea, Vanhoutte S M M M M Sporobolus wrightii Grass, Giant Sacaton P VL L L Stachys byzantina Lamb's Ears GCP L VL VL L Stachys coccinea Nettle, Scarlet Hedge P L L Stanleya pinnata Prince's Plume P VL VL L VL Stewartia koreana Korean Stewartia S M H H M Stipa comata Grass, Needle- and-Thread P L L L Stipa gigantea Needlegrass, Giant P L L Stipa lettermani Grass, Needle P L L Stipa neomexicana Needlegrass, New Mexico P L L Stipa tenuissima Grass, Mexican Feather P L L L L Stokesia laevis Aster, Stokes' P M L M Styrax japonicus Snowbell, Japanese T H H H H Sutera cordata Bacopa A L M M Symphoricarpos albus Snowberry, White S L L L L Symphoricarpos occidentalis Wolfberry S L L L L Symphoricarpos orbiculatus Coralberry, Red S L L M L Symphoricarpos oreophilus Snowberry, Mountain S L L L L Symphoricarpos x chenaultii Coralberry, Chenault S L L M L Symphoricarpos x doorenbosii Snowberry S L L L L Symphytum grandiflorum Comfrey P M M M Syringa laciniata Lilac, Cutleaf S L L L L Syringa meyeri 'Palibin' Lilac, Dwarf Korean S L L L L Syringa microphylla Lilac, Littleleaf S L L L L Syringa oblata 'Cheyenne' Lilac, Cheyenne Early S L L L L Syringa patula 'Miss Kim' Lilac, Miss Kim Dwarf S L L L L Syringa pekinensis Lilac, Peking S T L L L L Syringa reflexa Lilac, Nodding S L L L L Syringa reticulata Lilac, Japanese Tree S T M L L L Syringa vulgaris Lilac, Common Purple S L L L L Syringa x chinensis Lilac, Chinese S L L L L Syringa x hyacinthiflora Lilac, Hybrid S L L L L Syringa x josiflexa 'Royalty' Lilac, Hybrid Purple Singl S L M M L Syringa x persica Lilac, Persian S L L L L Syringa x prestoniae Lilac, Canadian S L M L L Tagetes spp. Marigold A L L L L Tanacetum densum amani Partridge Feather GCP VL VL VL VL Tanacetum niveum Tansy, Snow Daisy P L L VL L Tanacetum parthenium 'White Star' Feverfew, White P L M L Tanacetum x coccineum Painted Daisy P L M L Taxodium distichum Bald Cypress T M H H M Taxus cuspidata Yew, Spreading Japanese S M H H M Taxus x media Yew, Anglojap S M H H M Teucrium canadensis Germander, Creeping P L L Teucrium chamaedrys Germander, Wall GCP L L L Thalictrum aquilegifolium Meadowrue, Columbine P M M M M Thalictrum delavayi 'Hewitt's Double' Meadowrue, Hewitt's Double P M M M Thalictrum dipterocarpum Meadowrue, Yunnan P M M M Thalictrum fendleri Meadowrue, Fendler's P M M M M Thalictrum flavum glaucum Meadowrue, Yellow P M M Thalictrum rochebrunianum Meadowrue, Lavender Mist P M M M Thelesperma ambiguus Navajo Tea P L VL VL Thelesperma filifolium Threadleaf Thelesperma P L VL L Thermopsis divaricarpa Golden Banner P L L M M Thermopsis rhombifolia Golden Banner, Arroyo P L L L L Thuja occidentalis Arborvitae, American T M M M M Thuja orientalis Arborvitae, Oriental T M H M M Thuja plicata Arborvitae, Giant T M H H M Thymus 'Elfin' Thyme, Elfin GCP L L VL L Thymus argentia Thyme, Silver Posy P L VL L Thymus praecox 'Pseudolanuginosus' Thyme, Woolly GC L L VL L Thymus praecox arcticus Thyme, Mother of GCP L L L L Thymus serphyllum Thyme, Wild GCP L L L L Thymus vulgaris Thyme, Garden P L VL L Thymus x citriodorus Thyme, Lemon P L L L L Tiarella cordifolia Foamflower P M M M Tiarella wherryi Foamflower, Wherry's P M M M Tilia 'Euchlora' Linden, Crimean T M M M M Tilia americana Linden, American T M M L M Tilia cordata Linden, Littleleaf T M M M M Tilia mongolica Linden, Mongolian T M M L M Tilia tomentosa Linden, Silver T M M M M Tithonia rotundifolia Sunflower, Mexican A L L L Townsendia exscapa Easter Daisy, White P L L L Townsendia grandiflora Easter Daisy, Large-flower P L L L Townsendia parryi Easter Daisy, Violet-Blue P L L L Tradescantia andersoniana Spiderwort P M M M M Tradescantia occidentalis Spiderwort, Western Blue P L VL M L Tricyrtis hirta Toad Lily P M M Trollius chinensis Globeflower P M M M M Trollius pumilus Globeflower, Dwarf P M M Tropaeolum majus Nasturtium A L L L Tsuga canadensis 'Cole's Prostrata' Hemlock, Canadian Creeping S H H H H Tsuga canadensis 'Gracilis' Hemlock, Dwarf Spreading Cana S H H H H Typha angustifolia Cattail, Narrowleaf P H H H Typha latifolia Cattail, Common P H H H Ulmus americana Elm, American T M M M M Ulmus cultivars Elm T M L L M Ulmus glabra Elm, Scotch T L L L L Ulmus parvifolia Elm, Lacebark T L M L M Ulmus wilsoniana Elm, Wilson T M M M M Vaccinium Blueberry S M H H M Valeriana officinalis Garden Heliotrope P M M Verbascum 'Helen Johnson' Mullein, Peach P L L Verbascum bombyciferum Mullein, Wooly P L VL L Verbascum undulatum Mullein, Wavy- leafed P L L Verbena bipinnatifida Verbena, Native P L L Verbena bonariensis Verbena, Tall A L VL L Verbena canadensis Verbena, Rose P L M M Verbena hastata Vervain, Blue P M M Verbena x hybrida Verbena, Garden A L L L L Veronica 'Royal Candles' Speedwell, Royal Candles P L L Veronica 'Sunny Border Blue' Speedwell, Sunny Border Blue P L L M L Veronica Crystal River Speedwell, Crystal River GCP L L L L Veronica allionii Speedwell, Allioni GCP L L L L Veronica austriaca Speedwell, Hungarian P L L M L Veronica filiformis Speedwell, Birdseye GCP L VL L L Veronica gentianoides Speedwell, Gentian P L L Veronica liwanensis Speedwell, Turkish GCP L L L L Veronica longifolia Speedwell, Long Leaf P L L Veronica orientalis Speedwell, Oriental P L L Veronica pectinata Speedwell, Wooly Creeping GCP L L L L Veronica peduncularis 'Georgia Blue' Speedwell, Georgia Blue P L L L Veronica prostrata Speedwell, Prostrate GCP L L L L Veronica repens Speedwell, Creeping GCP L L L L Veronica spicata Speedwell, Spike P M L L M Veronica spicata incana Speedwell, Wooly P L L L Veronicastrum virginicum Bowman's Root P M M Viburnum carlesii Viburnum, Koreanspice S M M L M Viburnum dentatum Viburnum, Arrowwood S M M L M Viburnum dilatatum Viburnum, Linden S L M M M Viburnum lantana Wayfaringtree S T L L L L Viburnum lentago Viburnum, Nannyberry S L L M L Viburnum opulus Viburnum, European S M M L M Viburnum plicatum tomentosum Viburnum, Doublefile S M M M M Viburnum prunifolium Viburnum, Blackhaw S M L L M Viburnum rufidulum Viburnum, Rusty Blackhaw S M M M M Viburnum sargentii Viburnum Sargent S M L L L Viburnum trilobum Viburnum, American Cranberrybu S M L L M Viburnum x bodnantense 'Pink Dawn' Viburnum, Pink Dawn S M M M M Viburnum x burkwoodii Viburnum, Burkwood S M L L M Viburnum x carlcephalum Viburnum, Fragrant Snowball S M L L M Viburnum x juddii Viburnum, Judd S M M L M Viburnum x rhytidophylloides 'Alleghany' Viburnum, Alleghany S L L L L Viguiera multiflora Showy Goldeneye P L L Vinca major Periwinkle, Big-Leaf GCP M M M M Vinca minor Periwinkle GCP L L M L Viola canadensis Violet, Canadian P M M M Viola cornuta Pansy, Tufted P M M M M Viola corsica Violet, Corsican P M M M M Viola odorata Violet, English P M M M Viola tricolor Viola, Johnny- jump-up A M M M Viola x wittrockiana Pansy A M M M Vitis cultivars Grape cultivars S V M M M M Vitis riparia Grape, Frost S V M M M M Waldsteinia ternata Strawberry, Barren GCP L L L L Weigela florida Weigela S M M M M Wisteria floribunda Japanese Wisteria V L L Wisteria sinensis Wisteria, Chinese V M M Xanthoceras sorbifolium Yellowhorn T L L H M Yucca baccata Yucca, Banana S VL VL VL VL Yucca elata Soap Tree S VL VL VL VL Yucca filamentosa Adam's Needle S L VL VL L Yucca glauca Soapweed S VL VL VL VL Yucca recurivifolia Yucca, Spineless S VL VL VL VL Zauschneria californica latifolia Hummingbird Flower P L VL L Zauschneria garrettii 'Orange Carpet' California Fuchsia, Orange P L VL L Zelkova serrata Zelkova, Japanese T M M M M Zinnia elegans Zinnia A L L L L Zinnia grandiflora Paper Flower P VL VL VL VL WATER EFFICIENT LANDSCAPE WORKSHEET This worksheet is completed by the project applicant and is a required element of the Landscape and Irrigation Documentation Package. SECTION A. GALLONS OF WATER NEEDED BY PLANT CATEGORY AND IRRIGATION TYPE The specific irrigation water needs of each hydrozone in the design should be determined using the following formula and factors: Irrigation Water Budget = [(ETo × Plant Factor) – Re] × Irrigated Area ÷ Irrigation Efficiency × 0.623 Where: ETo = Reference Evapotranspiration = 27.4 inches/season (May through September) Re = Effective Precipitation = 6.8 inches/season (May through September) Irrigated Area = hydrozone area in square feet Water Use Plant Irrigation Default Category Factor Method Efficiency Cool-Season Turf 0.90 Overhead 75% High 0.80 Drip 90% Medium 0.65 Low 0.40 Very Low 0.25 SECTION B. HYDROZONE INFORMATION TABLE AND WATER BUDGET CALCULATION Complete the hydrozone table for each hydrozone. Use as many rows as necessary to provide the square footage of landscape area per hydrozone. Hydro- zone ETo (in/season) Plant Water Use Category Plant Factor Re (in/season) Irrigation Method Irrigation Efficiency Hydrozone Area (sq-ft) Irrig Water Need (gal/season) TOTAL AVERAGE IRRIGATION WATER NEED ALL ZONES*: gal/sf/season *The average must be less than the Maximum Applied Water Budget of 7.5 gal/sf/season. Total area of irrigated public right-of-way: sq-ft Total area of non-irrigated landscape: sq-ft Attachment E An example is provided below. Example Hydrozone Information Table and Water Budget Calculation: Hydro- zone ETo (in/season) Plant Water Use Category Plant Factor Re (in/season) Irrigation Method Irrigation Efficiency Hydrozone Area (sq-ft) Irrig Water Need (gal/season) Zone 1 27.4 L 0.40 6.8 Drip 0.90 2000 5759 Zone 2 27.4 M 0.65 6.8 Overhead 0.75 500 4573 Zone 3 27.4 Turf 0.90 6.8 Overhead 0.75 2000 29671 Zone 4 27.4 VL 0.25 6.8 Drip 0.90 1000 35 TOTAL 5500 40038 AVERAGE IRRIGATION WATER NEED ALL ZONES*: 7.3 gal/sf/season Total area of irrigated public right-of-way: 0 sq-ft Total area of non-irrigated landscape: 300 sq-ft June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 1 Staff Report –Minor Development Plan June 20, 2017 Planning & Zoning Commission Meeting Report date June 16, 2017 Project file Case #MNR17021 Legal description Lot 7, Western Sage Subdivision Address 5771 Wildridge Road East Zoning PUD Prepared By David McWilliams, Town Planer Summary Buz Reynolds, (the Applicant) developer of 5771 Wildridge Road East, seeks approval of a landscaping layout that differs from the one approved during the development application. The Final Design was approved in 2008, and received a series of extensions during the economic downturn. During the last extension, the following conditions were placed on the application including: o An improved Landscape Plan must be approved by PZC to address the landscaping below the lowest set of retaining walls. o The PZC must re review and approve the lowest retaining wall. On August 18, 2015, PZC approved a landscape plan (Attachment A), and took action to approve a modified concrete block wall design “with dark color”, as presented below: The Property has been developed with an alternative landscaping layout as evidenced in attached photographs, thereby forming the basis for this current application. During a final Certificate of Occupancy (CO) inspection request with the Planning Department, Staff was notified that the retaining wall stain could not be achieved. Staff is satisfied with the number of plantings (34 plantings) on the Property corresponding to the number in the approved landscape plan (Exhibit A), but is hesitant to grant the CO without the June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 2 approved landscaping near the retaining walls. The majority of the large plantings have been focused between the structure and the Wildridge Road Right of Way. As mentioned, the large block retaining walls were not stained as approved. The Applicant has stated that despite his best efforts, the blocks are not able to retain the stain that he has applied to them, due to the fine particulate nature of the block surface. That is, after application, the stain is washing off due to the sprinkler system. Request The applicant is requesting the approval of the installed landscaping as sufficient for the purposes of attaining a CO on the property. According to Avon Development Code, approval of the requested modifications can be processed as a Minor Development Plan. Specifically, Section 7.16.080(b)(2), considers the following changes eligible for review as a Minor Development Plan: (iv) Landscape modifications, including but not limited to removal of existing vegetation and addition of new vegetation. (ix) Modifications to approved development plans which do not change the character of the approved design; and (x) Other similar changes to a structure or property that do not significantly impact the site layout or design of the building. Relevant Code Sections 7.28.050 Landscaping (5) Revegetation Required: (i) All disturbed areas must be adequately reseeded and restored on all projects. A revegetation bond, satisfactory to the Director, must be furnished as a condition of certificate of occupancy and shall remain in full force and effect until the landscaping plan is completed, vegetation is sufficiently established and structural best management practices (BMPs), such as silt fence and straw bales, are removed from the site. 6) Guarantee of Installation. Required landscape improvements shall be installed prior to issuance of a certificate of occupancy for all structures. If weather conditions prevent installation, the property owner shall post a financial guarantee for the improvements. The guarantee shall be released upon completion and acceptance of the installation of the landscape improvements. 7.28.070 Retaining Walls (4) The design of retaining walls shall be constructed of materials compatible with the site and materials of the structures on the site. Retaining walls and cribbing should utilize natural materials, such as boulders, cut rocks, stone-veneer or textured, color-tinted concrete. Timbers and railroad ties are prohibited as retaining wall materials. Where two (2) alternatively designed retaining walls meet, a cohesive transition between walls must be demonstrated. Staff Response While staff is supportive of the project overall, the modifications to the landscape plan go against June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 3 the specific elements requested by the PZC and Town Council in prior approvals. Changes to the retaining wall design have left an element that is not compatible with the site. This requires, at a minimum, some sort of landscaping below the wall to help it blend in with the surroundings and the materials of the principle structure on the Property. Recommended Motions and Findings: “I move to Approve Case #MNR17021, an application for revised landscaping and retraining wall design for Lot 7, Western Sage Subdivision, with the findings of fact and conditions as recommended by staff.” Recommended Findings 1. The application is eligible for review as a Minor Development Plan as outlined in the June 16, 2017 staff report. 2. Conditional approval is necessary in order to ensure compliance with the applicable design standards. Recommended Condition 1. A revised landscape plan shall be submitted for staff review and approval not later than July demonstrating additional landscape improvements below the retaining walls. Exhibits A. Approved Landscape B. Photos of Property showing plantings and wall June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 4 Exhibit B: Photos View northwest from Wildridge Road. View south from Wildridge Road. June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 5 View from Wildridge Road. View up the east drainage. June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 6 View from east drainage of wall. Close up image of the wall showing the issue with staining. June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 7 Image of walls from below. Image looking up west drainage. June 20, 2017 Planning and Zoning Meeting MNR17021 8 Image of deck wall from west drainage. Image of west drainage near the driveway wall. Note: Large mature apsen trees is background are mostly located on Lot 7, eventhough planted for neighboring development on Lot 6. H11 P,- - WNIMI mow Mm y®R App io 1 tae' L yf y t`\ 5 WOlawion Wd6 1 ON, r •fnCY a,Gljt as . IN iii !Vr 3 i dw4 Cii M :. 10 P E , ff M$ . 3 $ b7iz , my • ate` t l• ,y + .ova ` ` u :.. . . i fT6 pb. N iifi T h i iM. Ff`. . K7 r 4 t map — Aims tae' L yf y t`\ 5 WOlawion Wd6 1 ON, r •fnCY a,Gljt as . IN iii !Vr 3 i dw4 Cii M :. 10 P E , ff M$ . 3 $ b7iz , my • ate` tl• ,y + .ova ` ` u :.. . . i fT6 pb. N iifi T h i iM. Ff`. . K7 r 4 t PZC Record of Decision: #MNR17016 Page 1 of 1 PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION RECORD OF DECISION DATE OF DECISION: June 6, 2017 TYPE OF APPLICATION: Minor Development Plan PROPERTY LOCATION: Beaver Creek Blvd Right of Way Block 2, Benchmark at Beaver Creek Subdivision FILE NUMBER: #MNR17016 This decision is made in accordance with the Avon Development Code (“Development Code”) §7.16.110: DECISION: Approved unanimously (5-0 vote) with the following findings: FINDINGS: 1) The application is in conformance with the review criteria contained in §7.16.080(f) and §7.16.090(f), AMC. 2) The Avon Comprehensive Plan’s goals and policies support streetscape design that enhances the pedestrian environment. 3) Signage, streetscape design, landscaping, points of interest, and other wayfinding elements are directly supported by the Avon Comprehensive Plan. 4) The Landscape Plan complies with the intent of Chapter 7.28.050, Landscaping, Avon Municipal Code. 5) All lighting is in compliance with the Outdoor Lighting Ordinance. THESE FINDINGS OF FACT AND RECORD OF DECISION ARE HEREBY APPROVED: BY:______________________________________ DATE: ___________________ PZC Chairperson 1 Meeting Minutes for June 6, 2017 Planning & Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes for Tuesday, June 6, 2017 I. Call to Order Commissioner Hardy called the meeting to order at 5:01pm. II. Roll Call All Commissioners were present with the exception of Commissioner Nusbaum and Commissioner Golembiewski. III. Additions & Amendments to the Agenda Matt Pielsticker noted the addition of the April 18, 2017 draft meeting minutes, and the Findings of Fact and Record of Decisions for VAR17001, MNR17010, and SRU17001. IV. Election of Temporary Chairperson Commissioner Hardy was nominated as the temporary chairperson, and no Commissioners were in objection. V. Conflicts of Interest There were no conflicts of interest. VI. Sign Program Amendment – 150 East Beaver Creek Boulevard File: SGN17004 Legal Description: Lot 24, Block 2, Benchmark at Beaver Creek Applicant: Chad Wilkison Summary: Proposal for an updated Sign Program to allow more flexibility in design at the Avon Plaza. Action: Commissioner Howell motioned for a continuance of the item. Commissioner Minervini seconded the motion and the motion passed unanimously. VII. Sign Design– 228 West Beaver Creek Boulevard File: SGN17005 Legal Description: Lot 37 A&B and Lot 36 A&B, Block 2, Benchmark at Beaver Creek Applicant: Todd Roehr Summary: Proposal for a new sign to make the Mein Haus Bed and Breakfast business more visible to visitors. Action: Commissioner Barnes motioned for approval of the item with the Finding below: Finding: 1. The Application was reviewed in conformance with Section 15.28, Sign Code, and found to be in conformance with the design review criteria outlined in Section 15.28.070, Avon Municipal Code. Commissioner Glaner seconded the motion and the motion carried unanimously. 2 Meeting Minutes for June 6, 2017 VIII. Sign Design – 71 Beaver Creek Place File: SGN17006 Legal Description: Lot 70, Block 2, Benchmark at Beaver Creek Applicant: Amanda Fitzjarrald Summary: Proposal for an updated Sign Program to allow more tenant signage at the ANB Bank. Action: Commissioner Barnes motioned for approval of the application with the following Findings and Conditions: Finding: 1. The Application was reviewed in conformance with Section 15.28, Sign Code, and found to be in conformance with the design review criteria outlined in Section 15.28.070, Avon Municipal Code. Conditions: 1. The existing wayfinding sign north of the north entrance will be removed. 2. The proposed location and sign display is acceptable so long as it is exterior lit and staff approved. 3. An updated Landscaping Plan showing complimentary plantings to the existing Plan at the location of the old monument sign will be presented and approved by staff. Commissioner Glaner seconded the motion and the motion carried unanimously. IX. PUBLIC HEARING - Minor Development Plan – Beaver Creek Boulevard Streetscape Improvements File: MNR17016 & SGN17007 Legal Description: Beaver Creek Boulevard Right of Way Applicant: Town of Avon Summary: Application to improve the lighting, signage, and striping of East and West Beaver Creek Boulevard in Town Center. Public Comments: Todd Roehr mentioned that the fire chief had concerns with maneuvering the roadway. Action: Commissioner Barnes motioned to approve MNR17016 with the following findings: Findings: 1. The application is in conformance with the review criteria contained in §7.16.080(f) and §7.16.090(f), AMC. 2. The Avon Comprehensive Plan’s goals and policies support streetscape design that enhances the pedestrian environment. 3. Signage, streetscape design, landscaping, points of interest, and other wayfinding elements are directly supported by the Avon Comprehensive Plan. 4. The Landscape Plan complies with the intent of Chapter 7.28.050, Landscaping, Avon Municipal Code. 5. All lighting is in compliance with the Outdoor Lighting Ordinance. Commissioner Howell seconded the motion and it passed unanimously. Commissioner Barnes made a motion to table SGN17007 pending updated design information. Commissioner Glaner seconded the motion and it passed unanimously. X. Approval of Meeting Minutes & Records of Decision  April 18, 2017 Meeting Minutes Commissioner Minervini made a motion to approve the April 18, 2017 Meeting Minutes. 3 Meeting Minutes for June 6, 2017  Record of Decision for VAR17001 & MNR17010 Commissioner Minervini made a motion to approve the Record of Decision. Commissioner Barnes seconded and the motion passed unanimously with Commissioner Glaner abstaining due to his absence from the meeting.  Record of Decision for SRU17001 Commissioner Minervini made a motion to approve the Record of Decision. Commissioner Howell seconded and the motion passed unanimously with Commissioner Glaner abstaining due to his absence from the meeting.  May 16, 2017 Meeting Minutes Commissioner Minervini made a motion to approve the May 16, 2017 Meeting Minutes. Commissioner Howell seconded and the motion passed unanimously. XI. Staff Updates  Town owned properties update – Public Meeting June 8 and Survey. XII. Adjourn The meeting was adjourned at 8:45pm. Approved this 20th Day of June, 2017 SIGNED: ___________________________________________ Chairperson