Loading...
PZC Packet 011717 To: Planning and Zoning Commission From: David McWilliams, Town Planner Meeting Date: January 17, 2017 Topic: Comprehensive Plan Update, Work Session No. 8 Introduction This session presents a redline strikethrough of section E to K of the Goals and Policies section of the Comprehensive Plan (Included as “Attachment A”, found in Work session no. 7), and Areas of Change and Intermediate Areas of the District Planning Principles (“Attachment B”). Aside from addressing the question, “does this merit inclusion in the Comprehensive Plan?,” staff asked what established district planning principles merited inclusion, and tried to unify the language between and across districts for a more legible document. Completed Goals and Policies The order of the Goals and Policies is an area where PZC guidance would be helpful. A proposed order of the Policies within any Goal section is below. In parentheses is an example of the policy type and language that would fit within that section.  Plan Concept (things Town does, like implement or assess)  Development Rule (things the Town wants to influence, like encourage or promote)  Partnership (groups Town, like work with or participate in)  Area (Town Center, Wildridge)  Type of Place (near schools, parks, etc.)  Thing (Nottingham Park, railroad) This order will provide a consistent feel to the document and aid in its legibility. While these categories are somewhat arbitrary in their makeup, it does allow for a notion of order within the document. Any suggestions about broadening or shrinking categories, adding more, or eliminating this strategy for another are welcome. This portion will be included as a (somewhat) clean version of the strikethrough during the next meeting. Section K: Implementation Matrix This section, which is between the Goals and Policies and the District Planning Principles is not up for review. Staff feels that including this in the next PZC session, along with a completed Goals and Policies Section, makes the most sense. It would be hard to pin down the exact location of the associated policy without first ordering the policies in their permanent locations first. District Planning Principles Areas of Change, Intermediate Areas, Areas of Stability Staff changed the wording of the three sub-sections of Town Districts from High, Medium, and Low Priorities to Change, Intermediate and Stable Areas in order to illustrate that areas are not less or more important to the Town, but are experiencing different levels of development pressure and should be examined accordingly. Some areas have moved between sections depending on the different development pressures since the original document was created ten years ago. Consistent Language Lots of the original Districts had similar Principles expressed in slightly different ways. The wording was expanded and also included in more Districts. For example, “Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts,” became a common element in Districts that have similarly zoned densities as Town Center. If there are cases of language inconsistency that were missed, please bring it up with the group. Regrouping Districts 14-18, representing open space lands north of I-70 are included as one group of districts due to their alignment as similar intent as buffer zones and Planning Principles. Maps The map found on page 69 of the currently adopted Comp Plan represents the entirety of Avon’s Planning Districts. All districts are proposed to keep the same boundaries, with the possible exception of #26. District #15 includes a Town-owned parcel that should probably be included in #26. Within the current District Planning Principles, some districts contain maps which are un- editable due to their file format. Staff feels that the out of date maps are still relevant and help people orient themselves to the districts and provide other relevant information. Town District Planning Principles I.District Planning Principles A. Districts Priority Classifications While the Goals and Policies of this plan generally apply to all areas of the Town, the system of dDistrict Planning Principles designations provides applies specific planning and urban design recommendations to distinct areas within the Town, stemming from. The district descriptions and principles are a result of input from the community, intent of the and landowners input, and the existing development rights. As part of the comprehensive planning effort, the Steering Committee assessed the appropriateness of the previous district boundaries and made adjustments as necessary to ensure that each district still comprised a cohesive geographic entity. Then the committee conducted an evaluation of the districts to ensure that the planning guidance and implementation recommendations of the previous plan were still current and appropriate. The next step was to assign to eEach district is assigned one of three relative priority designations – High PriorityAreas of Change, Medium Priority Intermediate Areas, orand Areas of StabilityStatic/Low Priority – based on the level of issues and/or changes confronting a particular district. The priority levels were assigned with the recognition that the Town must prioritize where and how it expends its resources to most effectively realize the community vision within this plan. As a result, the Steering Committee produced Below is a map identifying the newly established districts. and classifying each district by its priority level. The final step involved re- evaluating each district with emphasis on the high and medium priority areas in terms of the appropriateness of the district’s role and specific Planning Principles in accordance with the plan’s Vision, Future Land Use Plan, Community Framework Plan, and Goals and Policies. Attachment B Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 71 B. High Priority Districts The following districts are high priority for the Town: District 1: West Town Center District The role of the West Town Center District is to serves as the heart of the community. Social, cultural, intellectual, political, and recreational gatherings occur in this district. In addition, the district acts as the common ground between the full-time residents, part-time residents, and destination guests through diverse retail, and entertainment, and civic uses opportunities. The West Town Center District will continue as be an intensely developed mixed use, pedestrian-oriented area that serves as the primary focus for residential and lodging development within the overall Town CenterC. Currently, this district provides a diversity of land uses in vertically mixed-use buildings. Uses include retail, office, residential, government services, civic facilities, and pocket parks loosely grouped around a 50-foot pedestrian mall right-of- way. The heart of the community. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 72 Planning Principles:  Create a new “Main Street” in the existing pedestrian mall right-of-way.  Realign West Benchmark Road to improve circulation in the area and enhance the development feasibility of vacant parcels.  Link pedestrian, bicycle, and automobile circulation to and through Avon’s Town Center, Nottingham Park, the Confluence Riverfrontsite, and the Eagle Valley Trail River.  Develop Enhance the use of thea multi-modal transit center.  Develop a parking structure associated with the expansion of Avon’s the Avon Recreation Center.  Develop a mix of uses that provides a strong residential and lodging bed base supported by community and guest commercial uses.  Create inviting storefronts with retail, restaurant, and entertainment uses on ground levels and offices, lodging, and residential uses above.  Establish public plazas and other gathering spaces for community interaction and social events.  Provide entertainment opportunities for residents and guests to enliven the area and promoted and extended retail hours.  Use signage, streetscape design, landscaping, points of interest, and other wayfinding elements to help orient visitors to important destinations within the district and the larger Town Center.  Use architectural detailing on ground level/first floor to enhance the pedestrian environment that includes a human scale, display windows, appropriate lighting, and other pedestrian amenities. Encourage architectural detailing on ground level/first floor that includes a human scale, display windows, appropriate lighting, and other pedestrian amenities.   Site buildings of various sizes along the street edge to maximize sun exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 73  Develop a new transit center andEnhance private/public structured parking facilities that to provide easy access to and through the district.  Development and area improvements should adhere to the planning principles outlined in the West Town Center District Plan, and the Tract G Master Plan. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 74 District 2: East Town Center District The East Town Center District is a key revitalization prospect area for the community. Significant redevelopment opportunities exist in the district, and must should be considered comprehensively with concern for the needs and desires of the community. This district also abuts the Village at Avon and its associated future development. Strong pedestrian and street connections should be established so that these districts create a consistent and cohesive community core. The size of the parcels provides an opportunity for a variety of redevelopment opportunities. The challenge of enticing people out of their car to experience Town Center will be to overcome the confusing street patterns, indirect pedestrian walkways, and diminished sight corridors, and. to entice people out of their car to experience the entire Town Center. A mix of uses, including major retail establishments, smaller retail shops, personal services, offices, and supporting residential/lodging uses will be essential for the district. A key revitalization prospect. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 75 Planning Principles:  Develop a mix of commercial uses with supporting residential/lodging development.  Implement an intuitive street pattern that functionally links extends “Main Street” across Avon Road.  Plan for public plazas and other community gathering places.  Develop Facilitate structured parking facilities to make parking less obtrusive. to the pedestrian.  Accommodate anchor retailers without large expanses of parking to ensure these uses are integrated into a unifying framework. Encourage shared parking structures and parking districts to accommodate retail without large expanses of parking.  Create Define a cohesive and quality set of design principles physical framework and community image (compatible building orientation, scale, massing, sitting, street alignments, streetscape furnishings, signage, lighting, etc.) between the Town Center Districts and the Village at Avon.  Use Encourage architectural detailing on ground level/first floor to enhance the pedestrian environment that includes a human scale, display windows, appropriate lighting, and other pedestrian amenities.  Site buildings of varying sizes along the street to maximize sun exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk.  Ensure Encourage convenient pedestrian and auto access to the entire Town Center.  Development and area improvements should adhere to the planning principles outlined in the East Town Center District Plan. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 76 District 3: Confluence Riverfront District The Confluence Riverfront District is the essential community connector. Not only a place where a river and creek converge, the Confluence District represents one whereand roads, the railroad, regional trailEagle Valley Trail, and future lift gondola connection brings the community together and vitalizes the Town Center. The intent of the district serves as is to facilitate an extension of the Town Center with a significant residential/ lodging component, limited supporting commercial and services uses, and direct transit connection access to Beaver Creek Village, and create a connection with the Eagle River. The district is still contains lots comprised largely of undeveloped land., with the exception of the wastewater treatment facility and employee housing. The district has direct access to the railroad right-of-way, the Eagle River, and Avon Road. The pPlanning and development of this district must incorporate these three key assets. The essential community connector. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 77 Planning Principles:  Recognize the Confluence Riverfront District as the most valuable property in Town limits and should to be developed at its most optimal level.  Develop a mix of uses consisting of bed-base development and supporting commercial development.  Create a vibrant mix of uses and creative use of recreation and open space to allow a unique river experience.  Develop a lift connection linking the Confluence to Beaver Creek Landing.  Design architecture to be significant from all sides (no front or back), maximize solar exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk.  Parking areas, trash containers, and loading or service areas should be screened and/or buffered from the river corridor, Benchmark Road and from U.S. Highway 6 to minimize impacts on the river corridor.  Create a seamless vehicular and pedestrian connection to the Town Center.  Preserve and enhance public access to the existing linear park along the riverbank. Connections from this path to both the Town Center and Nottingham Park must be created in an ecologically sensitive manner as a key natural amenity.  Encourage preservation of trees in wetland areas. Encourage development efforts to minimize the loss of trees and impact to the riparian area while still achieving the urban design goals of this section.  Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts. Use signage, streetscape design, building forms, landscaping, points of interest, and other wayfinding elements to help orient visitors to important destinations within the district and the Town Center area.  Provide for transit facilities between the Town Center and the Confluence Riverfront in anticipation of a passenger train on the railroad ROW.  Plan for public plazas and other gathering spaces for community interaction, social interaction, and special events. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 78  Develop a whitewater park to broaden the spectrum of recreational opportunities in Town. District 4: Avon Road Corridor The Avon Road District’s role as a is the showcase for the best of Avon is derived from the part it plays in the experience of the community. Being the major connection between I-70 and Beaver Creek Resort, Avon Road is the first (and occasionally only) area many people see in the community. It is important that theis generally vehicular experience is significant enough to pique the interest of the vehicle’s occupants by getting them out of their cars and into to visit the Town Center. The artwork and immaculate landscaping helps this cause, but and the surrounding architecture and streetscapeing must also be affecting. Avon Road is the most traveled road in Avon, providing direct A showcase for the best of Avon. Comment [DM1]: Moved to District 27, Nottingham Station Comment [DM2]: Intermediate or stable Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 79 access to Avon’s Town Center, I-70, U.S. Highway 6, and the Beaver Creek and Bachelor Gulch base areas. In 1997, the Town completed a major improvement of Avon Road that replaced all five signalized intersections with roundabouts and significant streetscape enhancements. Though these improvements are widely recognized for reducing congestion, two significant challenges remain. First, tthe ease and speed at which vehicles traveling through Avon’s Town Center area between the I-70 interchange and the entrance to Beaver Creek is such that travelers are not enticed to venture into the Town Center’s major mixed-use districts; and. The second issue is that Avon Road is a barrier for pedestrians attempting to walk between East and West Town Center Districts. Planning Principles:  Extend Town Center urban design principles to Integrate Avon Road into the Town Center development by incorporating wayfinding, pedestrian planning, and other streetscape enhancements to ensure that Avon Road provides a sense of arrival to Avon.the Town Center.  Site buildings of various sizes along the street edge to maximize sun exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk.  Reconfigure key parcels and/or redevelop older, underutilized buildings adjacent to Avon Road to fulfill the purpose of the district as a showcase and to make them compatible with existing and future development in the West Town Center District.  Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts. Use signage, streetscape design, landscaping, points of interest, and other wayfinding elements to help orient visitors and lead them toward important destinations within the district and the Town Center.  Create stronger pedestrian connections across Avon Road to fully integrate the Town Center and link the East and West Town Center Districts.  Limit building heights fronting Avon Road to existing heights to avoid a canyon effect and to preserve Beaver Creek views.  Continue and expand the use of Avon Road (and surrounding Town Center Districts) as a gallery for sculptural art. Town District Planning Principles High Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 80  Pursue the Blue Zones recommendation of “right-sizing” Avon Road through studying available options. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 81 C. Medium Priority Intermediate Areas Districts The following Districts are deemed to present a medium priority for the Town. District 5: Nottingham Park District The Nottingham Park District is Avon’s cultural, civic, and recreational hub. Included in this district are Harry A. Nottingham Park, the municipal office complex, fire department, library, elementary school, and the Town’s recreation center. The district functions as the center for community activities, such as the Town’s Fourth Salute to Americaof July celebration and various athletic tournaments. Good pedestrian circulation between the municipal center, the park, the Town Center, and adjacent residential uses exist, but will need to be enhanced to respond to key future developments in the West Town Center District and the Confluence Riverfront District. Views and access into and from the Nottingham Park are key components to the District.Avon’s image and identity. Cultural, civic, and recreational hub. Comment [DM3]: Area of Change Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 82 Planning Principles:  Strengthen this area as a cultural and recreational center by including amenities such as athe Pperformanceing arts Ppavilion, through programming and improved supporting facilities. maintaining flexible space for temporary concession facilities, and providing a western anchor to the future “Main Street”.  Create private, comfortable spaces along Buck Creek for passive activities as an alternative to the play fields and other enhance the playground with more active space.s available within the rest of Nottingham Park.  Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts.Use signage, streetscape design, landscaping, points of interest, artwork, and other wayfinding elements to help orient visitors to the district’s various functions, the cultural and civic activity center, and toward important destinations within the Town Center area.  Realign Benchmark Road perpendicular with the future “Main Street” per the Avon Town Center Plan and enhance the pedestrian connections between the municipal center and the park.  Preserve view corridors to Beaver Creek and the new “Main Street” in the West Town Center District.  Implement use and design principles from the 2017 Tract G planning effort’s recommendations. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 83 District 6: U.S. Highway 6 Gateway Corridor The U.S. Highway 6 Gateway Corridor is the main entrance to the community and identifies Avon’s image. The area is characterized by: (1) the flat areas presently used for ski area parking, and high visibility from U.S. Highway 6; (2) the primary access to Beaver Creek; and (3) the Folsom/White property (The Gates Development) located on the south side of U.S. Highway 6. The undeveloped parcels currently serving as parking areas and other accessory uses for the Beaver Creek ski area present an important influence on development within the Town. Although these parcels are outside of Avon’s municipal boundaries, the Town should be consulted on any proposed development on these parcels. This intersection of U.S. Highway 6 and Avon Road is a major gateway to the Town. As part of the Town’s roundabout improvement project, this intersection was converted to a full roundabout with attractive landscaping and monumentation identifying both the Town and Beaver Creek. This corridor area also includes the Nottingham Station commercial area at the intersection of Hurd Lane and Avon Road. A pedestrian link is needed to connect this commercial area to the East Town Center District and the Confluence Riverfront District. The Folsom/White property is intended to provide residential/lodging uses with supporting commercial and service uses at a scale appropriate to buildable area. The area is somewhat isolated from other development within Avon due to The southern community gateway. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 84 its location on the south side of U.S. Highway 6. The area is characterized by steep terrain, with limited buildable areas directly adjacent to U.S. Highway 6. Planning Principles:  Enhance the U.S. Highway 6 right-of-way as a landscaped boulevard/parkway to provide a sense of arrival and departure for those traveling to and from Avon and to strengthen Avon’s overall community image and identity.  Limit development of south side of U.S. Highway 6 to guest service facilities near the Village Road intersection and to neighborhood supporting commercial near the Prater Lane intersection.  Strengthen the association between the Town and Beaver Creek through compatible urban design elements. streetscape elements, efficient access, and cooperative visitor information center.  Encourage screening of ski area parking areas and other accessory uses.  Create strong pedestrian connections to the Confluence Riverfront and the East Town Center Districts.  Site buildings of various sizes (but smaller than those found in the West Town Center District) to maximize sun exposure, protect views, break up building bulk, and prevent a canyon effect on Highway 6.  Minimize cut areas and preserve areas of steep slopes. Buildings should be built into the hillside and stepped up with rising topography to reduce their dominance above U.S. Highway 6.  Address access and parking at Nottingham Station.  Ensure that vehicular access points align with existing roads and create clean intersections.  Consider buildable area when determining an appropriate scale and density for development.  Encourage shared access when appropriate.  Enhance Preserve river access to the future whitewater park. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 85 District 7: Village at Avon West District The Village at Avon Village West District will be is a pedestrian-oriented mixed-use extension of the Town Center Districts with commercial, residential, lodging, educational, and cultural/recreational uses including an ice-skating/events center. The site is characterized by good visibility from I-70, gentle topography, and proximity to the East Town Center District. In order Tto create a unified and cohesive framework and community image, building and site development elements as well as public design elements such as street alignments, streetscape furnishings, signage, and lighting must be coordinated between the Village at Avon developer and the Town. A pedestrian- oriented urban village. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 86 Planning Principles:  Create strong auto, bicycle, and pedestrian connections to the East Town Center District via both East Beaver Creek Boulevard and Chapel Place.  Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts.Create a unified and cohesive physical framework and community image (compatible building orientation, scale, massing, street alignments, streetscape furnishings, signage, lighting, etc.) between the Village at Avon West District and the East Town Center District.  Site buildings of various sizes (but Buildings should be smaller than those found in the West Town Center District) to and maximize sun exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk.  Avoid large single-use buildings set back from the street edge that are surrounded by expanses of parking.  Create inviting storefronts, public plazas, green spaces, water features, streetscapes, sidewalks, and other gathering spaces for public interaction.  Encourage architectural detailing on ground level/first floor that includes a human scale, display windows, canopies, overhangs, sloped roofs, appropriate lighting, and other pedestrian amenities. Provide architecturally interesting detailing on ground level/first floor with elements such as canopies, overhangs, and sloped roofs.  Provide well-lit, pleasant pedestrian access from underground parking structures to the public street, paths and buildings.  Encourage retail and restaurant uses on ground levels with offices, lodging, and residential above.  Encourage shared parking structures and parking districts to accommodate vehicles without large expanses of parking.Utilize joint private/public structured parking facilities.  Provide well-lit, pleasant pedestrian access from underground parking structures to the public street, paths and buildings.  Buffer schools from commercial uses by surrounding them with residential development or open space. Comment [DM4]: Is this possible under the PUD or current zoning? Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 87  Encourage the design of Beaver Creek Boulevard to include a planted median. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 88 District 8: Village at Avon East District The Village at Avon East District is the a regional’s commercial center. It is intended to provides the Village at Avon West District with supporting commercial development and regional commercial uses associated with the I-70 and Post Boulevard interchange. The site is characterized by gently sloping topography along the valley floor with steeper slopes rising up to I-70. Planning Principles:  Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts Create a unified and cohesive physical framework and community image (compatible building orientation, scale, massing, street alignments, streetscape furnishings, signage, lighting, etc.) between the Village at Avon West District and the rest of the Town.  Site buildings of various sizes (but smaller than those found in the West Town Center District) to maximize sun exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk.  Create a strong overall pedestrian-orientation with tree lined streets and walking paths.  Screen large regional commercial uses from I-70 with trees and berms. The region’s commercial center. Comment [DM5]: Area of Stability Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 89 Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 90 District 9: Village at Avon North Gateway District The Village at Avon North Gateway District is primarily a high- quality residential neighborhood. It is intended to provide for residential development and a large community park. The northern frontage road through this district will provide an important east-west connector on the north side of I-70 linking Post Boulevard and Avon Road and connecting Buffalo Ridge to the rest of the Town. The district is highly visible from I-70 and thus presents a strong influence on Avon’s identity. Additionally, tThe area will serve as the gateway to the Village at Avon Northern Residential District. While Buffalo Ridge residential area is relatively isolated from other community commercial and service areas, efforts must be made to integrate it into the vitality of the Town. The elevated topography on either side of I-70 offers the possibility to construct a pedestrian overpass that would directly link this area with the Village at Avon East and West Districts and thereby the rest of the town. The school use currently approved for the district may be more appropriate elsewhere in the Village at Avon Planned Unit Develop. This will be evaluated as amendment proposal are brought forward for review. Planning Principles:  Site buildings to maximize sun exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk.  Protect view corridors, ridgelines, U.S. Forest Service lands, and steep slopes from development.  Encourage quality architecture to provide a positive gateway experience to the community.  Provide east-west pedestrian and bicycle routes.  Encourage additional informal landscaping of properties to soften the visual impact of the structures.  Ensure that any neighborhood commercial uses are truly intended to service the neighborhood.  Create connections through the park and residential uses to the USFS lands surrounding the district. High-quality residential neighborhood. Comment [DM6]: Area of Stability Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 91  Include bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure in development.  Explore the addition of trailhead facilities connecting to the East Avon Preserve and Forest Service lands.  Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 92 District 10: Village at Avon Northeast The Village at Avon Northeast is the Town’s eastern gateway as it is highly visible from the I-70 corridor. It is currently zoned for regionally oriented commercial, residential, and service- oriented uses and activities, however, the ultimate vision of the site is to protect it as open space. The area is relatively flat located at the base of steeply sloping hillsides. There is limited access to the site; therefore, it is important to consider moving entitlements to a more appropriate location within the Village at Avon Planned Unit Development. Planning Principles:  Explore ways of preserving all or part of the site for open space or park.  Consider view of the site from I-70 when developing, and ensure that the site represents a suitable gateway to the Town.  Identify and preserve significant cultural/heritage resources present on site and important views.  Maximize orientation to the river to provide connections and a potential riverfront park.  Prioritize Allow access to site from U.S. Highway 6 only instead ofover a frontage road. The Town’s eastern gateway. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 93 District 11: Metcalf Road District The Metcalf Road District is the Town’s only industrial center. It provides light industrial and commercial service uses as well as accessoryand dense residential development. During any redevelopment effort, long-term issues such as parking and access should be addressed. Existing light industrial uses on Nottingham and Metcalf Roads are intensely developed, with large buildings on small sites; generally with insufficient landscaping; inadequate access; and unscreened parking, storage, and trash containers. The area’s high visibility from I-70 makes it important to the Town’s image. Concerns over traffic safety issues as well as the area’s generally poor aesthetic characteristics are perceived as negatively affecting the image of the Wildridge and Wildwood residential developments located nearby. Yet, it is also recognized that tThese businesses provide an important component to Avon’s overall economic health. Opportunities should be encouraged to develop live/work developments that allow for light manufacture/industrial uses that do not possess significant conflicts with other surrounding land uses. The town’s industrial center. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 94 Planning Principles:  Accommodate limited/accessory residential development that supports primary industrial/employment land uses.  Develop a pedestrian connection linking West Beaver Creek Boulevard to Nottingham Road.  Coordinate with CDOT to introduce trees on uphill slopes in the I-70 right-of-way and along Metcalf Road to partially screen buildings and other accessory uses.  Require development that Mminimizes significant re- grading, and provides for proper on-site parking and access.  Require development and Eencourage existing development to add architectural or landscape screening of storage areas, HVAC equipment, loading docks, and trash containers.  Site buildings to maximize sun exposure, protect views, and break up building bulk.  In the event of a major redevelopment of this area, add traffic lanes on Metcalf Road to accommodate truck traffic. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 95 District 12: Railroad Corridor The railroad corridor runs the length of Avon along the Eagle River and represents the Town’s greatest transit opportunity. Currently the railroad is not being used for rail traffic, leaving the corridor effectively vacant. Regional transportation agencies/coalitions have made efforts to acquire the right-of-way in whole or in part in order to develop a regional transit and/or trails system. The I-70 Programmatic Environmental Impact Statement and the Intermountain Connection Capital Investment Plan bothPast studies indicate the corridor’s potential has merit as a mass transit and trail corridor. The right-of-way corridor represents an important opportunity for Avon and its preservation and enhancement is recommended. The presence of the railroad tracks through Town creates a substantial north-south barrier through much of Avon. The Town has been successful in securing rights to construct at-grade crossings for West Beaver Creek Boulevard and two access points into the ConfluenceRiverfront. Recent approvals seem to indicate an increased willingness on the part of the Union Pacific to allow such crossings. The rail corridor should be visually integrated into the Town. It should be considered a transportation corridor that is an integral component of Avon’s overall structure and character. The Town’s greatest transit opportunity. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 96 Planning Principles:  Ensure that the railroad right-of-way is preserved for future transit, trail or other transportation related endeavors.  Erase the railroad as a barrier to circulation in the community.  Develop additional at-grade and above grade crossing to better connect the Confluence District and the Nottingham Station commercialall areas to the Town Center’s mixed-use lodging and commercial areas. Ensure that essential crossings are permanent even if at-grade crossing rights are terminated in the future.  Work with Union Pacific to maintain railroad corridor, including mowing and weed mitigation.  Purchase or lease the railroad right-of-way when available. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 97 District 13: Nottingham Road Commercial District This area’s proximity to the I-70/Avon Road Interchange establishes its importance to the Town’s identity. The addition of a medical facility and the joint Police Fire facility reflects the strategic location of the area. Development and redevelopment that occurs here should reflect the standards in the Town Center, but should not compete with the Town Center in terms of size of buildings or intensity of development. Planning Principles:  Limit access points on Nottingham Road to simplify traffic movements.  Require landscape setbacks and internal landscaping of parking lots.  Screen all equipment and storage areas from view.  Limit building heights and setbacks to that which is compatible with the existing surrounding development.  Development intensity and activity should diminish when traveling north on Buck Creek Road.  Lot 1B, Buck Creek is designated for a public facilities use A secondary commercial district. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 98 for the planned construction of joint public safety facility including a regional fire station and police station, which facility will require direct ingress and egress access on Swift Gulch to enhance emergency response time.  Allow a building height of up to 60’ on Lot 1B, Buck Creek (zoned Public Facility), for a joint public safety facility, and allow scale and proportion in response to adjacent medical office building height and scale. Districts 14, and 15,16,17, and 18: Northern Hillside Open Space The Northern Hillside Open Space areas are comprised of the steep slopes of the valley wall north of I-70. The Metcalf Road District splits the district in half. These areas are protected from development with some limited informal recreational uses allowed. No further recommendations are made herein. Planning Principles:  Support and cooperate in efforts to bury power lines. District 16, 17, and 18: U.S. Forest Service Parcels Avon’s key open spaces are comprised of the steep slopes of the valley wall north of I-70. The West Avon Preserve (included in District 14) includes 11 miles of trails added in 2015, and the East Avon Preserve (District 17) is planned to include trails. Open space adjacent to town (Districts 16 and 18) isThree parcels owned by the U.S. Forest. Service are the Town’s key open space. Although outside the Town boundary, these parcels are important to maintaining the desired character of Avon and to directing for development to be consistent withto the overall land use plan. The parcels meet U.S. Forest Service criteria for exchange to eliminate irregular boundaries or awkward configurations. Loss of any of these parcels to private ownership and development would eliminate valuable visual and physical buffers between and among developed areas of Town and would deprive our citizens of prized open space and natural habitats. Planning Principles:  Maintain these districts as open space with continuing U.S. Forest Service ownership of the districts by collaborating with the agency to improve, utilize, and maintain them as low-impact publicly accessible regions. Pursue Town acquisition of these parcels for dedicated open space by working with the local and national land conservation The Town’s key open space. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 99 organizations.   Use these partnerships to eEstablish the public’sAvon’s values and desires with the U.S. Forest Service so that land swaps are unlikely to occur without approval from the Town.  Vigorously oppose any and all other possible disposition or degradation of the parcels by the U.S. Forest Service. Pursue Town acquisition of these parcels for dedicated open space by working with the local and national land conservation organizations.  Support and cooperate in efforts to bury power lines.  D. Low Priority DistrictsAreas of Stability District 19: West Residential District The West Residential District is the western gateway to Town. Presently, the west residential district consists of the Aspens Mobile Home Park. In recent years, improvements to landscape treatments, fences, and general clean up have resulted in the area presenting itself as a vital, local’s neighborhood. The area has the potential to be redeveloped over time as a higher density, master-planned, economically diverse residential area to include primarily attainable local housing. This could be considered in the long-term future of Avon when residential developments in the area reach capacity, and alternative solutions for housing are being sought. Those solutions should include pocket parks and enhanced pedestrian connectivity. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 100 Planning Principles:  Coordinate with CDOT to introduce low landforms and plantings (trees and shrubs) along the southern I-70 right-of- way to buffer the mobile home park from the interstate and light industrial uses across the interstate. In addition, the view from I-70 to the mobile home park will be screened while preserving views to the Town Center.  Encourage continued improvements to the visual quality of the area.  Limit building heights to a level subordinate to the Town Center and preserve views to the Town Center through the strategic placement of open space or the further limitation of building heights.  Encourage the construction of pocket parks and sidewalks to service the residential development in the area.  Extend Town Center urban design principles to provide consistency between districts.  District 20: River Residential District The River Residential District is a major local’s residential area. Much of the river residential district has been developed, but and future residential development that will occur along the river beyond the boundaries shown on the Urban Design Plan should be developed in accordance with the recommendations for this District. The major design influences are U.S. Highway 6, the riparian environment along the Eagle River, and public access to the river. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 101 Planning Principles:  Encourage redevelopment to take into consideration the objectives of the Eagle River Watershed Management Plan including river setbacks and best practices for development in proximity to the river.  Provide a public access easement, where appropriate, within building setback areas in development adjacent to the Eagle River for public enjoyment of the river and construction preservation of the Eagle Valley Trail.a public recreational trail.  Provide public parking and signage at strategically located trailheads.  Encourage the further connection and enhancement of the ECO Eagle Valley Trail.  Orient buildings to capitalize upon the Eagle River as an amenity. Parking areas, trash containers, and other uses that could potentially disrupt the quality of the river environment should be located away from the river and designed to have the least impact on the river corridor.  Limit building height to a scale that is subordinate to the Town Center and compatible with the river environment.  Use sensitive site planning, architectural detailing, articulation, and appropriate setbacks, color, and scale of structure to preserve the character of the river and its associated natural habitat.  Plant indigenous trees and shrubs to screen existing large residential buildings along U.S. Highway 6 and provide landforms and landscaping between residences and U.S. Highway 6.  Enhance the pedestrian experience by adding sidewalks along all roads on the valley floor. District 21: Nottingham Park Residential District Nottingham Park is bordered to the west, north, and northeast by existing high quality residential development. Provisions for pedestrians and bicyclists along West Beaver Creek Boulevard and adequate screening of parking and trash areas would help enhance the character of the area. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 102 Planning Principles:  Encourage existing development and require encourage redevelopment to screen parking and trash areas with landscaping material.  Site buildings of varying sizes along the street to maximize sun exposure, protect views, be compatible with existing surrounding development, and break up building bulk. District 22: Nottingham Road District This district is characterized by limited developable area due to steep slopes to the north, frontage on Nottingham Road, which is classified as a commercial collector road, and high exposure to I- 70. Existing residential development is typically multi-family buildings. Planning Principles:  Encourage additional informal landscaping to soften the visual impact of large existing structures.  Reseed exposed slopes with native grasses and wild flowers.  Require development to provide a landscape buffer adjacent to Nottingham Road and I-70.  Encourage high quality redevelopment consistent with the land use regulations.  Provide directEnhance access to existing trails and further link existing pedestrian infrastructure.  Improve signage for trailheads. District 23: I-70 Gateway The interchange on I-70 at Avon Road is the main gateway to the Town. As such, this should reflect the character and quality of the community and create a sense of arrival. Currently, a lighted gateway sign is placed along the west bound off ramp to Avon. However, tThe gateway approach should continue to be improved needs to be redesigned to enhance the overall image of the community including but not limited to through enhancing the pedestrian experience, lighting, road and right of way materials, enhanced view corridors, and signage. The emphasis should be on the creation of a positive entry experience that extends the character of the Town Center to Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 103 Avon’s front door. Planning Principles:  Enhance the intersections at the on/off ramps on Avon Road to include streetscape improvements and special landscape features.  Maintain the cottonwood trees that contribute to the gateway experience.  Improve the I-70 interchange for pedestrians and bikers. District 24: Wildridge Residential District This area consists of a residential subdivision containing varying densities, located on the sunny, south-facing slopes north of the main valley floor. The character for the developed landscape should reflect the area’s dry climate and typically steep terrain with low water-requiring plant materials and natural landscaping. Due to the limited amount of existing trees and shrubs and the open character of the property, special care should be taken to ensure that all structures are compatible with one another and in harmony with the natural surroundings. Planning Principles:  Redesign the intersection of Metcalf and Nottingham Roads, and implement the other recommendations for District 4 to enhance the entry to Wildridge and provide more direct access from the Town Center to Wildridge.  Construct bicycle lanes along Metcalf and Wildridge Roads.  Promote a trail system through open space areas in Wildridge to provide alternatives to the roadways for pedestrian circulation and greater connection to the surrounding open space.  Preserve and enhance the existing open space trails and explore the possibility of developing additional parcels into pocket parks.  Acquire and maintain as public open space the U.S. Forest Service-owned parcel adjacent to Wildridge that includes Beaver Creek Point.  Add an alternative or second access route to Wildridge (perhaps forest service road during the spring and summer). Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 104  Identify and delineate all open space parcels and public trails.  Site buildings of varying sizes along the street to maximize sun exposure, protect views, be compatible with existing surrounding development, and break up building bulk. District 25: Mountain Star Residential District This area is a planned unit development established in 1992, of large-lot, single-family homes, located east of Wildridge on the south-facing slopes north of the main valley floor. This covenant-controlled, gated community has its own design review committee. Planning Principles:  Prohibit significant alteration of natural environment and minimize stress on wildlife and loss of habitat.  Consider the development of a trailhead to access the surrounding public lands. District 26: Swift Gulch District The Town of Avon’s Public Works and Transportation Departments are located in the Swift Gulch District. In response to the area’s high visibility from I-70, efforts have been made to screen the existing buildings and facilities and ensure that they blend into the surrounding environment. Planning Principles:  Encourage building at a scale that minimizes visibility from I-70.  Screen accessory uses with landforms and landscaping, while allowing Building Heights up to 60’ along with scale and proportion in response to regional operations and facilities increasing the site development potential.  Encourage sidewalks and pedestrian connections.  Incorporate housing where appropriate. District 27: Nottingham Station/Eaglebend District The Nottingham Station/Eaglebend District contains single- family and multi-family residential development. The area is mostly developed, with a few remaining individual residential Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 105 lots still undeveloped. Design issues for development in this area are to address visibility from U.S. Highway 6, the protection and enhancement of the riparian environment along the Eagle River, and appropriate public access along the river. Planning Principles:  Examine the potential to develop pedestrian and bicycle connections between Stonebridge Drive and the Village at Avon Residential and Commercial Districts.  Encourage development to take into consideration the objectives of the Eagle River Watershed Management Plan objectives, including river setbacks and best practices for development in proximity to the river, into consideration.  Provide a public access easement, where appropriate, within building setback areas in development adjacent to the Eagle River for public enjoyment of the river and preservation of the Eagle Valley Trail.  Provide a public access easement, where appropriate, within building setback areas in development adjacent to the Eagle River for public enjoyment of the river and construction of a public recreational trail.  Encourage the further connection, enhancement, and visibility of the Eagle Valley Trail and the Whitewater Park.  Building should be oriented to capitalize upon the Eagle River as an amenity. Parking areas, trash containers, and other uses that could potentially disrupt the quality of the river environment should be located away from the river and designed to have the least impact on the river corridor. Set buildings back from the river to preserve its natural character, and step building facades back away from the river to avoid creating a ‘canyon effect’.  Limit building height to a scale that is subordinate to the Town Center and compatible with the existing development and river environment. Buildings should be designed to step down in height as they near the river and in response to the natural topography.  Encourage landforms, landscaping, and sidewalks between residences and U.S. Highway 6. Town District Planning Principles Low Priority Districts Town of Avon Comprehensive Plan Page 106 District 28: Village at Avon Northern Residential District This area is part of the Village at Avon P.U.D. ofplanned to become quality, large-lot, single-family homes and some multi- family residential development located on the south-facing slopes north of the main valley floor. This residential area is covenant-controlled, gated community with its own design review committee. This residential area has several provisions for public services and access ways that should be maintained. Further public access arrangements would be beneficial, including the preservation and/ acquisition of public space located adjacent to this area. Planning Principles:  Encourage further public access arrangements including the preservation/ acquisition of public space located adjacent to this area.  Encourage sidewalks and pedestrian connections.  Prevent significant alteration of natural landscape as well as ridgeline and steep slope development. This area should be highly sensitive to visual impacts of improvements, wildlife, and lighting. Page 1 To: Planning and Zoning Commission From: David McWilliams, Town Planner Meeting Date: January 17, 2017 Topic: Notice Procedure for Development Review Introduction PZC recently asked Staff to illustrate the different public noticing procedures for different Development Review types. Language from Code Section 7.16.020(d) is found below, with an underlined section representing the most relevant sentence. Staff’s response is further down, as an amended Table 7.16-1 with additional columns pertaining to the noticing procedure and the type of Development Review. To aid in applicant transparency, Staff proposes the immediate integration of the column titled “ Notice” of Table 7.16-1 to the current code text amendment process happening now. In the PUD section are highlighted typographical errors. One Procedure was placed in the incorrect column, and “appeal” and “annexation” were switched due to their positions in the AMC. This amendment will also be included in the current amendment process. Any introduction of new public noticing procedures will require a more collaborative approach between Staff, the PZC, and Town Council. A Town Council meeting with the Planning and Zoning Commission is tentatively scheduled for March, and may include this topic as a discussion point if deemed necessary by the Commission. 7.16.020(d) Notice Notice shall be required for all public hearings conducted by the Planning and Zoning Commission and Town Council. (1)Published and Posted Notice. Notice shall be published in a newspaper of general circulation within the Town and posted in the designated official places of posting by the Town at least eleven (11) days prior to the hearing date. (2) Mailed Notice. For procedures that require mailed notice, notice shall be sent by first-class mail to all real property owners within three hundred (300) feet of the property which is the subject of a development application, as measured from the boundary of the property. If a property within three hundred (300) feet that requires notification is a condominium project, notice may be mailed to the managing agent, registered agent or any member of the board of directors of the project. Mailed notice shall be postmarked at least eleven (11) days prior to the meeting. Mailed notice shall be sent by the Town at the applicant's expense. The Eagle County Assessor's records may be used to determine the addresses of real property owners. The Town shall include a certificate of mailing in the public record. Page 2 Mailed notice shall be required for annexation, major subdivision, planned unit development, special review use, rezoning, right-of-way vacation, variance and vested property right applications. Table 7.16-1 Development Review Procedures and Review Authority R = Review/Recommendations H = Public Hearing D = Decision A = Appeal Procedure Director PZC TC Notice Potential Outcome Rezoning (§7.16.050) R H-R H-D Mailed, Published Change in use, density, etc. Planned Unit Development (§7.16.060) Administrative PUD D A None, unless Published on appeal Correction of errors that don’t change size Minor PUD Amendment R H-R H-D Mailed, Published No change in density, non- residential land use, mass or scale, character of development, or open space Lot Split PUD Amendment for Wildridge PUD R H-R H-D Mailed, Published WR lot split Major PUD Amendment R H-R H-D Mailed, Published change in density, non-residential land use, mass or scale, character of development, or open space Preliminary PUD R H-R H-D Mailed, Published change in density, non-residential land use, mass or scale, character of development, or open space Final PUD R H-R H-D Mailed, Published change in density, non-residential land use, mass or scale, character of development, or open space Subdivision (§7.16.070) Administrative Subdivision D A None, unless Published on appeal Correcting survey errors, adjust lines by 2 feet or less Page 3 Minor Subdivision R H-D Published Create less than 4 separate parcels of land, no public improvements, consolidation of 2 or more lots, move lot lines by more than 2 feet Preliminary Plan R H-R H-D Mailed, Published Create 4 or more parcels, or public improvements Final Plan R H-D Mailed, Published Create 4 or more parcels, or public improvements Development Plan (§7.16.080) Minor D or R H-D A None Construction 600 sf or less, screen wall, landscape, deck, mechanical equipment, exterior, approved development plan 10% modifications, Major R H-D A Published All Building Construction over 600 sf Major in Town Core R H-R H-D Published All Building Construction over 600 sf in TC Design Review (§7.16.090) D or R H-R or H-D H-D or A None, or Published with Hearing Supplemental review of design standards Special Review Use (§7.16.100) R H-D A Mailed, Published Review of unique or unusual site development features Variance (§7.16.110) R H-D A Mailed, Published Prevention or lessening of practical difficulties and unnecessary hardships inconsistent with the objectives of Development Code Alternative Equivalent Compliance (§7.16.120) R R-D or R A or R- D Published (could be mailed with concurrent application) Allows development to meet the intent of the design related provisions of Development Code Page 4 Right-of-way Vacation (§7.16.130) R H-D Mailed, Published Vacation of Right of Way Vested Property Right (§7.16.040) R H-R H-D Mailed, Published Right to undertake and complete the development and use of property under the express terms and conditions of a site specific development plan Location, Character and Extent (§7.16.150) R H-D A Published Review and approval of location, character, and extent of public facilities. Appeal (§7.16.160) H-D Published Appeal of decision by Staff or judicial body Annexation (§7.36) R H-R H-D Mailed, Published Annexation of new lands 1041 Permit (§7.40) R H-R H-D Published To facilitate identification, designation and administration of matters of state interest consistent with the home rule power and authority of the Town of Avon Historic and/or Cultural Preservation Designated (§7.50) H-D Historic designations in Town 1 Planning & Zoning Commission Meeting Minutes Tuesday, January 3, 2017 I. Call to Order – 5:05pm II. Roll Call Commissioners Barnes, Howell, arrived late. Commissioner Bonidy was absent. III. Additions & Amendments to the Agenda IV. Approval of Meeting Minutes  December 20, 2016 Meeting Minutes Action: Commissioner Minervini moved to approve the meeting minutes. Commissioner Golembiewski seconded the motion and the motion passes 4-0. V. Conflicts of Interest No conflicts of interest were disclosed. VI. Sign Program Amendment – Buck Creek Medical Center – 50 Buck Creek Road File: SGN16013 Legal Description: Lot 1A, Buck Creek Applicant/Owner: Avon MOB LLC Summary: Application for a sign program amendment at the Medical Center. Commissioner Minervini motioned to approve the application with the following Findings and Conditions: Findings: 1. The MSP amendment was reviewed in accordance with §15.28.080(16), Sign Programs, and found to be in general conformance with the recommendations and requirements of the Sign Code. 2. The design of the proposed MSP amendment complies with the review criteria set forth in §15.28.070, Design Review Criteria, of the Avon Municipal Code. 3. The proposed MSP amendment is compatible with the site and provides consistent quality and aesthetics to other improvements of the Buck Creek Medical Office project. 4. The blade sign can increase the total size of the Master Sign Program due to the sign type, use, and location. Conditions: 1. All nonconforming signs that exist on site will be removed before the installation of the approved sign. 2. Any further request for Master Sign Code amendment will result in a complete review of the entire Master Sign Code by the Planning and Zoning Commission. Commissioner Barnes seconded the motion and the motion passed unanimously. VII. Major Design & Development Plan / Alternative Equivalent Compliance –5301 Ferret Lane - PUBLIC HEARING File: MJR16008 / AEC16008 Legal Description: Lot 68, Block 4, Wildridge Subdivision Applicant: George Plavec Summary: Public Hearing on a development plan for a duplex design addition to a single family house. 2 Public Comment: David Strandjord commented that this type of project should include a requirement to send a mailed notice to each homeowner within 300 feet in order to increase transparency. Action: Commissioner Barnes motioned to approve AEC 16008 with the following Findings and Conditions: Findings 1. The proposed application was reviewed pursuant to §7.16.080(f), Development Plan, §7.16.090(f), Design Review, and §7.16.120 Alternative Equivalent Compliance. 2. The first two components of the AEC result in benefits to the community that is equivalent to or better than compliance with the subject standard. 3. The first two components of the AEC impose no greater impacts on adjacent properties than would occur through compliance with the specific requirements of the Code. 4. The deviations from code in the garage and roof design results in a better overall design, thus meeting the AEC criteria. Condition 1. A revised landscape plan shall be submitted and approved by staff that brings the irrigated area into compliance with the Avon Code and shows the removal of the two cottonwoods trees to comply with the landscape component of the AEC. Commissioner Hardy seconded the motion and the motion passed unanimously. Commissioner Barnes motioned to approve MJR16008 with the following Findings: 1. The proposed application was reviewed pursuant to §7.16.080(f), Development Plan, §7.16.090(f), Design Review. 2. The design meets the development and design standards established in the Avon Development Code. 3. The design relates the development to the character of the surrounding community. 4. The design reflects the long range goals and design criteria of the Avon Comprehensive Plan. Commissioner Howell seconded the motion and the motion passed with a 5-1 vote, with Commissioner Minervini voting in opposition. VIII. Work Session – Comprehensive Plan Amendment Summary: Review of revised Goals and Policies from Section IV Goals and Policies. IX. Staff Updates Staff talked about affordable housing initiatives and the Beaver Creek Boulevard redesign process, coming before Town Council in the coming weeks. X. Adjourn Approved this 17th Day of January, 2017 SIGNED: _______________________ Jim Clancy, Chairperson PZC Findings of Fact and Record of Decision: #AEC16008 and MJR16008 Page 1 of 1 PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION FINDINGS OF FACT AND RECORD OF DECISION DATE: January 3, 2017 TYPE OF APPLICATIONS: Major Development Plan FILE NUMBERS: #AEC16008 and #MJR16008 PROPERTY LOCATION: Lot 68, Block 4 Wildridge Subdivision ADDRESS: 5301 Ferret Lane APPLICANT/ OWNER: George Plavec These findings of fact and record of decision is made in accordance with the Avon Development Code (“Development Code”) §7.16.020(f): AEC16008 DECISION: Approved with 6-0 vote. Findings 1. The proposed application was reviewed pursuant to §7.16.080(f), Development Plan, §7.16.090(f), Design Review, and §7.16.120 Alternative Equivalent Compliance. 2. The first two components of the AEC result in benefits to the community that is equivalent to or better than compliance with the subject standard. 3. The first two components of the AEC impose no greater impacts on adjacent properties than would occur through compliance with the specific requirements of the Code. 4. The deviations from code in the garage and roof design results in a better overall design, thus meeting the AEC criteria. Condition 1. A revised landscape plan shall be submitted and approved by staff that brings the irrigated area into compliance with the Avon Code and shows the removal of the two cottonwoods trees to comply with the landscape component of the AEC. MJR16008 DECISION: Approved with a 5-1 vote. Findings 1. The proposed application was reviewed pursuant to §7.16.080(f), Development Plan, §7.16.090(f), Design Review. 2. The design meets the development and design standards established in the Avon Development Code. 3. The design relates the development to the character of the surrounding community. 4. The design reflects the long range goals and design criteria of the Avon Comprehensive Plan. THESE FINDINGS OF FACT AND RECORD OF DECISION ARE HEREBY APPROVED: BY:______________________________________ DATE: ___________________ PZC Chairperson